I pointed out a flaw, and you didn't respond. Has LorenC found any of the original three photographs in a magazine prior to 1960? My recollection is that the answer is no.
I, and I assume others, were merely accepting Gilbert's word that the subsequent seven photos he discovered were of the same woman and taken at the same time as the original three. Now that it's been pointed out that at least one of the Gilbert photos was in a 1958 magazine (and we still only have LorenC's word on that) we can argue as to whether the girl in those pictures is the same girl in the original three.
There is some resemblance, but I cannot say for certain that the Gilbert photos either are, or are not of the same girl. Apparently the photo setting was regularly used to photograph a series of women for men's magazines.