Skip to comments.Did Scalia Parrot Fox News During Health-Care Arguments?
Posted on 04/06/2012 2:01:41 PM PDT by IndePundit
Is Roger Ailes clerking for Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia?
One might be forgiven for thinking so following last weeks oral arguments on the health-care law before the nations highest court.
As has been pointed out elsewhere, some of Scalias questions from the bench made use of the tone and even the diction of the attacks on the Affordable Care Act frequently heard on Fox News and conservative talk-radio shows.
After Scalia picked up on the idea that a government empowered to have its citizens buy health insurance or face a penalty may also strong arm them into buy some other good, such as broccoli, Charles Fried, who served as solicitor general under President Ronald Reagan, told The Washington Post that the court was trumpeting the most tendentious of the Tea Party arguments.
I even heard about broccoli, Fried said. The whole broccoli argument is beneath contempt. To hear it come from the bench was depressing.
On the second day of arguments, Scalia did indeed invoke the humble crucifer.
Why do you define the market that broadly? Scalia asked Solicitor General Donald Verrilli. Could you define the market? Everybody has to buy food sooner or later, so you define the market as food. Therefore everybody is in the market, therefore you can make people buy broccoli.
(Excerpt) Read more at thedailybeast.com ...
Imagine if Scalia said peas....
Who cares where he got it from? Scalia has enough intelligence in his pinky to write circles around anyone. He sure doesn’t need to get his talking points from FOX news.
He apparently parroted me and millions of other constitution loving Americans.
Now if only we could get them to toss out the interstate commerce clause.
Great Right-Wing Conspiracy Alert!!!
Did Ubama parrot Karl Marx during his health care demagoguery?
Actually, this is just a smarmy way of trying to belittle the arguments.
Sure, lay that drama out there, claw at every desperate inch— Obamabot.
The media has NO place questioning integrity.
They have a garden FULL of weeds and they should tend their own.
There the media goes again— tossing out judgement and opinion as if it is news.
Matthew, I think you look suspiciously like a little girl staring perv behind those shades, I have read such descriptions of pervs before.
Oh, and Bush, Beck nor the mister like broccoli but my dogs do.
I’ve never heard of broccoli being used as an example of something distasteful, EVER...nope.
It was an exclusive, breaking FOX news special. That SOME people don’t like broccoli.
P.S. don’t tell Michelle Obama some have an aversion to the green group, she is liable to hop her broom and torment somebody out of their dinner.
Duh, you idiot DailyBeast, it’s only been in the public square two years now where people have been using the broccoli argument in place of Obama Care... Gawd, these people must live under rocks...
Those scum live in buckets of warm spit. You owe rocks an apology.
Scalia hardly needs Fox News to do ANYTHING for him whatsoever.
The broccoli argument has been out there for years and the Liberal dopes still didn’t have an answer for it.
Forgot the (;^), dps.
What’s worse is that they treat every asking of the question as if it’s the first time someone’s asked it. It’s hysterical.
I seem to recall the Obamists brow-beating and threatening major restaurant chains into changing their menus. To make them more healthy.
In fact, I seem to remember Obamists going after school kids and getting them kicked out of school over their bagged lunches.
Brocolli? Why not.
The sad thing is, Democrats believe this junk.
The key question is ... were any of Scalia’s arguements contained in any of the briefs that were filed? If not, we can have one discussion; if so, then it doesn’t matter whether these arguements leaked over onto Fox News.
Solicitor General Donald Verrilli knows Scalia’s political leanings and should have been prepared to respond intelligently. He failed. That’s the real story.
I think it's an entirely reasonable argument.
The Commie Coercion Claws need to be repealed!
Or send her flying monkeys to steal 4th graders lunches!
But that won't prevent mindless leftwing parrots from claiming it.
If anything Fox parroted Scalia.
So FOX was the one "parroting" and Justice Scalia was referring to that argument. I think it's an entirely reasonable argument as well.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.