Skip to comments.Russian newspaper closed down over religious cartoons!
Posted on 02/17/2006 6:14:57 AM PST by b2stealth
Russian newspaper closed down over religious cartoons!
VOLGOGRAD, February 17 (RIA Novosti) - The mayor's office in a major regional center on the Volga has closed down a local newspaper embroiled in a controversy over the publication of a religious cartoon, a deputy mayor said Friday.
The Gorodskye Vesti newspaper in Volgograd carried an article, "No room for racists in power", with an illustration depicting Jesus Christ, Moses, Buddha and Mohammed in front of a television showing two groups of people about to start a fight. The caption read "We did not teach them to do that..."
"We have carefully studied the article and decided to close down the newspaper in order not to inflame ethnic hostilities," Deputy Mayor Andrei Doronin told a news conference.
On Wednesday, prosecutors announced that they were launching a probe into the matter after local politicians and representatives of public organizations voiced their concerns in the wake of the wave of protests that have engulfed the Muslim world after satirical cartoons of the Prophet Mohammed were published in a Danish newspaper September 30 and then reprinted by other media earlier this year.
Gorodskiye Izvestia Editor Tatyana Kaminskaya then apologized for any offense that may have been caused but added that she had received no complaints from religious or ethnic communities. She defended the article by saying that it protested against religious and ethnic intolerance.
"I can't understand why anyone could come to such conclusions," she said. "The piece is against religious and ethnic intolerance. A caricature is comical but somehow with a malicious depiction of reality. There was nothing of the sort in our newspaper."
Many Russian politicians and public figures, including President Vladimir Putin, condemned the Danish caricatures, while the spiritual leader of Russia's 20 million Muslims, Sheikh Ravil Gainutdin, called for peace following the worldwide disturbances.
Depictions of Mohammed are explicitly prohibited by Islamic law. Muslims in many countries took to the streets in protest against the publications, which led to the ransacking of Danish and other Western embassies. Danish and Norwegian peacekeepers were also attacked in Afghanistan.
One big mistake in the cartoon - including Mohammed in "we":
Fighting is obligatory for you, much as dislike it (Sura 2, The Cow, verse 216)
If you do not fight, He will punish you sternly and replace you by other men (Sura 9, Repentance, verse 39).
Not the finest hour for freedom of speech but it does appear to be consistent.
And that cartoon was supposed to be offensive to anybody?
Sounds like a cowardly politician making a decision he thought would please higher-ups. Last I heard on this subject is the newspaper and newspaper editor are getting lot of support from Moscow-based journalists.
Yes - it was stupid to shut down the newpaper, especially because of such a tame cartoon. That's what happens when politicians get involved!
Just hot off the press - the Russian ombudsman who oversees this sort of thing (Lukin) has called for the people who shut down the Volgograd newspaper to be punished.
We'll see how it's going to develop.
What I find as astonishing is the fact, that some local official has the power to close down a newspaper just like that, from one day to another.
Well, evidently they actually don't have that power and now have gotten themselves in trouble...
I've just found out, that the discussed newspaper was owned and run by the local, city authorities.
So it seems to be a bit more clear in such a situation.
However I still think they shouldn't have done it.
Several people in Russia were convicted for exhibiting these two pictures (among more like these). Do you think the right one is offensive or not?
I'd say it is.
But the Volgograd cartoon is far from these pictures.
Some good background information on this subject:
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.