Skip to comments.Judge Rules Border Fence Illegal
Posted on 03/22/2014 1:35:52 PM PDT by John Semmens
U.S. District Court Judge for the District of Columbia Beryl Howell ruled that the construction of any kind of barrier to the free movement of people across the US/Mexican border is illegal. There can be no disputing that such a barrier would explicitly target a protected ethnic minority. This violates the equal protection clause.
As the Judge sees it, in order to pass muster, a policy, program, or enforcement must be shown to affect all racial, ethnic, religious, sexual, and sexual-orientation subsets of the population in roughly equal proportion to each groups percentage of the population. Since a fence along the United States southern border would disproportionally affect Hispanics it is impermissible under our laws.
Howell suggested that if Congress is determined to build a border fence they should look north rather than south. The mix of populations on both sides of the US/Canada border is roughly similar. No one group would be disproportionally disadvantaged by having their movements over this border impeded.
While not part of the case being adjudicated, Judge Howell hinted that deportations should be subjected to scrutiny, as well. There is little doubt in my mind that a disproportionate share of those being forced to leave this country against their will are Hispanic. This would also appear to violate the equal protection clause.
The Mexican Government hailed Howells decision. Mexicos former foreign minister, Jorge Castañeda, insisted that there must be no impediments to the migration of Mexican nationals into the land that was stolen from our country by American aggression in the 19th century.
if you missed any of this week's other semi-news/semi-satire posts you can find them at...
What a jerk.
The fail is strong with this one.
Criminality/trespassing is now considered an ethnicity?? What an oxygen thief.
DEMOCRATIC COMMUNIST PARTY IN ACTION. 2014 we make him a lame duck. 2016 we take back the country.
So glad this is coming from you John!
Just Damn! Satire....realized it too late....blood pressure....emergency room....
You almost had me.
He should be ruled an idiot and shot on the spot. Scum like that need to be put down like a rabid dog.
I know, it’s satire; but it wouldn’t surprise me in the least.
Where do they find these idiots?
It’s no joke.
Coming soon to the courtrooms nearest to you.
Can’t tell the difference anymore.
I believe the Hollywood elite are in clear violation with their gated communities and gated houses!
jeeze, stop doing that. The random satire posts really pop my top.
This one will be hard to top! Had me going for a minute.
The comments in this thread just prove how good you are, John. LOL.
It’s always interesting how judges and LW activists will bend over backwards and write all kinds of laws protecting those who are not from this continent. Yet they will do nothing for the Native Americans who are still living in poverty on reservations. I mean, opening the border to let others come and take away from those already here. And they take that wealth back to their own countries and invest nothing here. Why do judges like this hate America?
Beyond stupid! Are fences between neighbors still OK? If so, why? What does this moron judge say about Mexico's southern border? Who is this judge? What is his/her name? Can we send him/her to a wrong side of the border Border Town without protection?
This is so outrageous that I immediately looked for the Semmons satire heading. That is not to say it couldn’t happen tomorrow in our Bizarro world.
explicitly target a protected ethnic minority.
Mexican nationals? Where in the Constitution are non-citizens protected from anything?
Strange. I can't feel my heartbeat.
Tar and feather too good for them?
Satire, right? Please tell me it’s satire.
WILL YOU QUIT THAT!
These articles are NOT good for my blood pressure!
This one was easy to pick out.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.