Skip to comments.CA City May Ban Smoking At Home
Posted on 11/24/2006 6:52:17 AM PST by theothercheek
The Belmont (CA) City Council is considering drafting an ordinance that declares secondhand smoke a public nuisance and extends the citys current ban on smoking in workplaces and most public areas to any residence except a single-family detached home.
The proposal, aimed at multi-unit apartment buildings, is meant to address the health concerns of elderly apartment residents who complained of complications caused by second-hand smoke, according to The Associated Press.
The City Council of this Silicon Valley suburb of San Francisco is expected to enforce the ordinance by relying on civil suits brought by citizens or the city, and by imposing fines on violators. The proposed ordinance is likely to be taken up by the City Council in January 2007, and could go into effect by March, unless a judge grants an injunction as a result of a court challenge.
Secondhand smoke has been declared a toxic contaminant by the states Environmental Protection Agency. Two cities in the state, Dublin and Calabasas, have already declared smoking a public nuisance, paving the way for people to sue their tobacco addicted neighbors. But Belmont will be the first city in the US to ban smoking in the privacy of ones home.
The Stiletto thinks that smoking is a slow form of suicide, and fervently wishes the one remaining person amongst her friends and family who still puffs on those accursed cancer sticks would quit - today. Nevertheless, she believes that based on the facts at hand a smoking ban in private residences would appear to violate Fourth Amendment personal, property and privacy rights that have been explicitly stated by the Founding Fathers and inferred as inherent by the Supreme Court. The proposed ordinance may also violate the Fourteenth Amendments equal protection clause because it disproportionately affects citizens who live in apartment complexes and other multi-family dwellings and expressly exempts those wealthy enough to be able to purchase a house in Silicon Valleys superheated real estate market.
Aside from being constitutionally dubious, Belmonts proposed ordinance is also highly ironic. In a state where consenting adults can engage in mind-bogglingly deviant sexual acts in the privacy of their homes, many Belmont residents wont be allowed to smoke a cigarette afterwards.
NOTE: The original source has links to relevant articles and Web sites.
Have they weighed in on diesel exhaust, or barbecue smoke?
"diesel exhaust, or barbecue smoke?"
Yes. It is illegal to sit or stand directly behind an exhaust pipe, or stand with your head placed stationary directly above your bbq. Moronsky 5150 is the ord. number.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.