Skip to comments.Father jailed for beating pregnant daughter after she refused abortion
Posted on 06/06/2014 6:56:58 PM PDT by Morgana
FREMONT, OH, June 6, 2014 (LifeSiteNews.com) -- A 36-year old Ohio man has been sentenced to 12 months in prison after pleading guilty to fifth-degree domestic violence, a felony, for beating his then-17-year old daughter after she told him she did not want to have an abortion.
In June 2013, Brian Schultz took his daughter, then several months pregnant, to an abortion clinic to set up an appointment for an abortion. After the daughter said she wanted to keep the child, Schultz and his wife, 41-year old Renee Schultz, began striking her. Credit: Shutterstock.com
Moments after his daughter testified against him on Thursday, Schultz pled guilty to the felony charge. The charges were dropped against his wife because the victim wanted her to be able to take care of the family's two younger girls.
Assistant Prosecutor Lorrain Croy told LifeSiteNews that "this indictment was for felony five domestic violence." While "domestic violence is a first degree misdemeanor on a first offense, with a possible 12 month sentence in the local jail," a victim's pregnancy "enhance[s]" charges "to a fifth degree felony, with 6 months mandatory incarceration and up to total of 12 months incarceration, she said.
Croy said the trial began on June 4, and Schultz pled guilty after his daughter concluded her testimony. "The judge sentenced him to 12 months and his bond was revoked and he was taken into custody. He was delivered to the prison on June 6, 2014, she said.
The couple was held on $50,000 bond per person for two days last year after charges were filed.
Click "like" if you are PRO-LIFE!
Ohio has laws outlining crimes against the unborn, but Croy said that fetal laws did not apply for two reasons. The first was that, despite victim testimony that she was struck in the face and stomach,"the injury was to the victim -- the daughter. She had bumps and bruises on her face and arms. There was NO injury to the baby."
Croy noted that the baby was born healthy and full-term on December 20, 2013. The baby is doing well and thriving. The victim is healthy but suffers emotionally from this violence, she said.
The other reason was the extent of the injuries. "Had there been more serious injury, the charges would have been more severe," explained Croy.
It appears that the victim protected her baby from the strikes to her stomach, which left bruising on her arms, but not her stomach.
"There is a family history of violence between the parents," Croy told LifeSiteNews. "The mother was convicted of falsification for claiming the last time that Brian Schultz was charged with domestic violence, she lied. Law enforcement then charged her with falsification and she was found guilty. Thereafter, the domestic charges against Brian were dismissed."
"The tragedy is the broken relationships between the victim and her own mother and the victims younger two sisters," said Croy. She said that "the family has ex-communicated the victim, and the mother and family members of Brian are attacking the victims character with false allegations and lies." This is happening despite how "the victim helped take care of the two sisters for many years in the home as the mother worked to support the family, she said.
"Brian Schultz was unemployed with no indication of disability or other reasons why he wouldnt work," said Croy. "The victim would get her sisters ready for school and help them in the afternoons. Such a sad loss for the victim."
"I spent a great deal of time with the victim and I have no doubt as to her veracity, sincerity, physical and emotional injury that she has suffered from her father, and the grief she suffers from the loss of the relationship with her own sisters."
Father goes to jail, but the mother sounds even more worthless. Sounds like the daughters didn’t have a chance.
Sounds to me like the pro life community will be there for her. Let’s pray.
The story here and from the local papers makes it sound like this has been part for the course with this couple for years. Too bad the daughter isn’t in a financial position to take care of her siblings and let the mom sit in jail where she belongs.
Give the guy a break, he’s pro choice.
The father sound like a pos
Why was she having sex outside of marriage anyway? WHAT a chump. Not a good Christian girl.
I hope so. Prayers for her.
Is the dad the father of his daughter’s baby?
You’re a moron.
Sounds like something from Saudi Arabia.
Christian girls get knocked up, too. Probably less likely to be on the pill or get an abortion.
Not less likely to have premarital and underage sex? Then they aren’t good Christians, as the poster said
My POINT was, why was a good Christian girl having sex? She had to have sex to get knocked up. As least, that's the way I remember it.
Where was her father all this time?
Sorry if I was not clear. Less likely to use contraception to prevent pregnancy and less likely to use abortion to terminate a pregnancy. So more likely to end up knocked up despite possibly lower levels of activity.
I was in a local pro life center and heard this little horror story. I won't name names but here it is. A local preacher of a big church in the area forced his teen daughter to have an abortion because he did not want him or his church to be embarrassed because of her out of wedlock pregnancy. So yes the baby is dead, the teen is wounded just so everything can be hunky-doory at that church with that minister. Now I don't know that the minister's girl or this child in this story are or are not "good Christians". I'm not here to judge. I'm here to keep babies from being slaughtered and women from being wounded. Can we keep our focus on this and pray for their salvation afterwards?
Her Parents were abusive I’m not surprised this teen fell prey to some guy who left her pregnant. This happens alot in dysfunctional families.
Well said on your other points. Prayer is the way to go.
Have mercy, my friend. She’s a young girl from a very (obviously) broken family. Thank goodness the baby wasn’t murdered. Pray for all involved.
Yes, baby is alive. That is a true blessing.
“So a child was murdered and a young girl damaged all so this preacher could save face. Sad. “
Like I said everyone makes a mistake even a preacher’s kid.
I can’t believe we are having a talk about rather or not the girl in this story was or was not a “good Christian” when her parents were so abusive it sounds like they never “good Christians” themselves. Hey I could be wrong but from the sounds of it what “good Christian” wants to kill their grand baby so much so that not only do they take her to an abortion mill but when she does not comply they beat her?
Like I said you all. I’m here for the baby and the woman.
You all pray for their salvation afterwards but save both before.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.