[Pessimist]

Right now I have a 1911, a 9mm MRI Baby Eagle, and a S&W 687 (.357 magnum / .38 special, 7 shot, 4" + barrel).

To me the most likely choice for carry out of thiose would be the 1911. (The 9mm is kinda thick due to the double stack magazine.).

But I'd be down with buying a new weapon too. :)

Also, I have no idea what the practial factors are for holster choice.

Comments?

PS: Just to stir the pot, I'd even consider .380...

[PBinTX]

Get the gun that you will carry regularly everyday in any season. Someone else said it first, “the 380 you carry is better than the 1911 you left at home.”

I found it all to easy to slip my 380 LCP in my pocket, and it is thin enough to conceal nicely. Holland Holster makes a holster that is about the same size and shape as an ordinary wallet. In my state, if someone notices you’re carrying, you could lose your CC license. I wont ever have that problem with a small gun.

[ExSoldier]

Holsters: Hands down the best (and most comfortable in all climates) IWB holster on the market: CROSSBREED

[CodeToad]

Kimber Ultra Carry. A small 1911. Works great.

[Little Ray]

Any gun is better than no gun.
Would suggest a Taurus or Smith hammerless (or shrouded hammer) “snubbie” in 38+P. Lotta good loads for them. I know it doesn’t begin with a “4” but it will work, if you do.