Skip to comments.Georgia Judge Rules Against Plaintiffs: Attorney Mark Hatfield "taking it up on appeal"
Posted on 02/03/2012 5:14:27 PM PST by Red Steel
As you know we were expecting word out of Georgia today and we got it. Late this afternoon Judge Malihi issued his ruling against all four Plaintiffs.
We caught up with Swensson/Powell's counsel, Mark Hatfield, late this afternoon to get his initial take on the ruling. Here is what he stated obviously we are disappointed w/the decision, but there are a couple of items in the ruling that we are looking at. First, the Judge never made any ruling on who has the burden of proof even though he indicated in chambers prior to the hearing that making the determination of the burden of proof laid with Defendant Obama." He went onto state "the Judge has a record of placing the burden on the candidate, but didn't do so in this case." Another point Hatfield made was the Indiana Court of Appeals ruling in Arkeny elevates the Indiana case above the Constitution" while also noting the Judge ignored the Minor court in Minor v Happersett, a ruling that clearly defined natural born Citizen, established precedent. When asked about next steps Hatfield stated "we are going full bore and taking it up on appeal.
Click this link to read Judge Malihi's ruling - http://www.art2superpac.com/georgiaballot.html
We will be following this in detail and will keep you abreast of activities as they unfold.
Remember, this isn't a race instead we are running a marathon.
Sincerely, Helen Tansey Director
Going to do some other things..I’ll be back. :-)
Sponsoring FReepers are contributing
$10 Each time a New Monthly Donor signs up!
Get more bang for your FR buck!
Click Here To Sign Up Now!
Can I say, “I told you so”?
Actually, the ruling REJECTS the idea that Minor attempted to define NBC. That isn't surprising, since Minor says, "For the purposes of this case it is not necessary to solve these doubts."
If the guy tries to appeal by saying the judge ignored what the judge specifically addressed:
"In deciding whether a woman was eligible to vote, the Minor Court merely concluded that children born in a country of parents who were its citizens would qualify as natural born, and this Court agrees. The Minor Court left open the issue of whether a child born within the United States of alien parent(s) is a natural born citizen."
then his appeal won't go anywhere.
Ditto. Crap case in a meaningless ALJ Court. If ya can’t win in an ALJ Court when the other side doesn’t show up ... well . . .
This appeal’s going nowhere anyway.
I feel sorry for anyone who has actually attached emotional importance to this in the false belief it ever had the slightest promise of achieving anything. It has less of a chance than that proverbial snow ball in the unholy place.
“Ditto. Crap case in a meaningless ALJ Court. If ya cant win in an ALJ Court when the other side doesnt show up ... well . . .”
" the Judge ignored the Minor court in Minor v Happersett, a ruling that clearly defined natural born Citizen, established precedent."
it appears that Judge Malihi found the witnesses (BC/SS#) were 'never tendered or qualified as experts' and dismissed the (BC/SS#) evidence based on the lack of probative value.
Disappointing, but the evidence was entered and ruled upon opening the opportunity to pursue appeal.
Soapbox - doesn’t exist anymore;
Ballot box - voter fraud is rampant;
Jury box - see this judge’s ruling and rumors that SCOTUS will likely uphold DeathCare.
Only one box left.
Reminds me of the "what the definition of is is".
The Judge played us all for suckers.
He never had any intention of ruling against Obama, he wanted publicity and he got it.
The outcome of this trial is the Judge’s practical joke on anyone foolish enough to believe we would get an honest trial.
The fix was in from the beginning,the lawyer knew it and didn’t even bother to show up.
So the “peril” stuff was all BS.
For how much was Judge Mahili bought?
I suspect the judge, after he agreed to hear the case and did not just throw it out received an offer he couldn’t refuse.
They’re pushing us to the ammo box on purpose. They know damn well that when the clarion call sounds, no one will listen nor care.
We are about to descend into true totalitarianism with little more than a few websites of dissenters. Everyone else is too concerned with what Steven Tyler’s going to say on American Idol.
WHAT IS the point of posting that link? Stop it.
The Constitution is dead.
There’s no need to be concerned about natural or naturalized anymore. In the NWO, it won’t matter anyway. Money is all that matters.
Any idiot with enough money can rule the US now.
obama is here to stay.
I suspect it's much simpler: the judge can read actually read.
UPDATE Georgia ruled and its not good. Judge Malihi found Wong Kim Ark to be the deciding standard. That means anyone can fly over to the U.S. have a baby and fly back to another country, raise their kid there and when that kid moves back to the U.S. he or she can run for President. Well post more and send out a message tomorrow.<.i>
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.