Posted on 03/05/2011 8:09:44 PM PST by Swordmaker
Good for you for exploring the options. There are quite a few now and the choices will continue to grow and improve. HP’s tablet could be quite interesting, though it’s own native OS puts it out in left field.
Does this chart, supposedly comparing features, deliberately OMIT included features of the new iPad 2 to make it look less capable than its competition. The answer is yes, it does. That's cheating.
What's also pertinent to this discussion that's missing from this chart that consumers might want to know? How about the number of tablet optimized apps available?
Do YOU own an iPhone 4? If you believe the single most successful smartphone release in history is a failure, you have fallen for the very well orchestrated FUD campaign that Google mounted to counter it's release and to promote Android phones.
The proof is that the totally unmodified iphone4, when released into the rest of the World's markets, DID NOT HAVE THE ANTENNA PROBLEM so heavily hyped in the press in the United States! In fact reviewers there, no matter how hard they tried, could not duplicate the problem! Multiple technical sources demonstrated similar attenuation on ALL cellular phones, and noted that what the articles were claiming was a "problem" unique to the Apple iPhone4, was in fact a normal fact of physics caused whenever you covered an antenna. They also demonstrated that the iPhone4 got BETTER reception than its competition and all previous models of the iPhone.
Once those facts came in, Apple discontinued their stop-gap, free bumper case program, the FUD campaign could not be maintained in light of the flood of countering scientific evidence from around the world and consumers reporting they were NOT experiencing the problems the FUD was claiming they were (the iPhone4 had a far lower level of complaints and returns than any other smartphone), and the iPhone4 still maintains a higher rate of sales than any other single make or model on the market today! Some failure!
As for reviews, for every one you find in favor of the iPad(2), I can find one for the Xoom, etc.
I really doubt that. I've seen those reviews. There aren't that many... And they run about two to one positive to negative on the Xoom,,, and all have some reservations about things like the buggy OS, mailing in to upgrade to 4G, and Flash not working. Most comment about the "rush to market" to beat Apple showing.
You live in denial. You can’t even be objective. Jobs really got you with the koolaid, didn’t he?
I'm posting this on my iPad. :-) I've found it to be a much more pleasant experience to be able to sit on my couch, watch TV and read/reply to FR than being "locked" in front of my desktop.
Even though I've had mine since Fathers Day last year, I still don't think I've exploited all the capabilities of this thing.
I can even remote control my ham radio station with this thing.....
My HTC Evo 4G still has it beat in most areas, and was half the price. Plus, it fits into my shirt pocket!
Your “smartphone” market share numbers are amusing in that if you posted the same thing for iPad, it would own around 90% of every age group.
The hardware differences aren’t nearly as important as the software differences - the iPad has far more software available than its “competitors” (to use the term loosely). Not to mention the fit, finish and friendliness of the iOS itself, which is without peer.
It’s easy to see why Apple stock is at $360/share, and its market cap is now 52% higher than Microsoft’s. It’s now #2 in market cap, behind only Exxon. Bill Gates must be livid. =:-D
“Case and point, iPhone 4.”
I presume you mean “case in point”. ;-)
The “screwed up” iPhone 4 is a product that any of Apple’s competitors would LOVE to have. It’s sold very well, despite massive coverage of a minor design flaw - and one that’s easy to completely avoid.
“though in a growing market of feature-based tablets, the iPad2 has failed. Yes, failed.”
LOL! I’ll make a note to treat anything you post VERY skeptically. Your grasp of reality is nonexistent.
If you hate Apple products, why are you here?
I own an Ipad, and am interested in Apple products. I asked to be put on an Apple ping-list, and I appreciate reading articles that I wouldn’t otherwise find.
You really don’t have to come onto these threads and poop all over them. Really.
One, where did I say I hate Apple products? Two, this is not an exclusive thread. If you can’t handle an oppposing viewpoint, tough.
Grasp of reality? When Apple execs response to the antenna issue is “you’re holding it wrong” and then acknowledges the flaw, its a massive PR fail.
That’s reality. I swear I have yet to hear a single objective Apple fan.
If you’re amused by the numbers, complain to Nielsen. Or are they anti Apple too?
You’re right, it was a PR disaster.
Human factors testing can only go so far in the lab, and given the issue they had with someone losing a pre-production model in a bar; can only go so far out in the world.
The iphone isn’t the first mobile device to have antenna issues, and it probably won’t be the last. I used to have an antenna issue with the Motorola RAZR I had before my 3GS. The way I would sometimes like to hold it, would cause the same attenuation problems the iPhone 4 had.
I learned not to hold it that way.
I’ve also had reception issues with portable radios and my OTA HD reception. RF is an imperfect medium, and cell tower coverage is not uniform.
Yep. It’s a difficult lesson learning not everyone holds a phone the same way. But its a lesson every manufacturer has learned.
My choice was between the iPhone and Droid X. It came down to screensize, comfort and features for me. I went with the Dx. It has its quirks but absolutely no regrets. If a non-work tablet is in the future, I will continue to comparison shop.
So, why are you here? To shoot down apple products that you DON’T hate? To “oppose” an informational thread? It’s annoying. I skip most of your comments, but you seem to have a mission or something.
Here are the numbers that matter:
100,000,000 iPhones sold
15,000,000 iPads sold in 9 months
15,000 native iPad apps
200,000,000 iTunes accounts
$2,000,000,000 paid out to iOS developers
The hardware. numbers don’t even count the millions more iPod Touch devices. (You know, iPods - the devices that continue to dominate their category despite endless claims others were iPod “killers”. LOL)
Android has a looooooong way to go to compete...plus the profit margins are weaker. ;-)
I ride a Yamaha motorcycle, many people think its a Harley, and without bashing the American icon my bike had just the features I needed, was more affordable and has certain pieces of engineering that are arguably troublefree.
But I won’t park it outside a joint that is all Harleys.
I am for the first time considering one of these portable pads as I will be traveling to Australia later this year and I don’t want a bulky laptop.
What percentage of iPhone owners do you suppose use a case? I do, and I think you’d be crazy not to...and that COMPLETELY eliminates any issue.
The whole thing was a tempest in a teapot.
I’m sorry you got stuck with an inferior product...
i have yet to understand the sturm and drang on the Apple threads. i appreciate swordmakers threads for info. My daughter and i both have IPhones [she’s 22yo. i am not geriatric] my husband and son have droids [only bc they are on verizon and my daughter and i are on ATT]. We are all happy with our phones. I am considering an ipad and was interested in this thread. I think we are all big boys and girls and able to discern for ourselves what we want. i think the Apple haters are far more vitriolic than those who happen to like apple products and i just don’t get why all the hate.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.