Skip to comments.Remembering William Campbell (RIP: Trelayne and Koloth on Star Trek - age 84)
Posted on 04/29/2011 3:00:02 PM PDT by EveningStar
It is our sad duty at StarTrek.com to report the passing of William Campbell. The actor, beloved in Star Trek circles for his roles as Trelane in the TOS episode The Squire of Gothos and as the Klingon Koloth in the TOS episode "The Trouble with Tribbles and the DS9 episode Blood Oath, passed away in the early evening of April 28 following a long illness.
(Excerpt) Read more at startrek.com ...
“Jim, this man is a Klingon.”
RIP, Mr. Campbell.
He was Q before Q was. RIP Trelayne.
“He was Q before Q was. RIP Trelayne.”
I was going to post the same thing.
Trelayne was Q.
I read it in a ST book once.
Actually now that i think of it Gary Michell was Q i believe.
Don’t forget him in “Dementia 13”, and “The High and the Mighty.” RIP One of my favorites.
What i meant was 100 years before TNG Q was banished from the continuum and his soul/being floated around space for ages before he came across Gary Mitchell and inhabited his body.
RIP, Mister Campbell.
she weakened Mitchell long enough for Kirk to overpower him. Kirk knocked Mitchell into a hole Mitchell had prepared (ironically) as Kirk’s grave. Using a phaser, Kirk collapsed the hillside on top of Mitchell, burying him beneath tons of rock and ending his threat forever.
I love it when Kirk found the one weakness of omnipotent beings.
Remember how the grave Mitchell marked was marked “James ‘R’. Kirk”? I’m such a TOS geek. I liked Trelane because he was such a flamboyant SOB. And his mom and dad told him he couldn’t “make” any more planets. Now THAT’S power, when you can make planets.
Wow, I didn’t know that. I never got into TNG, but I did enjoy some episodes, “The Crystaline Entity” and the “Inner Light” were great. I always wondered how Picard was “sane” after living an entire lifetime in 20 minutes, having kids, grandkids, etc.
“I always wondered how Picard was sane after living an entire lifetime in 20 minutes, having kids, grandkids, etc.”
He kept trying in later episodes to master the little Recorder, or Flute, or whatever that thing was, that was given to him as a remembrance of that life.
My opinion was it softened Picard some afterward. He saw life from the side of actually being a father, and grandfather, which he would never get to experience in real life unless you count his time in the Nexus.
Add Norman in I Mudd.
I backed up and looked at that one again. You sir, have made my day.
<He was Q before Q was. RIP Trelayne.
Couldn’t have said it better myself. ST ping, my little Q.
“Inner Light”, best TNG ever.
“Inner Light” made me cry. Imagine having a wife, kids, grandkids, friends, then having that all taken away and realizing they have all been dead for 5000 years. And that they used you so that they would be remembered.
Yea, that was a good episode.
How does one go back to their normal life after living almost an entire lifetime of another person in peril in a blink of an eye?
some of my favorite episodes were Yesterdays Enterprise, The best of both worlds, Q Who, Time Squared....
Unfortunatly i belive there were far more bad episodes than good ones though.
Don’t tell anyone but i may be only one of a few that actually enjoyed Voyager and thought that despite some really good battle scenes Deep Space 9 sucked badly.
If I remember correctly, the flute didn’t actually work in reality. It was auctioned off some years ago, for a considerable sum.
I bought all 4 seasons of "Enterprise"...so there! ;^)
I liked “Yesterday’s Enterprise”. Again, I was never a fan of TNG, but they nailed it in several episodes. I don’t know the name of the episode, but there was one where Q takes Picard to the dawn of time and Picard touches a pool of water, causing ripples that changes the entire course of the universe.
I heard someone say one time that “DS9 was Days of Our Lives in Space”
I did watch, but for the most part I agree.
I liked Voyager as well. I thought the concept was sound, and I liked the relationship that developed between Janeway, and Chocotae (sp). He was absolutely her opposite on his ship, but as soon as the 2 crews combined he was fiercely loyal to her. I believe if they had stayed in the Delta Quadrant they would have ended up married.
Now i remember Trelane actually was a Q, But not our Q.
In the book our Q came across Mitchell and possesed him.
It was part of the plot of the book i read like 8 years ago, Q-Squared.
I forget 90% of it but i remember it being a big book, good read, something like 500 pages.
It was only one of around 3 ST books I’ve read but i would recommend it.
The last one i read centered around Bev Crusher. The book was a gift so i read it.
I think Enterprise is a great enjoyable series.
As with many people i did not pay much attention to it when it was in production and because of that it got cancelled.
Too bad, It really picked up in the final season.
Villains are the best roles.
That was the final episode.
Another good one.
Q saves humanity.
The thing with the ST shows is that i really liked all of the cast members minus the Crusher twins but i could not stand almost the entire cast of DS9.
I was lucky a few years ago to finally visit the Star Trek Experience at the las Vegas Hilton a few months before they shut it down.
Practically had the place to myself for a few hours.
got to walk around Picards bridge which was very cool, lot’s of props on diplay, giant ship models hanging from the ceiling etc.
Even got to drink a warp core breach with dry ice in it at quarks bar. tasty!
I went to take a picture of a Borg and the guy started ragging on my camera, He called it inferior technology.
I know Janeway had a husband/boyfriend back home, i wonder what happened with her and Chakotay.
She was mentioned as Admiral Janeway in a movie but i never heard about what happened to him.
I liked “Enterprise,” too, mowowie.
The third season was a year long series about one enemy the Xindi, and various battles against it. In fact, the third year wrapped up everything so fully anything done afterwards simply wasn't and never could be good enough.
Enterprise was very good for the first three years with most of the first two years leading to the Xindi battle and the third year focusing on various parts of that battle. Once the Xindi battle was over, there was no attraction to return each week to see the next development in the story line. The first three years were mostly focuses on the Xindi theme either in leading up to the third year or concluding that particular story 'arc' at the end of the third year.. During the first three years, there were few 'elevator episodes' to hold down costs. Indeed, one such elevator episode with Commander Tucker and Lt. Reed stuck in Shuttlepod One was truly outstanding and highly regarded for it's character acting.
The fourth season lead off with the alien Nazis and never went anywhere. It had lost it's focus and had no distinct goal. It seemed like most of the year was a bunch of unrelated episodes which were unable maintain ones interest after the conclusion of the Xindi adventures.
I was thinking about the alternate universe Tholian web episodes which i thought was great, the explaination of the change of foreheads of the Klingons and the green Orion slave girls to be pretty enjoyable.
A lot of people believe the Xindi story arc killed the show, i thought it was great fun.
The Shran episodes were good too.
Shran was a great character.
The Inner Light was my favorite episode. It was so awesome in the last scene when Riker delivered the box with the flute and he began playing. Once of the best scenes I’ve ever seen on TV.
Before Star Trek, intro showing William Campbell co-starring in a forgotten series about truck drivers. Catchy theme too.
CANNONBALL - 1958 - Paul Birch, William Campbell - Opening & Closing credits
I remember reading that had ST gone to a fourth season, Campbell’s Klingon character of Koloth was going to be featured prominently as a running foil to Kirk. Alas, was not to be. He was memorable, nonetheless. RIP.
The Xindi episode arc was pretty intersting. I couldn’t wait to see what was going to happen next. Watching Archer change from wide eyed explorer to a tough, take no prisoner, leader was excellent to watch as well.
I also enjoyed the Shran episodes.
An expanded arc on the Temporal Cold War was in the works according to the “DVD extras”. I wish they could have gotten it done in season 4.
Where’s the monkey?
Yeah, I never heard any follow up about Chakotay either, if I was writing for the show, or a movie, I would have had him take Seven of Nine back to his tribe where he teaches, and she adapts to the ways of his people. This helps her complete her path to resuming her humanity.
He is then asked to come back to Starfleet, and becomes Captain of a ship, and his main focus is traveling the galaxy meeting new indigenous cultures like his own, and sometimes having to defend them from some really bad guys.
William Campbell co-starred in one of my favorite TV shows when I was a little kid:
He was also the husband of Judith Campbell Exner, one of JFK’s mistresses.
Oops... missed your post.
Mine’s a rerun.
Enterprise was the BEST since TOS. no smarmy prime directive...lots of kickass.
any episode with Shran(you got that pink skin?).
Through a Mirror, Darkly.
and many many others.
I’d add “Shuttlepod One” and “Twilight” to that list. I enjoyed both of those as well.
This is the one you were thinking off, the lat episode of TNG:
I remember watching that show.
Thank you for the info.
Was Trelayne retconned into being a Q?
Supposedly, but if he was Q, he was clearly a child Q (but no less dangerous). Deft acting on Mr. Campbell’s part to interpret the role as a “naughty boy,” and of course being scolded for mistreating his Human “pets,” as though they were hamsters he was taunting on a wheel. His “parents” weren’t much interested in the Humans at all (might be one argument why they might not have been Q, but just another superior race from the ethereal plane of reality, for which there were quite a number of on TOS).
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.