Skip to comments.Poll: Carrie Underwood vs. Kelly Clarkson, who is the greater American Idol?
Posted on 12/15/2009 10:49:10 AM PST by RGirard
American Idol has been a consistent smash hit on television for the past seven years. First year winner Kelly Clarkson has achieved tremendous success, thus paving the way and legitimizing the competition for all those who would perform after her.
To date, only Carrie Underwood has truly rivaled Kelly Clarkson for the un-offical title: "The Greatest American Idol." Here is a side by side comparison of the two Christian girls from the South whose triumphant success has inspired millions and forever flavored the world of both pop and country music.
(Excerpt) Read more at examiner.com ...
Carrie looks better in a bikini
Carrie Underwood .1%
Kelly Clarkson .2%
Barak Obami 99.7%
I think Carrie has passed Kelly up at this point. Kelly has an amazing voice, no doubt. Probably more talented voice-wise. Carrie has driven to the top of the industry. She is one of the biggest stars in music these days. I would put Daughtry up there, too. All three have had huge commercial success. To bad Adam had to start out the way he did. He really turned off a good part of the audience with that move.
Carrie Underwood by far.
Underwood, and it isn’t even close. I’d likely put Daughtry well above Clarkson, too. Clarkson seems to have been a bit of a one-hit wonder.
That’s funny ... :-)
Paula Abdul has had more #1 hits than all Idol alumni combined. lol
Ok, I and 18 other people have voted!
I like this quote from Underwood...
On releasing Jesus, Take the Wheel: People started saying, Oh, its kind of risky. Youre coming out with a religious song. And I was thinking, Really? I grew up in Oklahoma, I always had a close relationship with God. I never thought it was risky in the least. If anything, I thought it was the safest thing I could do.
Only reason I ever watched the show.
>>>Carrie looks better in a bikini
Need visual evidence to support claim.
I don't think that's true. Underwood has had eight or nine, whereas Abdul has only had four or five. Underwood has also had all three of her studio albums go to #1. I'm not sure if Abdul can say that either.
I was really impressed with that quote as well - she’s a good Christian girl
They were basically even in all things until I was reminded that Kelly made that horrid movie with Justin. I felt that she had to pay for that and so I voted for Carrie.
Some questions can never be answered. How many angels can dance on the head of a pin? Who would win in a fight, hulk or Superman? How many grizzly bears has Sarah Palin personally strangled? Unanswerable!
“Carrie Underwood by far.”
We’re watching the complete destruction of democracy and to think someone spends any time enven pondering this? This is why America is screwed.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.