Skip to comments.Probing Question: What happened before the Big Bang?
Posted on 08/04/2006 4:26:21 AM PDT by PatrickHenry
click here to read article
The Big Dig?
LOL! Well, did time exist? ...and for the umteenth time,
how did something explode from nothing?
The Big Cigarette came after.
I fervently believe in the Big Bang theory.
God spoke and BANG, the universe came into existence.
That is my only remaining hold on Religion. That some intelligence got the ball rolling. After that, I do not see it.
And for the umpteenth time, there was no "explosion." Spacetime expanded rapidly.
Note to lurkers: sirchtruth will be back with his inane question on the next such thread. No matter how many times he's given an answer he isintrinsically unable to actually assimilate any new data and appears to be stuck, educationally, somewhere in grade school.
Then you're not looking outside of that little box you've created...
"He went out for a beer and never came back" Bingo from.....
"Venus on the Half Shell"
Why, the Big Whizz, of course!
First, the brakes failed...
I have difficulty grasping loopy quantum gravity but I do understand God spoke and it stood fast.
Didn't Adam Sandler play him in a movie?
No I crawled out of the little box that the clerics tried to confine me in.. ...You got it backwards.
LOL! Yea, to some elitist, superior intellect I guess my questions are quite "inane," thanks for noticing!
Alex, I'll take wisdom for 500!
So, in other words, you prefer your myth better? I guess you were there!
It sure takes a lot of faith, to believe the crap all the "educated" people bring us. At least they keep us talking with their daily revisions.
Well, the book does say he created the universe.
Then the Big Bang is described very accurately.
Seems pretty simple to me.
Obscure "Jonah Goldberg reference" BTTT
"And for the umpteenth time, there was no "explosion." Spacetime expanded rapidly."
Beat me to it.
What happened before the Big Bang?
Since the deterioration has already started-
-the answer to question is:
the Islamofascist was seen in the neighborhood...
"In the beginning was the Word; and the Word was with God, and the Word was God..."
Verse memorized in childhood; chapter and verse reference long since forgotten.
Who was it that said we have three dimensional minds in an eight dimensional world......or something like that?
Such is your non-logic that you get it all backwards.
SEe, making mistakes and LEARNING from them is a sign of intelligence. Sticking to the same tired, old paradigm - in the face of overwhelming evidence - THAT is the realm of zealots and idiots. Kinda like the Muslims ACTUALLY THINK there will be 72 virgins waiting for them....well, that ain't happenin'. Nor will St. Peter meet you at the gates of "heaven". The Great Crow will not swoop down to gather your soul, and the Flying Spagetti Monster (B.H.N.A.) will not envelop your soul in Marinara sauce.
I'm amazed when zealots use "learning" as evidence that their "non-learning" is correct.
No, you're still in a box, it's just one wrapped with blinding gift paper.
I stole that one from Johnny Carson circa 1981.
LOL! That's where I got it, too. RIP, Johnny Carson.
Ashtekar says, exists another universe with space-time geometry similar to our own, except that instead of expanding, it is shrinking.
but daddy - "how big was the universe and what made it shrink er expand, er?
We don't know kids, but it ought to be worth another $100,000 grant to find out. And isn't that really what research is all about?
I can't figure out if it is God that has always existed or space? Considering time/space wasn't even considered a dimension until Einstein, I put God as my first choice. How many dimensions must be out there we don't know about?
It's easier than all of that. There was no Big Bang. The Universe has existed forever and will continue to exist forever. It changes and evolves and grows larger structures. Some things get destroyed. Some things get created. But there is no such thing as creation ex-nihilo, it's more like recycling.
You, my friend, are an excellent example to use for the term "zealot".
I'll trust in God, thank you. Logic is good for games and speculation.
I guess the ability to disagree is not within the realm of science... /s
By the way, show me the remains of the "persons" who we replaced a few thousand years ago in the deserts of Africa... I'm sure there are lots of examples of the "morphed" beings, we "evolved" from. After all, "science doesn't make mistakes". They just can't seem to find the right answers.
The fact that man is able to calculate orbits, does not necessarily rule out the existence of God. It just reveals what a good job He did, when He spoke this universe into existence. It expanded really quick, didn't it?
"If a tree falls in the forest..."
Let me get this right.
Science gives value to theory.
Theory says spacetime expanded rapidly.
Science says things happen with standard deviation, and standard patterns. Example stated deviastes beyond normal expectation.
Theory proves "Science" is easily fooled!
Science is pretty vain, isn't it?
I think it is John 1:1
"God retired?".....I believe the line was : It was a good play, I think I'll do it again sometime.
There was a Big Bang because we can see its remnants. But that doesn't mean it was the Big Bang - the Universe is apparently more vast than we imagined and Big Bangs might be happening all over the place, too far away for us to perceive.
You have overwhelming evidence of what? That the Universe created itself? Seriously, publish it if you've got it.
Some on this thread may not know about the Anthropic Principle - the idea that this Universe appears to have been designed to allow us to exist. Out of all the infinitely variable boundary conditions of the Universe: the Gravitational constant, the relative strength of the Strong and Weak forces, and many others the Universe just *happens* to have, or to embody, the exact set of parameters which make matter, space and life possible.
Change a constant by a few decimal places, and the Universe would consist only of hydrogen, or only of baryons - or it would have lasted only a few millenia before crunching back on itself. The odds of getting even carbon-synthesis to work are extraordinary small, and everything else has to be "just right" as well
The odds are literally infinitesimal that our Universe just happened to get it right. The religious theory that the Universe was designed - and designed for us - is strongly supported by the extraordinary unlikelihood of the Universe being able to support us.
The usual (atheistic) defence against the Anthropic Principle is to take refuge in the tired Star-Trek trope of there being quadrillions of parallel Universes, one of which is ours.
This is unscientific. Any "other" Universe would have to be completely orthogonal to this one, with no interaction of any kind. If a scientist could detect another Universe, he would have - by definition - simply have detected more of 'the' Universe.
Atheists (those who understand the Anthropic Principle anyway) must insist on there being unthinkable infinities of rigidly unknowable Universes in order for us to have become self-selected observers of this one Universe - the one that happens to have the right conditions for life. This "Million Spheres" approach to cosmogeny is literally unprovable, and therefore unscientific.
I just love science. It gives me something tanglible to explain some of those things around me that I don't understand.
I have a whole lot of questions for God. He's got the time to answer them...
All that now exists bursts from the singularity in a nano second and that wasn't an explosion? What was all of the light and heat and matter flying through space,old Jack Benny jokes?
God spoke and BANG, the universe came into existence.
I like it!
A bit of foreplay, I'd imagine.
All that light and heat and matter weren't flying through anything. The Big Bang was an explosion OF space, not of things in space. ANd the universe is still expanding from the Big Bang. Things are getting farther apart, but not from moving through space. More space is coming into existence between things.
The Big Match lit the Big Fuse?
Yes, it's an old joke. I like it too.I use it on humans who think they know how the universe began without God's help. It either cracks them up or they become very quiet.
What's the definition of "explosion?" If you slow down an explosion, what is actually occurring? Rapid expansion?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.