Skip to comments.Jackie Evancho - Nessun Dorma (from PBS Great Performances)
Posted on 02/23/2014 4:59:14 PM PST by Windflier
Enjoy one of the most beautiful renditions of Nessum Dorma you will ever hear.
From Jackie's Guest appearance on America's Got Talent (2011).
I don’t think anyone has ever sung an operatic aria as well Jackie at that age.
What planet is she from? Can’t be from here on Earth!
Wonderful,wonderful voice but Nessun Dorma sung in soprano just doesn’t reach the heights and crispness as that sung by a male tenor. IMHO
I dont think anyone has ever sung an operatic aria as well Jackie at that age.
No offense, but the late great Beverly Sills could sing rings around this kid.
La Sills is TEN here.
Oh, gosh, Placido ...
I’m going to have to watch my DVD of “Carmen” again. Caliente!
Roberto Alagna - La Marseillaise
I will listen. Sills was great singer but was unaware she was great at 10.
now listen to one of the best tenors ever
Mario Lanza’s “Nessun Dorma”
My honest opinion, the recording of 10-year-old Sills was not of sufficient quality to judge whether she was better at that age than Jackie Evancho. Not saying she wasn’t.
when music is terribly great, many humans do not need to understand a single word being sung to appreciate the performance - there is something about the vibrations in beautifully created melodic verse donw with perferct pitch, it simply “resonates” at a level from which most people “feel” it whether understanding it or not
Sublime. Unlike this gentleman’s smooth articulation, Placido Domingo’s Italian has just a hint of Mexico, or perhaps I imagine it. Also his French.
If there’s one tenor showpiece I can’t hear too many times ... this isn’t it. It’s “La Donna e Mobile.”
She is truly a once in an era phenomenon. There have been other young girl sopranos, but none with the depth of feeling and artistic expression of Jackie. I really believe she's in a class all her own.
That's a common reaction to Jackie's vocals and performance. Her voice is so magical, one could be forgiven for thinking she's been sent from heaven to heal the world.
So true. Music is a universal language.
Why is a soprano singing an aria written for tenor?
It makes no sense.
There are easily a dozen soprano arias a young soprano could tackle to showcase her talent.
Choosing this over hyped over played tenor aria just smacks of pop opera dumbed down to appeal to the masses.
That was absolutely astonishing!!! What a gift she..and we, who get to listen, have been given.
I notice on the subsequent posts no Pavarotti...he was always my gold standard for Nessun Dorma.
Because it's heavenly and heals something deep in the soul. Relax and just enjoy.
I've been listening to Jackie since she first appeared on the national stage, and I am still blown away by her performances. Even ones I've listened to a hundred times can still create a powerful effect on me.
There is something unique about this young girl that is hard to put into words. I suppose it's simply that she has the power to reach others with a depth that few artists possess.
There is a sweetness and richness to her voice and in such an angelic package.
Honestly, I got choked up....
I've gotten something in my eye on more than one occasion listening to Jackie. That's what I mean about her ability to touch others at a depth that's extraordinary.
I honestly believe she's going to go down as one of the most important vocalists of all time. What a gift to be living at a time when I can witness and appreciate such a talent first hand.
Acting comes before singing; acting comes before dance. No matter how well something is sung, it's missing a lot if it isn't acted well. Nessun Dorma should be delivered as if Turnadot might cut the singer's head off at the next moonrise. That's my critique of the young girl singing the piece. Here's lighter example with Bartoli and Fleming plotting to meet their lovers in the pines: Sull Aria. Aside from the flawless singing, look at the brilliant acting.
I wish I could just enjoy her.
I’m a fan of good singing.
Where you enjoy Jackie’s voice, I hear a young girl with some natural talent forcing and darkening her young voice to sound unnaturally older. That trick is very dangerous to her young voice.
She needs to find a good voice teacher and fast before she develops some worse habits.
Beverly Sills was classically trained by Estelle Liebling, a former soprano and voice teacher who was the last student of Mathilde Marchesi. While Sills started voice lessons at a young age, Liebling never forced Sills voice beyond its years. Instead, Sills spent years just learning how to sing properly by mastering vocalises.
When the Sills voice matured with age, the technique was solidly in place.
If young Jackie wants to go down the opera road, she needs to be taught to sing correctly and to learn a correct technique, otherwise she will ruin her voice for opera.
She would be better suited to a pop route, but she still needs to learn to sing correctly and have some formal training. I wish her the best.
I’ll get off my soap box now.
I wish that for you too. Good art is so much more than technical perfection. Above all is the power to touch people through the medium of artistic expression, and Jackie does that like few others.
One of the things people like most about Jackie, is her ability to put so much physical emotion into a song. Watching her sing, it's easy to imagine she's telling a personal story. She really is a visual/auditory experience.
That link was a better example of the manifestation of Sills' early talent. Whether better than Evancho at tat age, I'll let experts judge.
I don’t know much about opera but I do know that I really can’t stand to listen to this girl sing. I acknowledge that she has a great voice but something about her singing just grates on me. I don’t understand it since I have tried to listen/watch her and wind up walking away perturbed. lol
“Acting comes before singing; acting comes before dance. No matter how well something is sung, it’s missing a lot if it isn’t acted well.”
Acting cannot save a voice that is just not that great.
Most music is listened to, not observed. That is why it takes special talent to put more than just vocal skills, but emotions, into a great performance; emotions such that you can close your eyes and feel the whole thing in your mind.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.