Posted on 05/08/2024 3:59:43 AM PDT by MtnClimber
(That’s Joseph Pulitzer under Photobucket’s watermark).
I disagree in that state laws MUST conform to the guidelines of the Constitution.
State laws are not absolutely sovereign.
I think there is room to disagree on specific details on this, which is where I think we disagree. But I think overall, I would stand by my statement that state governments are not sovereign unto themselves in this Republic .
P
1. FEDERAL courts have no business enforcing STATE election laws. This is a clear jurisdictional matter between federal and state governments, and there is no role for federal courts in state elections unless there are civil/voting rights issues in dispute.
2. Even if there WAS a clear, undisputed civil/voting rights issue in one or more states in 2020, any court action must be initiated by an aggrieved party. If Pennsylvania somehow violated the Civil Right Act and/or the Voting Rights Act, for example, then the affected voters in Pennsylvania would have the legal standing to file lawsuits against the state in federal court. The State of Texas, on the other hand, is not an aggrieved party in the matter. This goes directly to the “lack of standing” determination in the Texas case against other states in 2020.
3. In every disputed state in the 2020 election, the state legislature had the authority to override its own state courts in the appointment of presidential electors, if the election process violated state law. None of them did. It’s not up to the federal courts to do the job that state legislatures are unwilling to do.
4. If states have the legal standing to get federal courts to enforce the laws of other states, then the first consequence in the first federal court ruling is that all state laws must be eliminated and then replaced by a national standard that all states must meet. Trust me — that’s the LAST thing you would want.
Lord I hope Trump hires a DOJ that is twice as partisan as these Clowns!! I pray for the 3:00 am raid of Jack Smith’s Home!! The New York Crooks being Cuffed and stuffed!!!
Please post any evidence you have to support this statement.
45: - THIS.
I was starting a reply, but you hit all the points.
Republicans got caught asleep at the switch and should have had a well formed strategy before the election. Instead, we had the clown car team of R. Giuliani, S. Powell, J. Ellis, etc making claims they could not back up and taking valuable bandwidth. Add to that kook claims by Mike Lindell that he could not back up and the results expected.
2020 is over. People should stop whining about it and look to 2024.
I agree that states are not absolutely sovereign, but the language of the U.S. Constitution gives an enormous degree of plenary power to state legislatures when it comes to presidential elections.
How's that working out for you Chief "Justice" Johnnie? You've turned the United States Supreme Court into just another bureaucracy; just another branch of the federal government controlled by weaklings who are paralyzed with fear of the Democrat/Communist Party America/American-hating Left, or who sympathize and support the principles of the Democrat/Communist Party America/American-hating Left.
What a waste of a perfectly good black robe!
I understand your view on this, FRiend...:)
Do not expect a courageous acts by the nine.
“If the constitution no longer applies, then fire them. That lifetime tenure only applies if the constitution applies.”
I absolutely agree!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.