One-stop-shots are the best, but they come with recoil. So to balance it, why not have a gun that can unload thirty rounds? No aggressor will take that lightly - if at all.
Anyway, it's an option for those who really just can't stand recoil.
Posted on 03/23/2011 12:14:47 AM PDT by krogers58
Looking for some advice for a concealed carry weapon for the wife. We were thinking a semi-auto, clip fed weapon. She seems intimidated by the recoil on my 9mm (Glock), and was wondering if there was a decent handgun that would give her more confidence with aiming and firing. I was thinking of something like a .380, but I've never shot them to compare them to a 9mm. Obviously they shoot a smaller cartridge, but the gun seems much lighter and would seem to be more susceptible to kick-back. Maybe I'm wrong. I think a .25 auto might be too light. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
I’d get her a short barreled .357 or .38 revolver. Get one without a hammer. No slide or mag for her to bother with. Just grab it and shoot, really simple like. The .357 has uber stopping power too. FAR more than the .380(or even a 9mm).
Smith & Wesson Model 632 Carry Comp Pro .327 Federal Magnum Revolver
.380 aren’t all that bad. They’ve got pretty much the same caliber as a 9mm, just not as much powder behind it. Range vs shot placement are the two biggest factors there. Chances are if a woman needs it, it’s going to be at point blank range to very short range.
About the Glock though look into a 9mm Springfield XD or some other brand. Your wife’s problem with the Glock recoil may actually be due to the larger grips on a Glock and not really the recoil of the round.
Stay away from the .25, quite possibly the worst round ever made. You’re better off with a pistol that shoots .22lr.
try a compact Smith&Wesson MP9...has the ability to change the grip size which might help with some of the recoil issues
I am sure you will get a lot of good advice here on FR, but what is comfortable to shoot for practice or self defense classes is so important. Get some range time BEFORE you buy.
I have only had one incidence of flinching, it was a nightmare. I found it is nearly impossible to hit what I was shooting at with my eyes closed.
I agree there, go with a hammerless revolver.
Only thing lacking really is capacity. Best case scenario shots never get fired even if the gun does get pulled, so capacity doesn’t matter.
Worst case... after that first round the bad guy’s day is pretty much ruined so the followups are just to make sure he doesn’t get back up. Anymore than 3 rounds here and haven’t been training enough.
“I have only had one incidence of flinching, it was a nightmare. I found it is nearly impossible to hit what I was shooting at with my eyes closed.”
I find if I shoot with my eyes open I don’t flinch so much! ;)
It will also never ‘jam’ or malfunction.
One-stop-shots are the best, but they come with recoil. So to balance it, why not have a gun that can unload thirty rounds? No aggressor will take that lightly - if at all.
Anyway, it's an option for those who really just can't stand recoil.
Now you give me advice. It is 52 years too late, but thanks for the effort.
How about a .45 with sub-sonic loads. Very comfortable to shoot, makes big holes.
3” barrel .38 revolver.
Lew Horton used to order them up from S&W.
Not always easy to find, but the best compromise between a snub-nose and a too large pistol.
Slightly longer barrel dampens recoil, revolver is SIMPLE to operate and check that it is, or is not, loaded.
Not true. I have had revolvers malfunction and break for me while at the range. It was rare and amongst many thousands of rounds fired, but it can happen. One instance is why my blued Ruger Security-Six now has a stainless ejection rod.
Perhaps the “seems intimidated by the recoil” needs a bit more thought. I’d be reluctant to unnecessarily compromise the primary purpose of self-protection. To me, the .45 ACP is the very best defensive round.
For a lightweight carry weapon, consider the Glock 36. It’s one of the lightest (unloaded) firearms on the market. Gotta love the Glock’s point-and-shoot simplicity, reliability, and durability.
For those with small hands, it uses a single-stack magazine. I recommend adding the magazine extender, which gives you a better grip; otherwise, your pinky finger hangs loose. You only get 8 rounds (6+1+1) to carry, BUT you get a very lightweight carry weapon; and, after all, how many rounds are you realistically/probably/likely going to need?
It’s really about trade-offs. Getting used to the recoil may be your best overall choice.
Don’t get a .25, a .22 long rifle has more power than a .25. .380s have enough for defensive use and you can get some good ones. However, the recoil on them is more than one would think but not as severe as a 9MM.
The question will be whether she can operate the slide or not. Some women don't have the grip strength for small frame automatics. I have seen some women that can't pull the trigger on DA/SA autos in the double action mode.
If she learns to handle the 9mm, I recommend a Glock 26 with a proper holster. Small, simple, high capacity. With the right ammo you can do a lot of damage.
If we are talking concealed then I want a nice silver plated snub nose .38 that I can jab into someones ribs because I don’t like to miss.
If you watch the movie Police Academy, the character Tackleberry might have a couple of suggestions for you.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.