Skip to comments.Princeton Scientist Tells Earth Researchers: Speak Out
Posted on 12/18/2010 7:39:52 AM PST by epithermal
SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIAGeoscientists want everyone, including policymakers, to understand their work and its possible ramifications for society. But on Wednesday, an overflow crowd of 400 at the American Geophysical Union (AGU) meeting here received some practical advice about getting the message out.
"Communication with the public is not a monologue, it's a dialogue," said Princeton University climatologist Michael Oppenheimer. "We should get used to being public people." Climate scientist Jay Gulledge of the Pew Center on Global Climate Change in Arlington, Virginia, said, "There used to be arguments in sessions like this between those who said, 'Keep your nose clean,' and others who said, 'Go talk to politicians.' You don't hear those [arguments] anymore."
Oppenheimer's talk was part of a bevy of presentations at the weeklong meeting devoted to communicating science to a broader audience. The initiative, part of AGU's increased emphasis on the topic, included workshops on speaking and science blogging and a panel with several authors of books on climate (including this reporter).
(Excerpt) Read more at news.sciencemag.org ...
"Civil rights attorney Joyce Schon of progressive group By Any Means Necessary encouraged participants to display their passion for the cause. "Your role is to discover the truth and lay down your lives to disseminate it," she told attendees during a panel discussion. The group distributed flyers asking scientists to "Defend our Science and to Fight for the Real Political Action Necessary to Solve the Environmental Crisis." "
Unbelievable that educated people would form an alliance with a radical fringe group like "By Any Means Necessary". Check out their web site to see what a Marxist group they are:
Did they have a panel discussion on how to properly communicate via email so that when your emails get leaked you don’t end up looking like a press flack for a third world dictator?
If this were a discussion on really educating the public about science, I’d say it was worthwhile. The amount of scientific illiteracy is simply appalling.
But it seems to be just a discussion on ramming the idea of “global warming” down the public’s throats. We’ve already been bombarded with fearmongering about global warming for a few decades now; too much crying wolf has made many of us immune to the message. Finding new ways to try to alarm us about global warming isn’t likely to do much at this point.
They are just like Obama.
The public rejects their constant yammering, fear mongering, and over-communication of their "message" (read propaganda).
So they conclude they need to TRY HARDER at communicating their "message".
It turns people off even more.
They are stuck trying to fit the square peg in the round hole. And they conclude they need to push harder. It demonstrates lack of common sense and mental illness IMHO.
In reality, these people all have well-paying jobs and enjoy an upper middle class lifestyle - no one's laying down their lives for anything. I find it intriguing how they superimpose this dramatic narrative to motivate warmist radicalism; as if they're tapping into some primal fantasy of being the persecuted truth-teller.
“Communication with the public is not a monologue, it’s a dialogue,” said Princeton University climatologist Michael Oppenheimer. “We should get used to being public people.” Climate scientist Jay Gulledge of the Pew Center on Global Climate Change in Arlington, Virginia, said, “There used to be arguments in sessions like this between those who said, ‘Keep your nose clean,’ and others who said, ‘Go talk to politicians.’ You don’t hear those [arguments] anymore.” From the article posted by epithermal
These “scientists” know they aren’t kidding anyone anymore. Now they’re admitting that they are _POLITICALLY_ motivated and Saul Alinsky’s “rules” are their play-book:
[Saul].....Alinsky scolded the Sixties Left for scaring off potential converts in Middle America. True revolutionaries do not flaunt their radicalism, Alinsky taught. They cut their hair, put on suits and infiltrate the system from within.
“A related principle taught by Alinsky was that radical organizers must not only speak the language of the middle class, but that they also must dress their crusades in the vestments of morality. Moral rationalization, he said, is indispensable to all kinds of action, whether to justify the selection or the use of ends or means. All great leaders, he added, invoked moral principles to cover naked self-interest in the clothing of freedom, equality of mankind, a law higher than man-made law, and so on. In short: All effective actions require the passport of morality. ...” Continue here: http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/Read.aspx?GUID=d6e27ece-9798-4f01-a378-3f1405f69704
Here they are putting Alinsky’s “rules” into action:
“This Urgent Call to Action represents a fresh and spirit-directed religious, ethical, ___and political voice___ for the care of creation in the U. S. ...” ~ Calvin B. DeWitt
Au Sable Institute of Environmental Studies
World Council of Churches
World Evangelical Fellowships (WEF) Unit on Ethics and Society
The Place of Creation in Todays Missionary Discourse Evangelical Environmentalism in America
By Calvin B. DeWitt
Whether we will enter the public square and offer our witness there is no longer an open question. We are in that square, and we will not withdraw. ...
An Urgent Call to Action The Call. Most moving to me as a participant in the recent work of scientists and evangelicals at Melhana was my personal observation that it was mostly the scientists who suggested wording of our joint statement to make it more passionate and more spiritual. ...
We declare that every sector of our nations leadershipreligious, scientific, business, political, and educationalmust act now to work toward the fundamental change in values, lifestyles, and public policies required to address these worsening problems before it is too late. There is no excuse for further delays. Business as usual cannot continue yet one more day. ... This Urgent Call to Action represents a fresh and spirit-directed religious, ethical, and political voice for the care of creation in the U. S. ...
The Creation and the Scientists. At their conciliatory meeting, the groups participants, including leading expert on biodiversity Peter Raven, NASA climate scientist James Hansen, and biological oceanographer and president elect of the AAAS James McCarthy, joined to announce that they happily discovered far more concordance than any of us had expected, quickly moving beyond dialogue to a shared sense of moral purpose. ...
Immediate Steps toward Implementation. ...
17. Rev. Cizik informed a press conference that the NAE will announce in February 2007 a firstever partnership with the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency, engaging its Energy Star program to reduce energy consumption in our respective 45,000 churches from 54 denominations. On the same day Dr. Howard Frumkin, Director of the Centers for Disease Controls National Center for Environmental Health (CDC), and a signatory of the Urgent Call to Action, released a news announcement that extended the work of the CDC to tackle the health threats posed by global warming as a public health issue that includes health effects of heat waves, waterborne and mosquito-borne diseases, worsening air pollution, and severe weather. Other participants in the group joined them in taking action in their own lives and settings, and are continuing to do so. ...
Missiology, Creation Care, and a Message of Hope In his introduction to Missionary Earthkeeping (1992), philosopher J. Mark Thomas wrote The great question now facing humankind is whether the necessary moral and spiritual courage can be mustered to alter the trajectory of destruction before the Earths environmental systems are stressed beyond saving. ...