What ?
I am just saying how they worded what they wrote about his sister that she had some reservations about him due to her description of him, limp especially which could have been fixed and scar which they didn’t say where from falling from a tree. She would know I think if it were her brother(half). It’s also odd that they would not have been in contact all these years if they were close companions when young.
To be fair, I didn’t click on the link to read any further.