Posted on 12/23/2010 3:42:18 PM PST by Mariner
I know, many of you can't bear the idea of somebody, anybody, taking on a role once played by John Wayne. I too was skeptical as I am a devoted Duke fan.
However, I'm also a great fan of Jeff Bridges and the Coen Brothers.
And, I can tell you this: The Dude does The Duke proud.
This is certainly the best Western since Unforgiven and probably in the top 10 ever. Yes, it's far better than the original in every respect.
Acting, dialogue, mood and photography come together to be the best movie the Coen Brothers have made.
It's not a story about vengeance. It's a story about justice. And what a story it is. The final scene before the Coda, when Rooster and Mattie are riding through the night is one of the most heart-wrenching scenes you will see in a movie. Ever.
Both are deserving of Academy Awards, as are the Coen Brothers in multiple categories.
Go see this movie in a theater...soon...
Have not seen it. I saw the previews, and I was appalled that someone was remaking the movie. Might give it a try....maybe
Good philosophy, i just hate supporting lefties with my money, it just makes me cringe.
1) Nudity or explicit stuff of a related nature.
2) Violations of the Second Commandment or the F word.
3) Really graphic violence (Doesn't really bother me, just a stat point).
4) Any liberal or PC material or messages.
Thankee kindly :)
Did you see the original?
Even if it doesn't, I might still see it.
Even if it doesn't, I might still see it.
Ah...a MAN! How delightful!!
"Bold talk for a one-eyed fat man!"

"Fill your hand you son-of-a-b!tch!"
Even if it doesn't, I might still see it.
The muscles that close an alligators jaws are as strong as steel. The muscles that OPEN them, however, are very weak.
I remember that scene and I haven’t seen it in 50 years!
Meanwhile, John Wayne’s TG is not the best movie. Cambell is terrible and Oklahoma does not look like the Rocky Mountains!
Saw it last night and I still wanted to puke. When I first saw it 41 years ago I lost my girlfriend that weekend. Probbly something I said about Cambell.
However, it's clean in every other respect. It's PG-13 and would be a plain G were it not for the shooting.
Sorry, but I thought it sucked.
Sorry for the triplicate post. Being fat, drunk and having one eye makes it hard to post.
What?
Heading out to see it right now. Can’t wait.
Report back!
Read a book on Reagan a few years ago titled “Reagan’s War” http://www.amazon.com/Reagans-War-Struggle-Triumph-Communism/dp/0385504713
The Author goes into the CPUSA’s involvement in Hollywood and Lloyd and E.G. Robinson are discussed. Few actors were members of the CP back then, mostly it was writers, directors, producers etc. E.G. denounced the CP in 48.
Yeah you are correct with the boy. Now, what is the Boy's name? I know.
Gosh, being a TrueGrit Purist, I'm starting to bend.
I do like the Coen brothers movies, for the most part. "Fargo" remains one of my favourites.
The Departed is a great movie and Fargo is well Fargo. Leo is a great actor, even if he is a jerk in real life. Catch me if you can was also brilliant.
I don’t remember their names...I haven’t seen the original in 10 years and the new one doesn’t mention them.
I won’t pay to see anything with Matt Damon in it after the smear job he did on Sarah Palin.
Thanks again :)
Agreed.
***Like reality tv, as long as they can just do remakes Hollywood loves it. It costs hardly anything in time or money to regurgitate trash. Creativity is what costs money.****
You mean like the 1931 version of THE MALTESE FALCON (Ricardo Cortez)as compared with the remake, the 1941 version(Humphry Bogart)?
Well camp here. Here.
Yes Craig was a perfect James Bond for this time, he'd have tanked when the original films were made. I'm fine with either he or Connery's portrayals so long as I keep the time frame in mind.
(If for no other reason than costumes have changed totally in the intervening years and today's dress code is far more accurate.}
Remakes are usually an insult. But I enjoy watching Stagecoach in all of it's variations and reinterpretations, so why not True Grit?
Campbell is or was a lame actor and all I need to do to judge his singing is run 'Wichita Line Man' thru my mind and that is settled as well. BUT, to me he was a fine LeBoef because LeBouf was supposed to be a jerk with a self image that finally came to pass.
I watch the original movie at least once a month. Sometimes twice. Such a great movie.
A classic scene was in the movie begining when Rooster was testifying to the court. I'll leave that as a teaser for your.
OK, here is another: “...why should I wash, I'm not gonna eat him...”
I’d like to see True Grit, but I don’t want to support anything that has anything to do with Matt Damon, so I’ll probably buy a ticket to some other movie that’s showing at the same time at the Multi-plex but go see True Grit instead.
Support the Coen Brother for their art.
And, this movie is ALL AMERICAN. It is all about Justice before the Law.
You got that one right. (Stamp the bottle to the ground a few times)
“If every time I hear about a Texican drinking out of a hoof print...”
Or how about the 1946 version of THE KILLERS (Burt Lancaster) as compared with the 1964 remake (Ronald Reagan).
Mattie dominates this movie with the exception of Roosters’ heroic scenes.
“Wayne was an mans man, a foavorite of many leading ladies and perhaps the greatest conservative, save maybe Reagan.”
John Wayne was a great actor, but he avoided military service during WW2. Even some of his fellow actors gave him a hard time about it.
Jimmy Stewart was the real deal; a hero in all aspects of his life, and a great conservative. In the late 1950s Strategic Air Command nominated Colonel Stewart, USAF reserve, for an important staff job at headquarters in Omaha, and Stewart was willing to retire from movies to take it. But the Senate armed forces committee rejected the nomination, because they refused to take an actor seriously for an important job! SAC hadn’t nominated him as window dressing. Jimmy Stewart was admired and respected by the generals who led SAC.
And, I can tell you this: The Dude does The Duke proud.
From the commercials I came to a, "Yea, not bad!" impression.
Yes, it's far better than the original in every respect.
Sorry.
Impossible.
"Jihad? Ill give you a jihad you miserable, rag-headed, heathen bastard!"
***Or how about the 1946 version of THE KILLERS (Burt Lancaster) as compared with the 1964 remake (Ronald Reagan).***
Unfortunatly, I haven’t seen either of these. But I will soon!
You mean you wouldn't load it wrong while in a state of drunkenness?
<<<>>> I agree, with you, Kim Darby (Mattie) was most crucial to the sucess of the movie. IMO, without her, the movie would have been a flop. IMO, she made the movie. Also, she played her role greatly and convincingly. OK Mariner: Where was Mattie from?
I was dead set against seeing the unnecessary remake as well.
But then I read somewhere that the new movie is more of an homage than a remake.
I do plan to see it at some point, perhaps when it’s out on DVD.
But I don’t expect that Jeff Bridges (a fine actor) is a threat to The Duke.
“I call that bold talk for a one eyed fat man.”
“In many ways, better than Connery.”
That’s taking it too far. Craig is good, but he’s an action star.
Connery is James Bond.
Matt Damon: Sarah Palin is “Totally Absurd”.
No thanks.
Absolutely no contest.
Damon was better than Campbell too.
The new movie is better in every respect.
My brother and I first saw True Grit when it first came out in 1969 (I was 19, he was 17). They filmed quite a few scenes for the film around here where I live in California. In the late 1970s, you could rent True Grit from the local library, so my brother bought a 16mm sound projector and we watched it over and over again.
Then when VHS tapes came out, my brother bought one of the first tape decks for $700 so he could watch True Grit on video. Came on two cassettes. Then we bought the DVDs, and later, the deluxe DVDs.
My brother called just yesterday to let me know that True Grit will be coming out on Blueray next month. He's going to buy it, though neither one of us has an HD TV.
“Bold talk for a one-eyed fat man!”
You nailed it.
He was amazing in Shutter Island.
Leo is a puss, but he can sure act. Always could.
I love watching movies in black theatres.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.