Skip to comments.To the Class of 2012 (How many of you are really learned men and women?)
Posted on 05/22/2012 6:49:03 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
05/21/12 Baltimore, Maryland Down, down, down
Day after day for the last 2 weeks almost everything has been grinding down.
Stocks, oil, copper, bond yields It looks as though the whole world economy is slowing down. China, India, America, Europe. All are slowing.
How much longer can this slow down continue?
A lot longer!
We should have some bounce in the markets this week. But beware. Our Crash Alert flag is up.
We spent the weekend in Charlottesville, VA at the UVA graduation for our son, Henry.
The University of Virginia is probably the most handsome campus in America. Especially in May. It has a green central esplanade bordered by columned buildings in the Greco-Roman style. At one end is the famous Rotunda. Flowers and trees bloom everywhere.
We know of no other president who achieved anything equivalent. Some waged dubious wars. Some launched weasely social welfare programs. The best of them idled away their careers, shaking hands, making deals, and otherwise shuffling offstage leaving it no better or worse than it was when the curtain first went up. But Mr. Jefferson left an architectural monument that is breathtaking. He would be proud of it today.
It is too bad that the soliloquies of its 2012 commencement exercises came nowhere close to the grandeur of the setting itself. Instead, there was nothing more than the usual hollow, air-head do-goodism you associate with graduation speakers. One urges students to go out in the world and make a difference. Another tells them to use their educations for some great public purpose. Another insists that they become the leaders of tomorrow. All declare that their years spent (there was no mention of the money) at UVA were a good investment both formative and decisive making them the determined, capable people that they have allegedly become.
Jefferson would roll his eyes.
Herewith, we offer an alternative graduation speech. An honest address to the class of 2012. One we will never be invited to give:
I see you before me. Arranged in alphabetical order. From Mr. Aaron from Alexandria to Mr. Zyman of Richmond. You are all suited up wearing the ancient vêtements that have marked men of learning for hundreds of years. And in a few minutes you will move the tassels on your funny little hats from the right side to the left, indicating that you have been awarded a bachelors degree. This signifies that you have joined the few the elite the learned.
But how many of you really are learned? How many are imposters? How many are capable of writing a simple essay? How many can decline a Latin verb? How many have mastered calculus and quantum physics?
Youve heard about the group of men at the old English club. The waiter comes up and asks if they would like some hock. One of them cleverly says hic, haec, hoc. So the waiter comes back with drinks for all of them except him. When he asks why, the waiter replies: But sir, you declined the hock.
How many of you got that joke?
I only ask the question because I am suspicious. Many college grads of today could hardly be called intellectuals. Many have hardly used their brains at all. Some have merely spent the last four years learning a few tricks and the latest jargon of a trade. Marketing, for example. Or journalism. Marketing evolves so fast that whatever you learn here will be mostly obsolete by the time you get a job. If you ever get a job. Besides, the important points could be picked up in a few weeks on the job anyway.
As to journalism, there are a few skills you need to know, which you could pick up in an afternoon; the rest is undifferentiated. You look. You ask questions. You think. And you tell the world what you come up with. No college necessary. In fact, college may hinder you. Instead of using your own eyes and your own brain, and developing your own way of looking at things, you spent your best years in class absorbing the claptrap du jour of the mainstream media.
Others among you have read popular novels or a few history books. You think you know something. Maybe you call yourself a historian. Or perhaps a literary critic. My advice is to keep that to yourself. You have paid a lot of money for something that millions of other people just as smart as you are do for a hobby or past-time. Theres not much real knowledge in either of those things just opinions and ideas which are more vanity and entertainment than genuine learning.
Same thing for those who have spent years studying politics or economics. Drop the pretense that you know something. You dont. All you have is a full plate of opinions most of them preposterous and most of them indigestible by a thoughtful person.
I dont doubt that many of the courses offered here to say nothing of the beer parties are interesting and fun. But are they worth $160,000 and 4 years of your life? How about some of these titles that I got out of the Course Catalog for 2012: Fantasy and Values or Black Women Authors or the Cinema of India or Feminist Theory in Anthropology, or Creole Narratives or Zen or Business Ethics ?
As to that last one, when you get out in the real world, which unless you go to graduate school is happening as of tomorrow you will find that it is very unlike the make-believe world at this university.
They say that by going to a university you open yourself up to a whole world of knowledge. Yes, perhaps you do gain easy access to a whole world of simplified knowledge and politically correct opinions. But you also cut yourself off from a larger world of real knowledge the kind you get by doing and observing.
In your course on Business Ethics, for example, you are no-doubt exposed to a number of ideas and theories on the subject. Youd be better off learning it on the job. First, instead of paying someone to teach you, you would get paid for learning. Besides, you can get the ideas and information in the course materials by reading a few $29 books or read them online for even less. That is true for almost all the coursework in the arts and social sciences. It is all available to you at much less expense. So, in a sense, you have been a sap to pay so much for it.
But you would do even better to combine your reading with real life experience. And in real life you would quickly discover that things are much more complex, much more nuanced, and much less clear than you thought. Thats true in business ethics as it is in everything else. As the Jewish philosopher Hillel explained, the core idea of the Torah, the Bible, the Sermon on the Mount, and business ethics is as simple as this: if you wouldnt want someone to do it to you, dont do it to someone else. The rest is detail. And the details depend on the situation, which you only encounter in its full complexity, when you are face to face with it. You dont encounter it in a book or in your lecture halls or in your seminars on campus. So, the time you spend on campus actually prevents and delays you from coming to grips with the real problems you will face in real life and thus retards your education.
So, youve spent or your parents or the taxpayers have spent $150,000 on your education. And youre retarded.
And now you enter the job market. And dont think youll have an easy time of it. Because previous graduates of this university and others have applied the lessons they learned in school and made a god-awful mess of the economy. There are 14 million people without jobs. About one in 20 young people is jobless. Youre just another one. Frankly, Im surprised the unemployment rate for young people isnt higher given how worthless most young people are.
Why so many unemployed? Because economics professors have taught 3 generations of economists that a command and control economy to a point will work. It wont. But a command and control economy is good for economists and do-gooders, who get jobs commanding.
Economists convinced policymakers who have their own corrupt reasons for wanting to twist up the economy to control the price of labor and prevent it from falling, using a variety of tools and subterfuges. By the way, a subterfuge is defined in the dictionary as an artifice or expedient used to evade a rule, escape a consequence, hide something, etc.
I mention that because I know that half of you are functionally illiterate. MSNBC recently reported that:
More than 50 percent of students at four-year schools and more than 75 percent at two-year colleges lacked the skills to perform complex literacy tasks.
The results cut across three types of literacy: analyzing news stories and other prose, understanding documents and having math skills needed for checkbooks or restaurant tips.
But one of the subterfuges used by the feds that makes it so hard for you to get a job is student loans. Theyve lent out more than $1 trillion some of it to you. Rather than work for lower wages, students borrow money at low teaser rates and go to school. On average, you have about $20,000 worth of debt when you leave this university. And Ill bet that a lot of you wont pay up.
But Ill give you some advice. String your lenders out as long as possible. Eventually, the same college-educated dimbulbs who perverted the employment market will destroy the dollar. Avoid paying your loan long enough and it will probably go away
Of course, the outlook is not all bad. Some of you will find good jobs those who have used your time wisely, by studying science and engineering. Its only the rest of you who are screwed.
The feds keep the price of labor too high. Employers would have to pay you more than you are worth. So, they are reluctant to hire you.
Employers know damned well too that youve been retarded by your education. So, theyre leery of hiring you. Especially if they see youve taken a class in business ethics. They think youll stab them in the back the first chance you get.
And theyre probably right. Because youve been told to go forth and create a better world. Ive seen the surveys. Two out of three of you want to work for non-profit organizations. Why is that? Because your whole weltanschauung well, I mean, your worldview has been corroded by your education. You think business is greedy selfish and stupid. But where they hell do you think non-profits get their money? Where does the government get its money? How can our society afford to let you waste so many years in college?
All of this money has to come from the productive sector of the economy.
You think you can do good by working for the government or a non-profit organization? Well, Ive got news. Youll be a parasite, just like the rest of them. A leech, sucking the life out of the real, productive economy. Thats another reason its so hard for you to find a job. The more people who fantasize about getting paid for doing good for trying to make a better world the worse the real world gets. Because that leaves fewer people actually doing the kind of real world work that makes the world richer and more prosperous and better organized safer and healthier.
So, forget about making the world a better place. Forget about leading anybody anywhere. Forget about thinking you know something. You dont know enough to lead yourself, let alone anyone else. And most of what you think you know is worthless claptrap. Pseudo-knowledge, in other words.
Finally, dont try to be a leader. The world doesnt need any more leaders. Its got too many already.
Instead, try to find a real job in the real world. Do it well. And mind your own business.
Thank you. And good luck.
Bill Bonner for The Daily Reckoning
I’m in gradudate school now and it’s no different. They throw up about a zillion powerpoints, then test you on them. Few if any of these students even buy or read the textbooks anymore.
The only “pursuit” is the pursuit to pass with a certain percentage and check all the blocks. Also to kiss the butt of whatever ego maniac PhD stands up there and prances around, spewing their extreme knowledge of the subject matter. Most of them know they have you by the nuts, and will fail those that rub them the wrong way for minor mistakes.
All a big game anymore — an expensive one.
Corporations COULD change things by dropping the requirements for a college degree. They COULD do their own apprenticeships, do their own training and teaching — and they could test the mettle of the employees along the way. But it’s the employers that demand we get these worthless degrees, so what can you do?
this is a great read.
Not sure how well this would go over with colleges, if a speaker comes in and takes issue with how their students are educated.
But, he really hits home with the overall point, that the college campus is very different from the real world. The students will find the world a very different place from the cocoon of a college campus. They will feel very differently about “evil” corporations, when they find the desire to get a job, overrides their liberal theology that business is evil.
The bottom line is that a diploma is just a scrap of paper that gets someone in the front door. This is the case because the federal courts, in their, ahem, wisdom, have decided that diplomas are the only written tool that can be used that defy racism in hiring practices.
And, as the rule has long said, “If you wish to destroy something of value, make it mandatory.”
Yet their is the unavoidable rule that scholarship is what the individual makes of it. A person intent on becoming learned and proficient is hard to stop, if the tools they need for their education exist at all.
One of the great mathematicians of history was an impoverished orphan, who as a young boy practiced writing equations with found chalk rock on tombstones in a cemetery.
Many great thinkers have come to be not because they were educated in schools, but by having access to a library after learning how to read.
Only in the last few decades has the US developed schools for “genius” students only, that were able to provide them the academic resources far beyond ordinary schools.
Good points. It’s evolved so that colleges and companies have certain expectations. The companies insist on hiring college graduates, thinking that the college degrees indicate that they have the knowledge or at least the desire to put in the effort to get through college. Students and families go into debt to get these degrees. A certain number of college graduates are rewarded with good jobs in the end.
You can learn the basics of marketing, accounting, management, journalism, and many other things, by working on the job, rather than spending four years in college. But, companies do not have a pathway into many fields in which they provide on the job training like that. Instead they insist on hiring college graduates.
So, with marketing for example, you just won’t get hired unless you have a degree in marketing.
Many people I know tell me that they learned far more on the job, in the first couple of years out of college, than they learned about their fields in college. Basically, they learned that there is the “theory” as taught in college, and then they learn how things are actually done in the “real world”.
Just forwarded this to my daughter who just graduated from the University of Dallas with a BS in Mathematics. Very proud of our girl!!
I have told my kids numerous times over the years ---- you can read anything you want outside of the classroom, but you major in something that will enable you to get a good job. No basket weaving, no "wymen's studies", etc.
So son is a mechanic (and very happy) and who knows what life will bring for the math major, but it is a hard science and UD was an EXCELLENT choice. Highly recommend it for any potential student (be prepared to be challenged big time).
We've always had waiters. They didn't always have bachelor's degrees. It's no skin off my teeth if a guy wants to spend thousands of dollars and four years to learn some useless information. He'll likely forget it all in a few years if not sooner. All so that he can spend his life doing menial jobs and perhaps landing an assistant manager position and making far less than a plumber.
The one thing most of these articles (and there have been many) don't address is the issue of intelligence. Humans did not suddenly become 50% more intelligent. And 50% of humans did not suddenly evolve higher intelligence. Half the people have less than 100 IQ. I would imagine anyone with below 110 IQ having an extremely difficult time passing an engineering program.
Think about the math on this one. We know that not all of the intelligent people go to college (ala Rush Limbaugh), but even if we have approaching 100% of above average intelligence people enrolled in college, once participation grows beyond 50%, we have by definition, college students of below average intelligence. The greater the participation rate, the lower average IQ of the college student. The current participation rate is ~70%.