Posted on 03/18/2011 8:38:52 PM PDT by patlin
1859 Official Opinion of US Admin
1859 Opinion of US Attorney General
(Excerpt) Read more at constitutionallyspeaking.wordpress.com ...
This goes hand in hand with this exact writing! You have to read it!
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-bloggers/2690317/posts
This Regime has never been constrained by truth. We don't know who those are who press to follow a path proved to have no facts when Obama himself has told us he is a 14th Amendment citizen, naturalized because citizens are either natural or naturalized, not a natural born Citizen. His cadre has an enormous advantage in their control of the the mainstream media. Explaining the historical and legal truth isn't easy, but you Patlin are showing discipline by keeping it simple. We don't know how many of those who keep redirecting the eligibility discussion to birth certificates are trolls.
A birth certificate, even one from Hawaii, does not change the nationality of Obama’s father, and retrospectively making Obama Sr. a U.S. citizen is the only way Barry is eligible. We need to keep explaining this fact until it is understood by all who do care about our Constitution. The rest will always place party politics a race above individual freedom, and above the Constitution.
bump
This Regime has never been constrained by truth. We don’t know who those are who press to follow a path proved to have no facts when Obama himself has told us he is a 14th Amendment citizen, naturalized because citizens are either natural or naturalized, not a natural born Citizen. His cadre has an enormous advantage in their control of the the mainstream media. Explaining the historical and legal truth isn’t easy, but you Patlin are showing discipline by keeping it simple. We don’t know how many of those who keep redirecting the eligibility discussion to birth certificates are trolls.
A birth certificate, even one from Hawaii, does not change the nationality of Obama’s father, and retrospectively making Obama Sr. a U.S. citizen is the only way Barry is eligible. We need to keep explaining this fact until it is understood by all who do care about our Constitution. The rest will always place party politics a race above individual freedom, and above the Constitution.
I still don’t see why being born C-Section should disqualify someone from being president.
“KISS” is my motto. It's also just plain common sense as stated by Justice Story in his Rules for Constitutional Interpretation. I found his works in early 2009 & have lived by them since when researching the history & interpretation of the 14th which “DOES” give us the meaning of Article II natural born. Donofrio & Mario disagree with me, but then they have been bogged down by their lawyer degrees. As Justice Story said in that commentary:
§ 210. XV. In the first place, then, every word employed in the constitution is to be expounded in its plain, obvious, and common sense, unless the context furnishes some ground to control, qualify, or enlarge it. Constitutions are not designed for metaphysical or logical subtleties, for niceties of expression, for critical propriety, for elaborate shades of meaning, or for the exercise of philosophical acuteness, or juridical research. They are instruments of a practical nature, founded on the common business of human life, adapted to common wants, designed for common use, and fitted for common understandings. The people make them; the people adopt them; the people must be supposed to read them, with the help of common sense; and cannot be presumed to admit in them any recondite meaning, or any extraordinary gloss.
We done been “deluded and snared”!
We could use a few “new” Justices Story these days. Brilliant clarity of mind!!
ping
Terrific research. Thank you.
I haven’t been following this very much so please forgive my naivety... I was born in Europe and my husband was born here as was our daughter. Is she eligible to be president?
I liked this post so much..it is the reason I am sipping my second bottle of wine..
The first was a Alexis Lichine Merlot 2008..the second an Abruzzo something..both very cheap..
I sit here..how in the heck was he elected..the only conclusion is ignorance..
Ignorance opens the dark door to tyranny.
1) He was British by his birth - from his Father’s citizenship.
2) He was Indonesian by adoption - from his Mother’s subsequent Husband.
3) While an adult (in college, grad school) he identified himself as a foreign student (implied by limited information known about this time of his life).
4) While an adult, he traveled under a non-US passport to a country (Pakistan) which banned US travelers at that time. (surmised, not proven)
Given these disqualifying issues, it is irrelevant where (Hawaii, Washington State, Canada, Kenya) he was born. Mr. Barry Sotero is not a Natural Born Citizen.
1) He was British by his birth - from his Father’s citizenship.
2) He was Indonesian by adoption - from his Mother’s subsequent Husband.
3) While an adult (in college, grad school) he identified himself as a foreign student (implied by limited information known about this time of his life).
4) While an adult, he traveled under a non-US passport to a country (Pakistan) which banned US travelers at that time. (surmised, not proven)
Given these disqualifying issues, it is irrelevant where (Hawaii, Washington State, Canada, Kenya) he was born. Mr. Barry Sotero is not a Natural Born Citizen.
________________________________________________________________________
Outstanding!
++++!!!!
The BC/COLB/Place of birth are not relevant. When Rudy Giliani says “he was born in the country”. The response needs to be - so what, what about jus sanguini.
The next round of billboards just need to say this:
“jus sanguini
Translantion: Born a Brit, ain’t legit.”
If you were naturalized before your daughter's birth, the answer is yes.
A NBC is a person born on US soil of TWO citizen parentS.
0b0z0 didn't meet this condition by his own admission that his father, the roaming Communist vagabond BO Sr., was a Kenyan/British citizen! Assuming that that was his REAL father.
The Kenyan never was, is, nor ever will be eligible to hold the office of the POTUS. The other two branches are spitting on the Constitution, our founding fathers, and every US citizen.
Correction:
the second an Abruzzo 0b0z0 something..both very cheap.. no known origin.
Was she born on US soil & were you a naturalized US citizen when she was born? If the answer to both is “yes’, then yes she is eligible.
Now, had the feminist movement and progressivism not messed with the tried & TRUE from time immemorial natural law doctrine of the family unit that our founding fathers adopted, where in the wife & all children born into that marriage follow the nationality of the father, the world would be a better place and people wouldn't be paying for all these legal against the US Govt from legal & illegal aliens. This issue costs us taxpayers over a 100 billion dollars a year. A cost we need to cut immediately & get back to enforcing our founding principles of citizenship by consent.
OMG, that was at 4 in the morning, I would have been under the table hours ago!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.