Skip to comments.Study: 401(k) Retirement Plans Failing Most Workers
Posted on 09/07/2013 6:39:30 PM PDT by Toddsterpatriot
According to a new study, the 401(k) savings account isn't adequately providing for people's retirement and is adding to the nation's growing wealth inequality.
The report from the Economic Policy Institute, a liberal-leaning public policy think-tank, illustrates how the shift from pensions to individual savings accounts has affected retirees. The authors find that it is the wealthiest workers who are benefiting the most because they can actually contribute enough to make 401(k) plans work for retirement.
"401(k)s were never designed to replace pensions for most workers. They serve primarily as a tax shelter for high earners," said economist Monique Morrissey, the report's co-author, in a statement. "The 401(k) revolution has been a disaster, yet some policymakers are calling for cuts to Social Security, which will be the only significant source of retirement income for most Americans--if they are able to retire in the first place."
According to the report:
Retirement-income inequality has grown in part because most 401(k) participants are required to contribute to these plans in order to participate, whereas workers are automatically enrolled in defined-benefit pensions and, in the private sector, are not required to contribute to these plans. Thus, higher-income workers are much more likely to participate in defined-contribution plans. In addition, higher-income workers have more disposable income and a higher investment-risk tolerance, receive larger tax breaks, and are more likely to work for employers that provide generous matches.
(Excerpt) Read more at finance.yahoo.com ...
I think the goal is to do the reverse, steal all the 401K money and prop up social security.
Time to confiscate those evil 401(k)s.
Most workers failing the 401k plans.
Just because higher earners are able to leverage more benefits from 401K’s does not mean pensions are better investment instruments than 401k’s for the average worker.
I may have left out a much or ten.
How’d those Delphi pensions do for the average worker?
if the accounts are causing a measurable “wealth disparity,” then people are certainly saving enough money to help their retirements
since the article does not make any other sense, our “propaganda alarm” is emitting a high pitched warble /..
No thanks, keep your damn hands off my money. I'll decide what's best for me.
Are we being setup for the grab?
What the hell are you trying to do? End the cycle of poverty in this country? Have people actually build up an inheritance that they can pass down to their family when they die? Don't be such a hater. Big Brother knows what's best.
Poland Confiscates Half Of Private Pension Funds To “Cut” Sovereign Debt Load...
(I left mine at it’s peak, several years ago, and took the penalty. No regrets. No worries.)
They should allow 401k plans, both employer provided and individual, the option of converting all funds to a regular savings account every 5 years. Remove the 10% early retirement penalty and offer a flat 15% tax rate and you’d see over 6 trillion in 401k balances convert providing a tax windfall for the government and a huge savings for retirees.
Exactly. These are the arguments they use to nationalize private retirement accounts. Low income people can’t save so it’s not “fair” and possible stock losses are not as safe as letting the gov’t keep it for you and doling it out to you when they deem fit.
401s not making it? No kidding. NO growth in the economy, no return on investments.
Rate of return on stocks = inflation + dividend yield + GDP
Here it comes
We now are going to start hearing a lot more of these type of stories and “studies” in the coming months
The 401k was a great thing. The problem is convincing younger workers to utilize it to the max and not borrow against it.
Exactly this is the setup to seize these accounts for a broke gov.
We’ve got about 5 years until we can start draw down without penalty. I hope things hold together that long. We’ll draw the max without penalty for sure.
“You didn’t build that!”
6 Trillion dollar? Not sure about that, you see the 401k “locked up” was never intended to be release. It’s the govenment piggy bank just waiting for rainy day.
Are we being set up for the grab?
Hell, I’d say the grab has been taking place for years and years as inflation reduces the value of all retirement accounts whether 401K, IRA’s or simple savings accounts.
Next, Pelosi will be saying the .gov will have to take your 401k to keep the .gov from taking your 401k.
Only a matter of "When."
Hegelian dialectic at work.
1) The statist establishment creates a crisis by mis-educating the workers for decades.
2) Most workers won’t have any idea of how to calculate their retirement needs (they weren’t taught math or econ. in the publik skools).
3) In comes the “Government Family” on a white horse to save the day.
4) The ‘rich’ who were driven by the ‘perverted profit motive’ to screw the poor, will now have to ‘pay their fair share’. IRAs and 401K’s will be looted to pay for the righteous ignoramuses who voted for a free lunch. Many of them will use their benefits to buy drugs or enter strip clubs.
5) The rest is obvious. USA becomes Peron’s Argentina (run by Evita Clinton), or worse.
Baaaaaaa - Sheeple - Baaaaaaaa.
One might want to investigate what the ridiculous zero percent interest rate is doing to the 401k if your money isn’t growing you don’t have the benefit of compound interest and your money does not grow enough to provide a retirement income. It is just like Social Security which is also tied to a ridiculous interest rate, among other things, like not having the money go into a trust fund for SS recipients and instead being spent in the general fund where it cannot grow. The entire system has been corrupted by the Fed, Congress, and who knows what else.
This whole article reads like a how-to-Hate-The-Rich manual. (toss in a few standard digs against whites and anyone with a college degree for good measure).
This must be the current Polish socialist gov’t in action.
They took over after the more conservative PM Kaczynski died in Russia.
No surprises here.
They lean liberal like the CPUSA leans left.
Socialism Is Legal Plunder - "The Law" - Bastiat
There is no end to the machinations of these psychopaths.
Never mind. Tusk is supposedly a ‘center-right’ Prime Minister. That doesn’t mean much in Europe these days.
This is CBS BS. I am a worker and my IRA which I started at 27, has enabled me to become financially independent, even though I have inherited almost nothing.
Now they wanf to steal my IRA to “help” me. Right.
Oh boy... Here comes the drumbeat for the federal government to take over and “manage” private retirement accounts. It starts with propaganda pieces from the state-run news media, like this piece from CBS. Look for one of these (at least) per week.
No kidding. I cry when I see how much my SS would have earned in the market compared to the pittance I’ll receive at 67.
I suspect that the government wil be making a move on these accounts in some fashion soon. The writing is on the wall.
..the poor workers who are not on the govt teet and working for a living and paying into their OWN retirement fund are going to be roasted and basted.
until there is a CRISIS and the fed govt and the sob will have to SAVE us and take our money so they can really do better with it...
they'll call it pension "reform"....and they'll steal every single one of our hard earned pennies...
And add the amount your employer paid in and you would be extremely wealthy.
I wonder if Monique Morrisey’s job benefits include a 401K...
It sounds like EPI offers an excellent benefit package.
Most workers aren’t putting much into 401Ks. Those who do too often borrow against it or cash it out, instead of letting savings grow.
Yes we will. The intent of these stories is to take away our IRAs and shore up Social Insecurity with them. In other words, theft by govenment.
If a worker’s SS account had been invested in mutual funds for their benefit and not used to buy votes by the government, each worker would have well over a million dollars at their disposal at retirement time.
Solution: Unionize everyone with plush plans and raise the minimum wage to $50/hour. Add price controls and forced manufacturing and services to keep products flowing....Worked great for the Soviet Union and others around the world - no way did only the rich benefit...
Here they come. Notice how they mention that those 401Ks are adding to the nation’s wealth inequalities.
They are going to take them soon. Especially if the House falls to democrats in 2014.
Actually, most people have an IRA or a 401K. We got more 401Ks than IRAs now, they just haven't gotten as big yet--
How many Americans have 401(k)s?
In 2011, 51 million American workers were active 401(k) participants.
401(k) Plan Assets
Billions of dollars, end-of-period, selected periods
Millions of Americans use IRAs to save for retirement. An estimated 48.9 million U.S. households, or 40.4 percent, owned IRAs as of 2012
Billions of dollars, selected years
--and this means the average worker's got around $100K stashed away. Good enough.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.