Teacher acquitted of having sex with student 231 times

UK Daily Mail ^ | March 29, 2012

[ConservativeStatement]

A teacher accused of having sex with one of her students 231 times over three years was acquitted yesterday when a judge ruled there was not enough evidence to convict her.

When the not guilty verdict was read out, Deborah Ashton's hands went to her mouth and she starting sobbing.

The 47-year-old was facing five charges of sex crimes against a student who claimed to have been 12 when their sexual relationship began in 2002.

[ConservativeStatement]

Admins: Headline was shortened to fit.

[billorites]

Who keeps count like that?

[PGR88]

After about 15 times, who is counting?

[HiTech RedNeck]

Maybe that was the number of notches on the lad’s bedpost???

[gov_bean_ counter]

Who keeps count like that

A math teacher???

[ClearCase_guy]

Justice Alison Beames said: 'It is a precise number that simply cannot be accepted as reliable and accurate,' adding that the fact the boy could not recall a tattoo on Ashton's stomach which was described by her lawyer as being the 'size of a basketball'.

[allmendream]

The Judge thought the same thing you did.....

“Justice Alison Beames said: ‘It is a precise number that simply cannot be accepted as reliable and accurate,’ adding that the fact the boy could not recall a tattoo on Ashton's stomach which was described by her lawyer as being the ‘size of a basketball’.”

Evidence like that indicates it likely that the boy made it all up. And who knew there were advantages to having a massive tattoo on the ‘naked’ parts of your body?

[ClearCase_guy]

Beat you by 1 second!

[HiTech RedNeck]

I know boys like to brag, but this was downright mean of him.

[lightman]

Who keeps count like that

A math teacher???

Parents got suspicious when it looked like a beaver had been knawing the headboard...kid made too many notches.

[FoxPro]

Not guilty...

[Tucker39]

Maybe this case is like the story about 2 guys who bet each other who could “perform” more often over a weekend. The one guy kept score and wound up with a score of 9.

His buddy just made a pencil mark on the wall at the head of the bed each time he completed a task; winding up with a total of only 3.

Sunday evening, at the end of the competition, the first guy, “Mr. 9” went to his buddy’s room to check. When he walked in, “Mr. 3” just gestured with his hand toward the 3 pencil marks on the wall.

“Mr. 9” just hung his head in shame and exclaimed, “No doubt about it; you’re the winner! Who could imagine such a thing? A hundred and eleven times! What a man!”

[Old Sarge]

Miscarriage of Justice?

[bigbob]

It was only 230 times, I swear!

They should be like married and divorced by now, right?

[null and void]

[Vigilanteman]

Who looks at a tattoo on a woman’s stomach when he’s busy boinking her?

[cuban leaf]

Why would one even tattoo their stomach? Nobody can see it.

[70th Division]

A good teacher would say “We are going to Do It, and Do It, and Do It till we get it right.”

[allmendream]

Well THIS CASE may provide a good reason why.

In fact I would, after reading about this, suggest any man or woman who works with children or otherwise might be subject to such accusations might want to do something similar.

Hard to claim you had a sexual relationship with someone who has prominent tattoos on their naked body and/or sexual parts - and then not be able to describe them.

[flatfish]

Kid needs to have his ass caned in Singapore...

.

[Jonty30]

Was there enough proof that she should have been convicted?

I ask, because the fact that she might go after a 12 year old doesn’t seem as plausible. It almost seems a hit job by the student.

[gunsequalfreedom]

Very sad story for this teacher. It seems it could have reached this conclusion before putting this woman through this hell.

The part about the tatoo should have been enough early on for the prosecutors to know the story was not credible. Sad commentary on the prosecution. Happy the courst finally got it right.

[ßuddaßudd]

Huh? only 231 times?
what is wrong with kids these days...

[Big Horn]

Anyone can make a mistake.

[GladesGuru]

Just so long as they were not dancing!

[GladesGuru]

“Kid needs to have his ass caned in Singapore...

How about importing ‘caners’ to deal with the large number of Ferals in our schools?

[allmendream]

Yes, it seems that this case was a load of garbage.

Kid says he knows they had sex 231 times. Doesn’t know she has a huge tattoo on her belly. Says the majority of times they had sex in the back of her car - and the kid is unable to accurately describe the back of her car.

[The_Media_never_lie]

Where's the crime and who's the victim?

Should’a been my teach.......

[Jack Hammer]

Hey, kids - hate your teacher?

Accuse him/her of having sex with you, and ruin reputation and career, both.

It’s easy, it’s fun, and you’ll even become famous.

[N. Theknow]

Hmmmm. Too obvious to claim that it was 1-2-3 times, so, mix up the numbers to say it was Oh, maybe 2-3-1 times, since 3-2-1 would not be believable.

[Mr.Unique]

...'size of a basketball'...

The tat, or her belly?

[PGalt]

Parents got suspicious when it looked like a beaver had been knawing the headboard...kid made too many notches.

LOL! Bump for beavers!

[Mr.Unique]

Nobody can see it.

Except the teacher's pet.

[Marathoner]

a tattoo on Ashton's stomach which was described by her lawyer as being the ‘size of a basketball’

I guess I'm older than dirt now, but for the life of me I just don't see anything remotely appealing about tattoos period, especially on women.

[allmendream]

I agree completely - but I am starting to see the appeal of a large prominent tattoo near one’s naked parts - just as a easily distinguished mark that could differentiate a false accusation from a real one.

If I worked where such an accusation might be likely and/or could be particularly devastating - I would consider getting one.

[HiTech RedNeck]

This happened in Britain (it refers to the Crown), not the USA — the lawyers are sharper over here and probably would not have let this live as long as it did.

Now the lad doesn’t even have a credible brag any more, and it sure doesn’t sound like anything remotely like an honest mistake. He’ll get in deep dutch for this.

[HiTech RedNeck]

This happened in Britain (it refers to the Crown), not the USA — the lawyers are sharper over here and probably would not have let this live as long as it did.

Now the lad doesn’t even have a credible brag any more, and it sure doesn’t sound like anything remotely like an honest mistake. He’ll get in deep dutch for this.