Original 'Idol' Kelly Clarkson wins two at MTV Video Music Awards (photos)

Reality TV World ^ | 8-29-05 | UPI News Service

[Wolfstar]

I think she is a good singer, but I in no way think she is a good looking girl Wolfstar.

And that's fine, Guy. You're certainly entitled to your point of view, and I respect it. As I said, Kelly reminds me of Judy Garland in several ways, not the least of which is the fact that Judy was also not a great beauty. The real point I wanted to make is that beauty is not everything.

[A CA Guy]

I've seen her perform in person. She has great energy and will continue to have a career.

I don't know about Garland and Kelly having similarities while young at all.

[goodolemr]

Showing midriff does not make one slutty. Geez Louise. Overract much?

[A CA Guy]

Don't know what you were posting to, but I said nothing about slutty, I said I saw no similarities between her and Judy Garland.

I earlier said she had a very good voice but was not at all an attractive girl.

[goodolemr]

Sorry man. I ran accross this thread last night while searching for American Idol the other night. Someone on the prior page made the slutty comments, but I just clicked the reply button at the end of the thread.

---

As for the Judy Garland comparson, here's a pic of Kelly from AI: