Skip to comments.CA Judge Deems Ramming Jewish Woman with Shopping Cart ‘Free Speech’
Posted on 01/04/2012 9:10:56 AM PST by Lmo56
Back in June of 2010 a leader of a pro-Palestinian student group at University of Berkeley allegedly rammed a Jewish woman with a shopping cart as she staged a counter-protest to an anti-Israel Apartheid Week rally conducted by the Muslim Student Association and Students for Justice in Palestine. The counter-protest was dubbed Israel Wants Peace Week.
Now, U.S. District Court Judge Richard Seeborg has deemed that the Muslim students who harassed Jessica Felber and other Jewish students were simply engaging in protected political speech.
(Excerpt) Read more at news.yahoo.com ...
Only in California ...
Now that's quite a concept.
Now that's quite a concept.
The next ruling from this judge or one his ilk will be when he says that killing or maiming a Jew is considered free speech especially if it by a Muzzie. Watch for it because it will happen because Leftism is inherently anti-Semitic.
Biographical Directory of Federal Judges
Seeborg, Richard G.
Born 1956 in Landstuhl, Germany
Federal Judicial Service:
Judge, U. S. District Court, Northern District of California
Nominated by Barack Obama on August 6, 2009, to a seat vacated by Maxine M. Chesney; Confirmed by the Senate on December 24, 2009, and received commission on January 4, 2010.
U.S. Magistrate Judge, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, 2001-2009
Yale College, B.A., 1978
Columbia University School of Law, J.D., 1981
Law Clerk to Hon. John H. Pratt, U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, 1981-1982
Private practice of law, San Francisco, Calif., 1982-1991
Assistant U.S. Attorney, Northern District of California, 1991-1998
Private practice of law, Palo Alto, Calif., 1998-2001
Herr Seeborg was born in Landstuhl, Germany, was appointed a U.S. Attorney by Bill Clinton, and moved into the judicial slot by Barack Hussein Obama.
So....I can walk up and punch this “judge” in the face, if I disagree with his ruling?
This must be the prelude to allowing fringe groups (Occupy, etc.) get away with violence because it is leftist political mob antics.
If ramming a Jew with a shopping cart is free speech, is ramming a mosque with a fuel tanker protected expression as well?
the longer Americans sit idly by and don;t take to the streets over actions like this, the more our rights will be eroded.
Time has come and gone for some SERIOUS Civil Disobedience when the minions of the government so flagrantly defy common sense and American traditions.
I think we need a law BARRING people who are natural born citizens from holding any position in the Courts.
Where in the hell do these quisling rat bastards come from”:?? Unbelievable,
I think you can only use a shopping cart. Attach one to the front of your car.
Question: Are they really “Leftists” or are they simply “Fascists”?
Both Lenin and Marx were Jews; I don’t understand why the modern American leftists are anti-semitic which is why I pose the question.
Next thing you know, beating a guy to within an inch of his life for espousing the wrong ideas will be excused under the right for labor to organize! Oh! Wait....nevermind.
Nomination to federal district courtOn August 7, 2009, President Barack Obama nominated Seeborg to be a United States district judge on the United States District Court for the Northern District of California. On October 15, 2009, the United States Senate Committee on the Judiciary voted to send Seeborg’s nomination to the full Senate. The Senate confirmed Seeborg by unanimous consent on December 24, 2009.
This judge has just moved the present cold civil war one step closer to hot.
If I were the one assaulted, and got such a ruling from the judge, I would not take it too kindly. I’ll stop there.
Liberal family members have long ago been informed that they are no longer welcome.
A leftist antisemitic judge that doesn't know the history of terrorist organizations.
Neither Lenin, nor Marx were Jewish.
This is a lie started by no other than the Nazis.
Marx was Lutheran. (His father was distantly of paternal Jewish ancestry, mother German, which is the basis for the rumor)
Lenin’s parents were Maria Alexandrovna Ulyanova, a schoolteacher, and Ilya Nikolayevich Ulyanov, a government education official. Lenin was baptised on 28 April 1870 at the local church of St. Nicholas into the Russian Orthodox Church.
There is no appreciable difference in methodology between “Leftists” and “Fascists”; between Lenin and Hitler.
Each time we draw lines of distinction between them we give philosophical cover to bloodthirsty tyrants.
Leftist = Socialist = Fascist = Communist
There are degrees - but, just like someone who is a “little bit pregnant”, it’s just a matter of time before it shows.
Try slaughtering a pig in a mosque.
Nope, that would be “Hate Speech”.
Collectivists control freaks is the best way to describe them. There are self-hating Jews who also hate their fellow Jew. Hitler hated Jews and he was a Leftist. Same with Stalin.
Jews are the guardians of the word of God. God’s words are the instructions of life which are antithetical to collectivism which always results in death and destruction.
I wouldn’t be surprised if more research on this judge yielded info that his parents were Nazi sympathizers.
What the f*&k is he talking about, Dude?
The Socialist Roots of Modern Antisemitism.
Read this and you will wonder no longer why Statists are also almost universally racists.
From the essay....
Capitalism and the market economy encourage racial, ethnic, and religious tolerance, while supporting a plurality of diverse lifestyles and customs. Heavily regulated or socialist economies, in contrast, tend to breed intolerance and ethnic persecution. Socialism leads to low rates of economic growth, disputes over resource use, and concentrated political power-all conditions which encourage conflict rather than cooperation. Ethnic and religious minorities usually do poorly when political coercion is prevalent. Economic collapsesusually associated with interventionismworsen the problem by unleashing the destructive psychological forces of envy and resentment, which feed prejudice and persecution.
While discrimination is present in societies of all kinds, discriminators must pay pecuniary costs for indulging their prejudices in a market setting. Even the prejudiced usually will trade with minorities; bigots attempt to oppress minorities by socializing the costs through government action, but bigots usually are less willing to bear these costs themselves. Repeated commercial interactions also increase the social familiarity of customs or lifestyles that otherwise might be found unusual or alien. Sustained economic growth alleviates political and social tensions by creating more for everybody.
Me again..... Booker T. Washington noticed the same thing in regards to the high quality bricks they learned to make at Tuskegee Institute - that repeated commercial interactions also increased the social familiarity between whites and blacks - and gave local whites a direct benefit to having Tuskegee in their midst - locally produced high quality bricks at a lower price - and social interactions that fostered cooperation and understanding.
So we can ram abortionists with shopping carts now?
How much ramming is acceptable? Can we back up and re-ram? How about weight, is there a limit to the weight allowed with which we ram?
Facepalm ad infinitum.
“So...I can walk up and punch this “judge” in the face, if I disagree with his ruling?”
Nope, not for that, but based upon his ruling, you CAN punch him if you disagree with his politics. Suggest you wait until after he votes in the next election, ask him who he voted for, and if he says he voted for a Democrat, then you beat the living sh!t out of him (or drop a shopping cart on him) because you disagree with his political beliefs.
Just following the law. ;>)
We first had evil SUVs and now we have free speaking assault carts. Stupid is a stupid does, Judge.
The judge’s bio. Makes sense.
“Wow -— assault = free speach
Now that’s quite a concept.”
Well, if that’s going to be established law, I welcome the opportunity to thoroughly use my rights to free speech! And I have some great ideas on whom to speak to!
Hey Your Honor, how many times did you hear your father say he was “just following orders”?
No, but apparently you can ram him with a shopping cart!
BTW, don’t shopping carts usually belong to a supermarket? Were the Muslims cited for STEALING it?
This is the kind of Judge GINGRICH is talking about taking action to REMOVE
What about hitting the judge over the head with a spiked baseball bat? Is that freedom of speech too? What differentiates a shopping cart from a blunt object?
At least this Judge has paved the way for shooting back, without retribution.....
I have no idea.
It appears his hypothesis was:
“Since Lenin and Marx were Jewish (a false statement, as they were Russian Orthodox and Lutheran, respectively), modern leftist must like Jews.”
Aside from the factually-incorrect basis (e.g., neither being Jewish), the basis of the hypothesis seems to be a mismash of:
1. Protocols of Elders of Zion (a Russian forgery which claimed Jews were behind communism)
2. The Mein Kampf, which admitted the Protocols were a fake, but nonetheless embraced them as true in principle
3. Historical ignorance of the fact that leftists (from communist to fascists) have always hated Jewish people.
4. The accident of history whereby European/Russian nationalists hated Jews MORE than leftists hated Jews (and used them as scapegoats), which forced Jews into the leftist camp by default.
The results of 1-4 are idiot posters on FreeRepublic who say things like “Jews voted for Hitler because he was a Democrat!”
This judge needs a menal evaluation! This is insane!
menal = mental
Only when the left does it. After all, those Tea Partiers are the violent ones!!
Do I need a sarcasm tag?
I dunno - Wheels?
menal = a combination of mental and anal. It is the type of exam most often prescribed when the patient has his head planted firmly in his backside.
However, I know we can all agree, the only important thing concerning Lenin is that he is dead. As we used to proudly pronounce in this country, “ The only good Communist, is a dead Communist”
Hey boys and girls, It’s IMPEACHMENT time.
Wow, that’s news to me; I’d always believed Marx, Lenin and Trotsky were Jews.
LOL! I think I know where this is going.
So if I run down a black muslim, that is free speech??
Karl's father Heinrich was not of "distant paternal Jewish ancestry." He was descended from a long line of prominent rabbis, with his father the latest in the line, and was raised Jewish, converting to Lutheranism shortly before Karl was born.
Karl's mother was born into a wealthy Dutch Jewish family, the one that later founded the Phillips Electronics firm. I have no info on whether she ever formally converted.
By Jewish law, of course, Karl was a Jew. Not to mention under the Nuremberg Laws, if they float your boat.