Skip to comments.Pink Floyd's Roger Waters says Britain should return Falklands to Argentina
Posted on 02/29/2012 7:08:40 PM PST by Olog-hai
click here to read article
Love your music, hate your air-headed politics.
Just another ale-swilling surrender monkey.
Aria, of Pacific Northwest USA, says leave what Margaret Thatcher fought for alone.
So why not...I figure I’m at least as intelligent as some rock band person.
But that said, what do the Falklands have that anyone wants?
Or is he just being imperial in a politically correct manner? It's pretty harsh to give your citizens to another country with a spotty history.
To me, Floyd was more about Gilmour and Rick Wright. I prefer Echoes over The Wall.
Yes - but what would Syd Barrett think about all this?
Petula Clark, it’s your turn to tell us!
Unfortunately the last time Roger Waters got on a kick about the Falklands we got the Final Cut and Pink Floyd broke up soon after
The lunatic is on some grass.
As if those guys pretentious pseudo-art output hadn’t done enough damage! Feh!
I love Pink Floyd’s music, but Waters has always struck me as one of those “artiste” types who is long on wind and short on brains. His solo stuff is so preachy it’s hard to listen to.
He don’t need no ejucayshun.
“Waters, who is on tour in South America, allegedly said he was “as ashamed as I possibly could be of our colonial past ... When we were out raping and plundering and stealing”. “
If he’s pissed at this aspect of his country’s legacy he ought to be irate that the Italians have forgotten their history of the same that lasted for hundreds of years more than English colonialism and with far more brutality inflicted on the conquered.
Always knew that.
I got to hand it to the rest of the band for putting up with his idiocy for such a very long time. I dont care how talented a lot of people think he is.
How can the UK “return” something to Argentina which never belonged to Argentina?
While The Final Cut is my favorite PF album (don’t ask why, just accept that it is ;) Waters made a career of one thing. Daddy issues.
His entire lyrical output is over the loss of his father and little more than a cathartic exercise in whining to the world about it.
Some of it worked spectacularly, some didn’t, but Gilmore saved PF from a rapid descent into obscurity because without his Strat work, PF would be just a ‘pre-Emo’ Emo band.
And yes, I am donning the asbestos underwear for the fire about to come my way ;)
What’s a “Pink Floyd” .... some new kind of British QFP?
Residents of the Falkland Islands seem to disagree.
I like all Pink Floyds music. I am a fanatic, but Roger is a lunatic liberal anti-semite idiot. And I love the wall but their earlier stuff like Meddle and Atom Heart mother were some of the most talented works by the band. And agree Gilmour and Wright were amazing. Roger is a wonderful showman but needs to SHET UP!
No flames from me. Hes still not over it.
Gilmore was probly tryin so hard to play his heart out he didnt notice what a douche Waters probly had always been.
I liked the Final Cut. Two Suns in the Sunset is cool.
No, no, no. The question is “Which ones Pink?”
And Roger’s, or any other artist’s opinion is relevant because...?
An excellent song. My faves Are Gunner’s Dream and Paranoid Eyes. Of the two PA gets top shot. Then again I’m a sucker for concept albums. Nothing like a good story set to good music.
I am however surprised at how many people who hear 2 suns have no clue what he’s referring to. I mean it IS kinda obvious ;)
They have made it very clear that they want to be part of the UK, and do not want to leave and/or become citizens of other countries. The UK supports the Falklands very considerably economically with little (up to now) return benefit, because it is their responsibility to their fellow citizens.
Funny that song is on my ipod right now.. Far Out!
Funny that song is on my ipod right now.. Far Out!
I had some Floyd on vinyl when I was in my 20s, but my interest in them faded out like a bad fart.
The Falklands were never part of Argentina to begin with. The Falklanders want to keep their UK passports and want nothing to do with Argentina. This was true before oil was discovered and is even more so now. If they stay with the UK and commercial oil production begins, the Falklands will be one of the richest places on earth, per capita. If they went with Argentina, the islanders would see nothing and they would be faced with a horde of Argentinian settlers whose purpose would be to demographically replace the Falklanders. Argentina used to be a decent place with a high standard of living. Unfortunately, it’s gone steadily down hill with a series of statist governments. Under the current administration, the president spends like crazy to assure her continued re-election and criminalizes the reporting of the actual inflation rate.
The reemergence of the Falklands ‘issue’ is about oil money. The Falklanders would never agree to be a part of Argentina and the UK has said it would not give up the islanders without their consent.
And Waters is a proponent and an apologist for Argentinian colonialism. Argentina wants the oil and the land, and to hell with the inhabitants. And Waters is 100% behind them. Who's the colonialist now, Roger?
It is wholly inappropriate of you to point that out or even publicly discuss this. Roger W is a loyal leftist and as such little things like critically thinking through a given issue is clearly not on the agenda...nor should it be!
Don’t you realize the man FEELS?!?!?!? HE FEELS!!!!
Evil right wingers, I swear. Why, you’re probably one of them damn Reagan/Thacher fans too....
You’re onto me. I’m (sob!) so ashamed... :-(
Why would Roger support a country that harbored a bunch of Nazi War Criminals? Why not just say that the Falklands should be independent, instead of under any country, at the very least?
It’s ok. In your shame, you have demonstrated you FEEL! as well and so can be forgiven ;)
I have to admit that I’m enjoying this, watching idiot actors and rock stars make fools of themselves talking about “colonialism” in the Falklands and that Britain should “give them back,” statements that identify HOW ****ING DUMBASS STUPID THESE PEOPLE ARE.
It’s like watching all of your enemies line up to stick their heads into airplane propellors because they have been talked into believing it will help the world. And, indeed, they are correct.
It was amazing seeing the video of Gilmour’s “On an Island” Tour, and seeing him and Wright doing Echoes in its’ entirety one final time.
The other members even admitted that it was Wright that kept PF together in the immediate aftermath of Sid’s departure. His “Paintbox” is still one of my all-time favorite PF songs.
I want to see them publicly questioned with the following...
“How many years do we go back for the ‘repatriation’ cutoff point? How many countries do we revert to their prior ownership? Is it not unfair to those below that cutoff and who determines it? Who feeds the billions of people displaced and where do they then go?”
Ait back, eat popcorn and record on video to win the Oscar for Best Comedy.
Water’s a delusional drug user, if you follow his politics. That the Falklands was never part of Argenina isn’t relevant. His hatred of Britain is.
It’s practically a cliche for lib musicians to hate their country and work that hatred into their music. Look at Rage Against the Machine, my favorite go-to dipsticks for these examples.
It ‘guarantees’ their place in ‘history’ under the ‘any press is good press’ philosophy. RATM is full-on anti-American/Communist in their lyrics and an icon of anarchists everywhere (cognitive dissonance aside), RW hates his British heritage, both profit handsomely from the very things they claim to ‘hate’, go against their stated philosophies and laugh all the way to the bank.
Oikophobia, hatred or fear of ones own culture, is the ersatz sophistication of the intellectually vapid and insecure. It is the equivalent of a teenager belittling his family and friends to look good for the cool crowd.
Believing, “my country’s enemy is my friend”, is a terminal form of stupidity. See OWS.
Time to grow up and leave rock and roll with it’s heart of rebellion behind in the dust. I think people think it keeps them young, like the hoods of the 50s greased their hair back into their well into their 40s and 50s. It didn’t make them young, just a little pathetic.
Rock and roll has been nasty since it’s inception. The problem is it’s like bad cooking, when you are brought up on it you don’t know any better.
One wonder in which language Mr. Waters delivered his anti-colonial diatribe; certainly not English or Spanish.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.