Skip to comments.Robyn Gibson Defends Mel to Court: Report
Posted on 07/15/2010 1:00:49 PM PDT by nickcarraway
click here to read article
Yeah, I think he’s being scammed. This was planned for a long time.
If he doesn’t have a history of this kind of stuff, I think it’s unlikely he’d start now.
I have not condemned this man and have had suspicions. He is rich and he made a movie that upset HOLLYWOOD intensely. They never forgave him for that....setup? Possibly.....
Mel is a complete jerk, an alcoholic with serious psychiatric problems. I pray for him; I think he’s been under attack by Satan since he created The Passion of the Christ.
That said, I can certainly believe that his wife never experienced any violence at his hands. It sounds as though, without her, he has had a nervous breakdown. I suppose it might drive a man mad to know that he has destroyed his family and his career, and lost half a billion dollars, because of his complete stupidity over a woman who turned out to be a golddigging whore. Wouldn’t be the first time.
I once knew a very sweet and gentle man who, after a lifetime of stability and highly responsible behavior, suffered a complete mental breakdown and for a period did a number of awful things. He received psychiatric care and has never done anything wrong since. But it was harrowing for his wife and family while he was going nuts.
She probably agrees with Mel that ‘babies mamma’ “deserved” a punch in the mouth; not that I would blame her if she did.
Have you heard the tapes? They are way wack!
Sounds like he got involve w/ a phyco b*tch and she is trying to take him to the cleaners.
Gibson was married to Robyn for like 25 years, had 7 kids with her. Given he has been in Hollywood for such a long time, and has therefore seen what Hollywood is all about - its really dumbfounding to me why he would give up his family for what was clearly an unstable relationship with this Russian bird.
Audio expert believes the taped phone conversations may have been altered.
I only heard a bit...; typically I don’t waste my time on entertainment news.
Yes, the bit I heard is disturbing; but like I said, I think this is a set up.
Wow, another conservative West of the Cascades.
Spot on! You might want to add "any OF MY money".
If he admitted to punching her, then he probably made the outburst that she released. It is quite dramatic if you have not heard it. I would like to know the mechanism, i.e. exactly how it was recorded. If its not a phone message, and it is not; how did she set it up and did someone help her?
Why do successful men fall for something as trivial as sex in a way that ruins their reputation, legacy and hurts their family? Its not like he could not get it on the side, discretely. People close may look the other way. Not so with Spitzer and Morris; but they are political figures. Hollywood as in Europe is full of willing mistresses. Gibson is a political figure in a way, so he should expect to be outed for having a mistress, but so what? It would cause less damage than this. Come on Mel.
Not saying I don't believe her testimony, but that I do not doubt which side of her bread contains the refined salted dairy product. ;)
He and his people deny that he punched her.
According to sources connected with Mel, on January 6, 2010, Mel and Oksana were arguing at home when Oksana took baby Lucia, ran around the backyard, threw herself on the ground, came back inside the house and began shaking Lucia like a ragdoll. Mel followed and the sources acknowledge there was physical contact, but insist Mel did not punch her and was just trying to protect the baby.
Mel found out that the grass may be greener and younger but there is a lot of bullcr@p used to fertilize that lawn. You can put up with the smell and stench when you are younger but later you find you can’t tolerate it no matter how much you hold your nose.
Didn’t Mel and Robyn have at least eight children together? That’s quite a brood and the marriage succeeded for a long time without any incident I recall.
Oksana alleges past abuse where her teeth were knocked out or something, yet I would think in today’s world this would not have escaped attention. It would have leaked to the Hollywood spies.
I also question Oksana’s setup, deliberately staging and recording her phone calls with Mel, unknown to him. I intensely hate that kind of dishonesty and sneakiness. It has been noted he goes quiet several times, but she eggs him on.
Mel has been very, very successful in the movie business and obviously rich, rich, rich. Oksana knew this going in, eh. So, making the custody battle into more than it is gives her the possibility of a higher settlement. Just sayin’...
I’ve kept quiet about the flurry of sensational tapes, but skeptical all the way. I’m not ready to give up “Braveheart” and Mel’s other stellar accomplishments. With his wife in his corner, maybe things will come around in his favor and I’d love to see some of the nitwits from ET bite their tongues off.
His people may well NOW deny that he punched her; HE HIMSELF was recorded agreeing that he did so, and assessing the situation after the fact as her being deserving of a punch to the mouth that broke her teeth while she was holding their baby.
Please understand, I am in no way denying that Mel is a racist, a sexist, and a jerk. And he’s sure not being a good witness for his Catholic faith. You can’t tell me he’s been to confession in the past couple of years.
AMEN, again! He has been possessed by Satan.
Except the validity of the recordings are now called into question. Link in post 11. And this ISN’T Gibsons people. Unfortunately I can’t get the video to play on my machine.
Right now Mel has not denied that the tapes are authentic, and there is only speculation (which you apparently wish to accept whole heatedly) that there was any tampering of the tapes.
Gibson has said nothing. Only his attorneys have. And they have said he only asks that this not be played out in the press. She has other ideas. There can be only one reason that she would release tapes to an online gossip site after a judge sealed them with a restraining order. And that reason is to humiliate.
Gibson, if the tapes were inauthentic, should immediately stand up and loudly and publicly proclaim their falsity.
Problem is that he probably DID say, in response to her complaint that he knocked her teeth out by punching her in the mouth while she was holding their baby “You deserved it!” as well as speculating upon her being raped ‘by a bunch of n*ggers’, reporting her about hiring “wetbacks”, etc.
The guy is one twisted sick sorry excuse for a man. And I based that on comments and actions unrelated to these new revelations. Holocaust denial, “sugar tits”, ‘Jews starting all wars’; as well as for leaving his long term wife and mother of his children for this freakshow in progress.
Face it, the guy is demented, and a hateful racist; and apparently the kind of guy who would punch a woman in the mouth, knocking out her teeth, while she was holding their baby; and then say she deserved it.
A sick and sorry excuse for a man any way you care to look at it.
If she wants us to believe that there’s been no abuse, then she needs to show us those pearly whites.
Gibson has always kept his private life private. She's looking for a pay off. You can discount Robyns testimony if you want. I won't. And if he was so racist, I think we'd have heard from Danny Glover and others before this.
You’re calling his wife a liar?!
My thoughts exactly.
Unless a guy has experienced a psycho b*tch firsthand for himself, he wouldn't understand.
It has to be experienced to be believed, otherwise you would think women like that are something wrtiers make up, like the ones in the movies, "The Hand that Rocks the Cradle" or "Body Heat."
But they really exist.
As a corollary, I’d like to point out that there is such a thing as denial. My ex’s mother was beaten black and blue on a weekly basis. This is not in dispute; all four of her kids agree, as do her relatives. After the wife beater died, she denied he’d ever been abusive. True story.
This was a declaration filed with the court. Do you REALLY think if there had been abuse, there wouldn’t be dental and doctor records?! Are you so ready to smear him that you’ll smear an innocent person just for fun?
That sounds like a set up to me. She states something that was bad but not that bad and he replies “You deserved it.” Then it’s edited in later to refer to the teeth being knocked out.
I just find it strange that she thought she needed to remind him that he’d knocked her teeth out.
You don’t put recording equipment in your diamond earings before the man supposedly goes off on you without having some sort of agenda.
I didn’t smear anybody. And what kind of twisted mind thinks I posted what I did ‘for fun’??? Do you think recalling what my former mother-in-law went through was ‘fun’? Why are you attacking me? I didn’t do anything to you. I shared some firsthand knowledge. It may or may not be pertinent. Your overheated reply wasn’t appreciated. Tone it down, please.
You responded to a poster that was questioning Robyn Gibsons veracity with the above statement. And you were called on it.
Like I said, if someone had me supposedly on tape saying things I did not say, I would stand up immediately and publicly call them out as false.
That Gibson has not done this speaks volumes to me.
The guy is a Holocaust denying, Jew hating, conspiracy theorist; and the son of a Holocaust denying Jew hating conspiracy theorist. It didn't take these tapes to convince me the guy was a racist.
“oh, but he was drunk!”
Yeah, because feed me too many shots of whiskey and suddenly I think Jews started all wars and that the Holocaust never happened!
Sorry if I fail to worship your hero, the guy is one sick twisted sorry excuse for a man.
String him up before he has a chance to defend himself?
Everyone who wants to dispense with the bother of a trial should watch the Ox-Bow Incident movie with Henry Fonda.
You can see how a lynch mob gets carried away.
Some women that suffer abuse are in denial. This is a fact. I have seen it first hand. Whether or not it applies in this case I do not know. Another thing I don’t know is why you came after me with such a bizarre accusation. I can assure you I wasn’t having ‘fun’. I was simply sharing information. I didn’t appreciate you making it personal. I’ve never said anything hostile to you.
There are a lot of posters that are enjoying the hunt. It makes them feel superior.
I didn't, by pointing out what a sick and twisted sorry excuse for a man Mel is, advocate lynching the guy.
But based upon his past words and deeds, these tapes do not seem at all out of character.
Nor do I think that Robyn Gibson is a disinterested party in the eventual payout to the Gold-digger; which was my point of entry to this thread.
That statement also questions her veracity. She did not have to come forward. Her divorce is almost final. Silence would cost her nothing. She obviously couldn't remain silent. To indicate that she may be "in denial" was NOT nice.
uh.....by his ACTIONS, maybe.
Robyn Gibson already has her money. It's set aside. $400 mil. The divorce is final this month. If you think hard enough, you may be able to smear a very respected lady some more.
The divorce is final this month. The money is already set aside by the court.
Will you stop making accusations about what I said, please? I never questioned anyone’s veracity. If you believe there is no such thing as denial, then I suppose you could attack my comment-but why are you coming after ME? I shared something I witnessed first hand. I’ve said that I don’t know if it applies in this situation or not. But you can’t let it go. What have I ever done to you, that you are determined to put words in my mouth and make all these weird accusations against me?
And won’t she be getting part of his future earnings?
Robyn always made sure Mel was serviced Before she took a jacuzzi.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.