American Idol 2012--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2012

[slugbug]

Hi Jonny!

[silent_jonny]

The Notorious Rapper P.A.B. (Patti Ann Brown

ROFL!

Consider that gif stolen :)

[MagUSNRET]

TOnights question......
How many inane attempts at “fake outs” is Ryan going to try to pull before we finally know who is voted off the island...?

[slugbug]

I agree with your “ramblings”! I think they are spot on!

[twin2]

Hi sj! Waiting with baited breath for results....not really.

Cleaning house b/c tomorrow is the post-work Friday bar-b-que at my house. Plus one of my friends is bringing his friend that has an enormous crush on me. I think I will flirt:)

I feel like it's high school.

[RummyChick]

what’s going on with Phillip not being in the Ford commercials?? This is at least the second one he hasn’t been in.

[silent_jonny]

Our doomsday bunker will be super fun! I'll bring some lemon squares.

LOL--they would be a nice change from the beans :)

[DouglasKC]

Hey question for you all: Why isn’t Phil Phillips in the Ford commercials?

[silent_jonny]

Hi, Yaelle!

[retrokitten]

Plus one of my friends is bringing his friend that has an enormous crush on me. I think I will flirt:)

Do it. I highly recommend flirting with everyone. LOL

[MagUSNRET]

Cause Fords are only for pimps and those they pimp? (just a hunch) ;-)

[CASchack]

Hi Jonny.

My ears are already tired from Joshua’s scream clips.

[peggybac]

Illness?

[silent_jonny]

Seacrest calls up Joshua.

Iovine: (first song) Good, but not great. (says the judges shouldn't have given him a standing ovation) I think I was laying down at the time. (second song) Slightly overblown, overemotional. Like putting a Ferrari on a race track and leaving it in first gear. (third song--his choice) In fairness, I gave him a song that didn't have enough melody. Joshua needs melody. I take 100% responsibility for that.

No results. Seacrest sends him back to the couch.

[peggybac]

Beatbox, HTC 1X. God, I’m old.

[silent_jonny]

Joshua Ledet has a tough road to hoe....can't decide if he wants to be compared to Obama OR to Fantasia.

True.

[CASchack]

I refuse to consider a Beatbox due to that obnoxious commercial, played again and again.

[silent_jonny]

BYOBAGM (and gas mask)

They're standard in the Doomsday Bunker :-D

[MagUSNRET]

IM just not into tonights show...gonna have to be some good snarkin to keep me awake.....along with my frequent runs to the kitchen, to avoid another evening of poor singing with gender confused male shirtless dancers with chains and leather.

[twin2]

LOL thanks:)

[peggybac]

WHO is this annoying black chick?

[silent_jonny]

I took dibs on the top bunk on SUNDAY!-—which may indeed be a tactical error ion my part...since “warm air rises” LMAO!

LOLOL!

[Netizen]

This is going ti be a very long hour.

[retrokitten]

I hate these stupid in show commercials.

[MagUSNRET]

OK.........what was up with that annoying black chick filler?????
Damn.I coulda already been in the kitchen too........

[twin2]

Cheer up, you are getting to watch a complete commercialtainment Ice Age ad.

Watch out here comes Lisa Marie. Does she serve any purpose? Really?

[MagUSNRET]

What the HELL is this???????
Elvis is turning in his grave!!!!!!!!!

[slugbug]

WHO is this annoying black chick?

I don't know but P2 seemed quite annoyed with her too! :)

[peggybac]

It’s frightening how much she looks like her daddy.

[retrokitten]

Her back up band looks like the bastard sons of Tom Petty and Jack White.

[CASchack]

It sounds as if Lisa Marie inherited her mother’s talent for singing.

[silent_jonny]

Lisa Marie Presley peforms. (clearly pre-recorded)

What a dreary nothing song. They have to dress up the stage and the band members like extras from a Tim Burton movie, just to keep it interesting.

[stylecouncilor]

Lisa Marie has tried to make her singing career happen for a long time. Now I know why it’s taking so long.

[RummyChick]

She sold a lot of the rights to her dad to people involved with American Idol.Don’t remember the details.

[kjam22]

She needs to work on her “thunk yu”....

[SilvieWaldorfMD]

Lisa Marie is on Idol simply because she’s Elvis’ daughter.

She can’t carry a melody if her life depended on it.

[silent_jonny]

I hope you took the trash out, had a work-related phone call—something to make the last five minutes worthwhile :)

[MagUSNRET]

She might be able to get gigs singing at funerals.......good grief...that was horrific!

[twin2]

LOL, like decades long!

She must have paid some big money to get this cush spot.

[retrokitten]

I was going to say something similar- if you are Elvis’ daughter and you can’t make your singing career happen- take a hint!

[stylecouncilor]

LOL!

[kjam22]

I thought the band was good... and kinda liked the vibe of the song.... hmmm

[Netizen]

It was like Morticia Adams’ daughter Tuesday sang a song.

[Shelayne]

Good evening, Jonny and Peeps!

No 3 Musketeers tonight. Boo.

Is there a real possibility we could lose that Joshua tonight? After again hearing him say he picked “Imagine” for the underlying message, I want him banished. Banished, I say!

[CASchack]

Maybe Michael Jackson advised her to sell the rights during their brief “marriage.”

[retrokitten]

You know, in another context, I may have liked it. But it seemed so out of place for AI. Sort of like when Florence and the Machine were on last season.

[silent_jonny]

A 16 year old girl singing two songs about having sex. Is this really ok for a family show?

Adding this to the inappropriate list--P2's last song, "We've Got Tonight", is about a one night stand. J-Lo said she bet all the Ferlies in the audience wished he was singing that to them.

"Does he mean a sleep-over?"

[Netizen]

instead of Rock n’ Roll it was Black n’ Droll

[silent_jonny]

Seacrest calls Jessica up.

You know the drill. A lot of recaps and talk from Iovine. She was a hit and a miss for him.

Back to the couch she goes for now.

[peggybac]

Lisa Marie is more masculine than Adam Lambert.