Free Republic
Browse · Search
Bloggers & Personal
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

And This is Revolution
Sultan Knish ^ | 14 Jan 2013 | Daniel Greenfield

Posted on 01/15/2013 5:20:36 AM PST by expat1000

There are a few things worth knowing about revolutions. Most people don't participate in them, even if the history books often make it seem otherwise. Revolutions are thought up by small groups of people who then make it everyone's business. Or alternately they don't. And those are the revolutions that never happen.

Most people, at any given time and place, are dissatisfied with the government and believe, rightly, that whoever is in charge is guilty of stealing from them, oppressing them and making it impossible for them to live their lives in peace. And they also believe that things are not likely to get any better. Hope is a vanishing emotion that dissipates easily in the drudgery of ordinary everyday work. It may be taken out for a spin on historical occasions, but then it goes back into the barn where it sits for a while gathering dust until it is needed again.

There are however some known crossroads of revolution. A successful revolution usually doesn't happen among the thoroughly repressed. Those people tend to lack the motivation and skills to face down a modern army. When the peasants revolt, they can often be tricked into going home with some false promises and free beer. It worked more often with the serfs in European history than you would think. It's the middle class that you really have to watch out for.

People are not at their most dangerous when they're eating bread crusts and hoping that they won't die tomorrow. By then they're often broken, perhaps not individually, but as a society. It wasn't the people on the collective farms who challenged Soviet tanks in Moscow. Nor was it the Chinese farmers, now being bulldozed off their land, sometimes literally, who stood up to the tanks in Tienanmen Square.

The most dangerous people are the ones who have tasted enough freedom and prosperity to want to keep it. They don't think their leaders are godlike and they have enough education and competence to think the heretical thought that just about anybody could do the same job as the king, the emperor, the czar or the president. They have experience enough upward mobility to understand that a man's place in the world isn't fixed. It can and should be changed. And that is what distinguishes them from the serf. That is what makes them so dangerous.

Authority works best when it isn't challenged. Ceremony, whether it is that of an emperor or any lesser rank, invests authority with mystical force. Peer pressure and social conformity employ horizontal pressures to keep everyone in their place. Secret police and ranks of informers allow the regime to project an illusion of omnipotent force that seems to be everywhere at once. Reigns of terror create examples to intimidate anyone who might think of challenging the regime.

Revolutions strip away these illusions. The secret police run for cover or comically march out with clubs and guns against mobs, and get beaten to a pulp. The neighbor who rats on everyone sits home and stews in front of the television. And then the regime has no choice but to call on the army and hope that it still retains enough control over the officers and that the officers still have enough control over their men to do the bloody work of winning a civil war.

The army test is the acid test of a regime because it exposes the actual level of power of the regime, which relies entirely on its officer corps and its grunts to be willing to shoot people in the street. In Russia, the army proved unwilling to kill a bunch of civilians to protect a coup by their own superiors leading to the end of the Soviet Union and the fall of Communism.

After generations of worldwide terror, the great red beast was reduced to relying on the willingness of a handful of Russian kids in tanks to run over protesters. The kids, who had grown up on Western rock and roll, listening to old men preach about a coming revolution that was already older than the oldest man they had ever seen, while the echoes of capitalist dreams leaked through the Iron Curtain, chose to sit this one out. And Communism died in the streets of Moscow.

But where the Soviet Union fell, the Chinese Communist Party succeeded because they had men who were willing to run over other men with tanks. After all the great debates and posturing, the fate of hundreds of millions of people came down to the same things that all revolutions come down to, not cogent arguments or complex theories, but the willingness of some men to kill other men for a cause.

Communism also died in China. It had to. But the leadership class remained in power and their princes made it into a hereditary dynasty. In Iran, protests were pitted against the guns of the Revolutionary Guard. The regime won, but at the cost of shifting power to the Revolutionary Guard. In Syria, each side escalated, found foreign backers and is fighting a war in which the most ruthless bastards are winning. That is how the Communists ended up winning in Russia, but not after a long bout of murderous warfare in which all sides did horrible things and painted the land red. Any Russian naval officers with a sense of history watching the whole thing happen from a portside cafe are probably remembering how the same thing went down in the land of red snow.

It's the aspiring middle class that begins revolutions, but when they turn bloody enough, then they usually aren't the ones who inherit them. An ascending middle class begins revolutions to protect its privileges, only to see those revolutions hijacked by the fanatics, who to be fair, often began them, the lawyers who want to be executioners, the demagogues who fail at everything but street corner tirades and the psychopaths who drift in and then take over.

The American Revolution avoided being overtaken by these types of lunatics, though at times it was a closer thing than anyone realizes. If history had gone a little differently, Aaron Burr could very well have been our Robespierre. And General Lafayette could have been France's George Washington. Instead the American Revolution stayed in the hands of the people who wanted peace and prosperity, rather than radical social change, and France descended into blood and chaos at the hands of those who thought that revolution was worthless unless it allowed them to completely transform society.

The other kind of revolution, the Bastille kind, has managed to catch up with us. A vast territory and technological revolutions held it at bay for the longest time, but it was the aspiring middle class that eventually allowed itself to be seduced into mortgaging its political power, national integrity and economic freedom to gain an illusory peace and security in the form of a powerful government. And if there to be another revolution against it, it will once again come from the ranks of the middle class.

The American middle class can feel itself sinking. Its prosperity has been stagnating and the jobs are drying up. The educational revolution isn't doing what it was supposed to, for most, instead it saddled much of the country with even more debt. Debt is the watchword of the present, as it was of France before the Revolution. Everything is in debt and mortgaged to the hilt for everything else. International financial systems have made it possible to spread the pain and bury it in complicated financial transactions and speculation, but that just means the debt is bigger and badder than ever.

The pre-revolutionary middle class can choose between two sets of villains, big government and big business. Both are big, and thus meet the criteria for being worth revolting against, but the choice of villains often comes down to a choice of professions.

The college student who owes insane amounts of money to a complex network of financial institutions for a degree of dubious worth and a credit card whose interest rates are more complicated than the subject she was studying, is likely to sympathize with Occupy Wall Street's bank baiting. The small businessman who feels like he spends all day filling out forms in order to get other forms to fill out, while seeking his profits being sucked up by the government and its institutions, feels a tug toward the Tea Party.

It's the anarchist who is closest to the mark when he notes that there really isn't that much of a distinction between the two. The government bails out the banks with bad money and the banks bail out the government with fake money. Governments and corporations, are run by the same people with the same phony mantra of social justice, that really means showy philanthropy and profitable regs. But then the cynics usually tend to be closer to the mark because faults are easy to find.

The American middle class is caught between two rebellions. One by an urban middle class elite that would like a more closed and regulated society and another by a rural middle class that would like a more open and less regulated society, with the suburbs split in the middle.

Having the cities is not absolutely mandatory for a revolution. The modern American city is a drain that produces very little except bureaucracy and culture. And while the power of those two should not be underestimated, if every major American city were to vanish tomorrow, some of the sciences would be hard hit and the bureaucracy would become decentralized, but most other things would continue on as before.

During the American Revolution holding on to the cities proved next to impossible, because of British naval power and the large concentrations of Loyalists. Even during the Civil War, most Northern cities leaned rather close to the anti-war side. Urban Democrats may lionize Lincoln now, but many of them thought of him, the way that their descendants thought of George W. Bush, as a war criminal with the brain of a monkey who was obsessed with oppressing the common man. Even some liberal Republicans thought of him that way.

But underestimating culture is dangerous. The sort of culture that we have is mostly worthless, but that doesn't make it any less effective. There is a great distance between Beethoven's Eroica and Katy Perry singing for Obama, but unlike Beethoven, few modern liberal writers and artists would have the integrity to rip up the title page on learning that their messiah had feet of muck. The Soviet Union fell in part because it lost that sense of cultural momentum, clinging to the Western Canon, while being overwhelmed by the pop trash that now rules Russia. And though it may be trash, cultural innovation creates a sense that we are moving forward. Those on the side of the newest trend seem like they have the answers to the future. Those who aren't, end up looking like Brezhnev.

Revolutions can be won without that cultural momentum, but it's harder than ever because culture carries with it that tang of prosperity, that sense that the good times are out there for those who want them. And revolutions tend to fall on the side of prosperity, on the side of an aspiring middle class looking to the future. Culture can be beaten, but it is best beaten with culture. Successful revolutions make their ideas compelling and appealing, not just in words, but in attitudes, in music, in literature and in art. France had Marat and America had the Death of Jane McCrea,

A revolution is part anger and outrage. It is that sense that you are being unfairly treated and that the life you had or could have had is slipping away from you. It is that breath of freedom that you once took and the belief that life on the other side of the wall must be better. It is a narrative, a story that rejects the authority of those in power on moral grounds and on practical ones.

Revolution works best when the authorities are weakened by a transition period, when they were once oppressive, but have been liberalizing, or where they are asserting a new level of authority that the people are not used to. It is in these transition points that revolutions are most effective because the authorities are not ready to cope with them and the people are made bold and desperate by the uncertainty.

Revolutions are not easy, until they begin rolling, and then it seems in retrospect as if they were always inevitable, the way that big things are. It is that explosion of kinetic energy born out of the potential energy of large numbers of people discovering their strength that fills the air with energy. That ionization is what most people associate with freedom, with the inevitable collapse of an old order and the rise of a new order.

At first a few people begin to push against the wall, and then more and more, their numbers growing as wall-pushing suddenly becomes the thing to do, and suddenly the sober men and women who never held with it, who put their faith in protests and petitions, join in. The wall shakes and then it falls.

This is revolution. Daniel Greenfield is a New York City based writer and blogger and a Shillman Journalism Fellow of the David Horowitz Freedom Center.

TOPICS: History; Politics; Society
KEYWORDS: archy; banglist; cwii; guncontrol; secondamendment

1 posted on 01/15/2013 5:20:38 AM PST by expat1000
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: arasina; daisy mae for the usa; AdvisorB; wizardoz; free-in-nyc; Vendome; Louis Foxwell; ...

Sultan Knish/Daniel Greenfield Ping List (notification of new articles). FReepmail or drop me a comment to get on or off.
2 posted on 01/15/2013 5:22:13 AM PST by expat1000
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: expat1000


3 posted on 01/15/2013 5:31:04 AM PST by Roses0508
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: expat1000


4 posted on 01/15/2013 5:32:20 AM PST by Thorliveshere
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

this is bump

5 posted on 01/15/2013 5:36:53 AM PST by foreverfree
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: expat1000

One can only hope...

6 posted on 01/15/2013 5:43:57 AM PST by Bon mots (Abu Ghraib: 47 Times on the front page of the NY Times | Benghazi: 2 Times)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: expat1000

What a coincidence!

Just last night, I told one of my music students the “Eroica” Story. She had just seen “Les Miz” and was curious about that era in history.

I told her the story to illustrate how we often idolize leaders and then they prove to have feet of clay.

Great article as usual!

Thank you for your faithful postings!

7 posted on 01/15/2013 5:46:13 AM PST by left that other site (Worry is the darkroom that develops negatives.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: expat1000

Great article.

8 posted on 01/15/2013 5:48:56 AM PST by TADSLOS ( "I ask sir, what is the militia? It is the whole people except for a few politicians."-George Mason)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: expat1000

There’s a tidal wave of revolutionary talk out there as of late. I think the sobering reality of another 4 years of Barack Hussein Obama, the Marxist faggot, is starting to become clear in the minds of many freedom-loving Americans.

Most of us are in our fox holes, looking across a vast cultural wasteland, our rifles pointed down range waiting for the first wave of attacks from this Communist Manchurian candidate. Next Monday is his coronation day. He knows that he has another 4 years to destroy this country, but I don’t believe he’s going to wait that long. He knows that the Obamacare taxes and the really massive social programs will start turning in 2014, and that, he’s likely certain, will breed discontent among the masses who are forced to fork over even more money every paycheck or risk being imprisoned.

It’s getting to the point, folks, where an upper-middle-class salary doesn’t mean anything to anyone anymore. It’s getting to the point that “Going Galt” has true, real meaning to people who don’t want to get mixed up with the Obamacare juggernaut.

How many of you would truly stand on your porch, shotgun under your arm, watching for the tax man to show up with a bill demanding payment for medical care you never received for a program you never intend to use?

How many of you would answer the sound of a battering ram at your door at 2 in the morning with the report of a shotgun or a defensive weapon barking back at the gestapo?

How many of you would hide in an attic for months on end, clutching your Bibles and your rifles in the hope that “it will all be over soon?”

Well, it won’t be, and this article proves to us that it will require the tired, weary masses to rise up against the juggernaut that our Federal government has become. It will require an exhausting amount of effort and money. And most sobering: it might cost you your life. But is it all worth it in the end? Only if you’re willing to give it everything and to teach your children, your grandchildren, your friends, your family, your neighbors that America is still great and the idea of individual responsibility can be profitable for everyone involved.

It will require a string of Henry Bowman moments to spark outrage and fear among our “leaders.” It’s only after that, only after the goon squads fill our neighborhoods and attempt to turn our streets into prisons, that we will need to ask, “Are you ready to fire at the first wave coming across that cultural wasteland? Or are you too concerned about your money, your car, your home, and your precious nothings?”

Remember, those things can be taken away by force. You have the right to defend your life to the death, regardless if the government says otherwise.

9 posted on 01/15/2013 5:54:06 AM PST by rarestia (It's time to water the Tree of Liberty.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: expat1000

Thanks for the Post, very well explained.

10 posted on 01/15/2013 5:56:47 AM PST by 2001convSVT (Going Galt as fast as I can.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: rarestia

“You have the right to defend your life to the death...”

I’m stealing that. :)

11 posted on 01/15/2013 5:58:03 AM PST by PLMerite (Shut the Beyotch Down! Burn, baby, burn!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: expat1000

“Revolutions are not easy, until they begin rolling, and then it seems in retrospect as if they were always inevitable, the way that big things are. It is that explosion of kinetic energy born out of the potential energy of large numbers of people discovering their strength that fills the air with energy. That ionization is what most people associate with freedom, with the inevitable collapse of an old order and the rise of a new order.”

The Founders said it. WE THE PEOPLE.
They didn’t ask how old you are, where you live, what color or ethnicity you are, what weapons you hold, how much money you have, what religion you practice, (or even IF you practice.)
WE THE PEOPLE. We either fight for the rights that the Laws of Nature and Nature’s G-d gave us, or we die and the nation dies with us. Freedom dies with us. The Constitution dies with us.
There are no more illusions. We SEE who our true enemies are. They are already killing us day by day in ways large and small, rhetorically and literally. When we sleep, they are the stuff of nightmares, and when we are awake, we see that our nightmares have not confined themselves to dreams from which we can awaken.

12 posted on 01/15/2013 6:00:05 AM PST by MestaMachine (Sometimes the smartest man in the room is standing in the midst of imbeciles.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: PLMerite
I’m stealing that

Feel free. It's an honest statement.

13 posted on 01/15/2013 6:23:14 AM PST by rarestia (It's time to water the Tree of Liberty.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: MestaMachine

It’s a daily nightmare, Mesta. I completely agree. It’s that same recurring nightmare you have with the same talking points, the same events, and when you awake, a profound sense of deja vu overcomes you.

If anything, it’s taught me to treasure small things, to take in what you can enjoy. For me, it’s the woody taste of a good cigar or a cup of hot coffee on a winter morning.

It’s the deep bluish-green color of the grass when the last rays of the setting sun bounce orange off storm clouds in the distance.

It’s that brisk winter air that fills your lungs as you look skyward at a glorious morning sky full of stars.

We have to take the time to notice these little things or the “big” things around us will consume our minds in a way that the nightmare of deja vu makes us remember all of the negatives around us every hour of everyday.

14 posted on 01/15/2013 6:28:32 AM PST by rarestia (It's time to water the Tree of Liberty.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 12 | View Replies]

To: expat1000


15 posted on 01/15/2013 6:28:38 AM PST by Liberty Valance (Keep a simple manner for a happy life :o)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: expat1000

I have enjoyed reading Daniel’s work for the last several months. He is one of the most observent writers of our time.

Please add me to the ping list.

Big Mack

16 posted on 01/15/2013 6:37:01 AM PST by Big Mack (I didn't claw my way to the top of the food chain to eat VEGETABLES!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: unspun; Nachum; WXRGina; prof.h.mandingo; HonestConservative; ExTexasRedhead; ...

bump and ping

17 posted on 01/15/2013 6:56:53 AM PST by Albion Wilde (Gun control is hitting what you aim at. —Chuck Norris)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Albion Wilde; logitech

Excellent column! Thanks for the PING!

PING to Logitech!

18 posted on 01/15/2013 8:03:21 AM PST by WXRGina (Further up and further in!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies]

To: expat1000

Great post expat. I’ve come to like the Sultan almost as much as Mr. Steyn.

19 posted on 01/15/2013 8:03:59 AM PST by zeugma (Those of us who work for a living are outnumbered by those who vote for a living.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: WXRGina

You are most welcome! Sharing the brilliance....

20 posted on 01/15/2013 8:36:33 AM PST by Albion Wilde (Gun control is hitting what you aim at. —Chuck Norris)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 18 | View Replies]

To: left that other site

What is “the Eroica story”?

21 posted on 01/15/2013 11:04:54 AM PST by DuncanWaring (The Lord uses the good ones; the bad ones use the Lord.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

To: DuncanWaring

Beethoven dedicated his third symphony to Napoleon, because he believed that Napoleon was for a republican form of government, and would bring about the end of tyrannical monarchies in Europe.

When Napoleon ended up crowning himself emperor and went around conquering other countries, Ludwig was so upset he contemplated destroying the entire symphony, but ended up just tearing to shreds the first page which contained the dedication to Bonaparte. “Bonaparte” was the original working title, but got quickly changed to “Heroic”.

Dan Greenfield alludes to this incident in his fine article, citing that none of the Obama-worshippers have the guts to do something similar in the field of the Arts.

22 posted on 01/15/2013 11:40:14 AM PST by left that other site (Worry is the darkroom that develops negatives.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 21 | View Replies]

To: left that other site


23 posted on 01/15/2013 12:36:44 PM PST by DuncanWaring (The Lord uses the good ones; the bad ones use the Lord.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 22 | View Replies]

To: DuncanWaring

My Pleasure. Always willing to share with a Fellow FReeper!

It was a funny coincidence, reading a reference to this in Dan’s Article,

When I had JUST told this story to one of my students LAST NIGHT! LOL!

24 posted on 01/15/2013 12:49:15 PM PST by left that other site (Worry is the darkroom that develops negatives.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 23 | View Replies]

To: rarestia

You can sacrifice your life after teaching your children, and in a country with borders your martyrdom would have saved your country. But now, the matrix (marxist govt aided by its media propaganda machine) will just import ignorant, eager masses. Tyranny in this country with relative materialistic abundance to them who never tasted freedom, doesn’t sound too bad a deal.

We must defeat the matrix using the tactics of the left and by other ingenious means. Individual sacrifice will not be enough.

25 posted on 01/15/2013 1:08:12 PM PST by The_Media_never_lie (Actually, they lie when it suits them! The crooked MS media must be defeated any way it can be done!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: Big Mack

Welcome to the Sultan Knish/Daniel Greenfield ping list!

26 posted on 01/15/2013 5:10:11 PM PST by expat1000
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 16 | View Replies]

To: expat1000; Albion Wilde

The revolution will be a little harder as Zero rolls out his executive orders on the 16th of January.

27 posted on 01/16/2013 5:22:36 AM PST by Jimmy Valentine's brother (CBC, just another bunch of jive a$$ street corner hustlers)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Albion Wilde

Many thanks for the bump and ping. Great stuff. Thanks again. Bookmark worthy.

28 posted on 01/17/2013 7:14:39 AM PST by prof.h.mandingo (Buck v. Bell (1927) An idea whose time has come (for extreme liberalism))
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies]

To: prof.h.mandingo; expat1000
Great stuff. Thanks again. Bookmark worthy.

I try to limit my blog reading, but this guy's every word is worth reading. So many thanks to expat1000 for posting Greenfield links here daily.

29 posted on 01/17/2013 9:18:29 AM PST by Albion Wilde (Gun control is hitting what you aim at. —Chuck Norris)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 28 | View Replies]

To: expat1000
"It does not require a majority to prevail, but rather an irate tireless minority keen to set brush fires in people's minds."- Sam Adams
30 posted on 01/21/2013 11:15:19 AM PST by TurboZamboni (Looting the future to bribe the present)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Bloggers & Personal
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson