You seem to think that these two cases are identical when they are not. Different time and culture tho. Good for Arthur that civil unrest was resolved and that the issue died down enough for him to rule effectively.
How many cases were there in regards to Arthur before the Supreme Court? Are the Obama questions identical to the ones being raised against 0bama? Is everthing in the two instances identical to you?
Hey, the issue is does the President meet the qualifications of the office. In both cases, we’ve got allegations that Arthur did not and Obama does not.
And it seems, that it’s going to be, in both cases, that no one is going to come up with proof.
So, they sound the same to me on a Constitutional grounds...