Skip to comments.MLB Expands Instant Replay to Let Managers Challenge Calls
Posted on 01/16/2014 12:22:27 PM PST by ColdOne
On Thursday, Major League Baseball formally approved the use of instant replay for the 2014 season. Under the new system, managers will have one challenge they can use. If their challenge is successful, managers will be able to retain that challenge and use it one more time during the game for a maximum of two challenges per game.
After the start of the seventh inning, the crew chief of the game may choose to use instant replay on any reviewable call even if a manager is out of challenges, according to Major League Baseball's announcement:
(Excerpt) Read more at breitbart.com ...
I hate it.
So end baseball.
Baseball really should be electronically officiated, there’s nothing going on in the game that couldn’t be handled with RFIDs, pressure sensors, and Hawk-Eyes. Then there’d be no need for reviews, and they could fire most of their terrible umps.
Joe West being on the top of the list to be fired first!!!
They’ve done the impossible....come up with a replay rule that is even more screwed-up than the NFL’s.
As if three hours isn’t long enough for a baseball game.
I like it, so many bad calls.
I think the crew chief should be able to challenge any call though not just after the 7th inning, runs scored or not scored in the first inning count just as much as any other.
Will push average game times to over 4 hours.
I agree. It takes something away from the game.
Agree, but are all MLB games going to become 4 hour marathons? Every game becoming BOS-NYY isn’t a positive.
My guess is there will be very few challenges made by managers. I’m thinking the repercussions of showing up and ump won’t be worth one or two overturned calls.
Nothing ruins the game more than your team losing over a bad call. Ask the fans of the 1985 Cardinals.
I don’t blame the umps for bad calls, they are human, the game is very fast and I am amazed they don’t make even more mistakes.
However, this system SUXXXXXX.
Football’s IR has become a game with in the game, Baseball should be like Hockey and have another ump in booth that can over ride calls as need be.
Have you ever seen what Curt Shilling thinks of that?
Let’s shoot for 12 hours...just like cricket!
I doubt it, because the first question any manager would get with the press is “Why didn’t you challenge that play?”.
Football coaches don’t worry about Refs taking it out on them, and refs in football have a lot more lee-way in what they call or not
He is now back in the minors and his one shot at making the history books was thrown away by Jim Joyce not doing his job.
Personally I like the idea of electronic umpires. The human ones even when they are paying attention tend to be erratic in their calls.
Three hours? Last season the AZ Diamondbacks played 78 extra innings. And my FIL watched every stinking game they played. I was rooting for them to NOT make the playoffs so I could shut the TV off for a few months.
I’d like to the the balls and strikes digitized. You could do it with lasers. The only wrinkle is sizing each batter waist to shoulder.
Hate it too. Is the “neighborhood” play at 2nd on double plays going to be out now? Are we looking at more broken ankles and legs to middle infielders?
Are they going to look at whether the ball was moving around in the glove to determine possession like the NFL on pass receptions which has become inconsistent?
Actually the neighborhood play is exempt from review
Force play (except the fielder’s touching of second base on a double play)
I guess the only good thing about this is they limit it to two challenges (4 max), so hopefully it won’t do too much to the game.
That’s good. I’d still rather see the umpires get together first and try to get the call correct.
Spring Training should be fun as they iron out the kinks.
And possibly just the availability of challenges will keep the umps a bit more on their toes.
They gotta stop letting guys take so long between pitches. If 20 seconds pass, call a ball.
I like it. But also the batter. Now it's step out, adjust gloves, scratch whatever, flip the bat, paw the dirt, endless adjusting position in box, pointing bat at pitcher, spit a few times and then get ready. When the pitcher is ready, he can pitch.
There's a significant amount of baseball in it, what with the '27 Yanks, Ruth's 60 HR, and so forth.
Bryson says the average game in '27 took less than 90 minutes to play. He specifically sites a Yankees double-header that was played in under 2:45.
Absolutely, batters shouldn’t be given an unlimited number of “time outs” anymore, that’s just as bad as the pitchers taking too long.
What’s important is getting the call correct, but the replay system has to be quick enough. The review should be limited to 90 seconds, like in the NFL.
It shouldn’t be too hard to fit everybody with those little targets they use to electronically overlay cartoon type characters onto human body movements. Then they could give the plate umpire a stool and he could sit twelve feet behind home and read novels ‘til a decision is needed.
Teams will be allowed to have a club employee monitoring video and communicating with the manager whether or not to challenge. Both the home and road teams must have equal access to all video, but no additional electronic equipment will be allowed. Camera angles in all parks will also be standardized.
Refs and umps are very different, at least presently. Umpires have control in baseball not so much in football. Football is more like the inmates running the prison. When’s the last time you saw a ref run a coach in football?
No reason an official in the booth can’t review questionable calls throughout the game without putting the burden on the managers.
I recall him saying at one point that part of his tape review for game prep was reviewing the ump to get a handle on the size and shape of the ump’s strike zone. And the fact that so many umps have “their” strike zone rather than THE strike zone is often listed as part of the problem with MLB officiating. So I’d guess he’d come out for things that ended custom strike zones, unless he likes the competitive advantage given to pitchers that review ump tapes.
He beat a strike-zone camera to pieces as he was walking away from an at-bat.
(So I’d guess he prefers Pitchers who review the calls have an advantage. Part of the game.)
Well I’ll have to disagree with him, the fact that no two umps call the same strike zone in the same league is one of problems with MLB.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.