Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Seven million died in the 'forgotten' holocaust
Toronto Sun ^ | 11/16/03 | ERIC MARGOLIS

Posted on 11/16/2003 10:05:24 AM PST by freedom44

Five years ago, I wrote about the unknown Holocaust in Ukraine. I was shocked to receive a flood of mail from young Americans and Canadians of Ukrainian descent telling me that until they read my column, they knew nothing of the 1932-33 genocide in which Josef Stalin's Soviet regime murdered seven million Ukrainians and sent two million more to concentration camps.

How, I wondered, could such historical amnesia afflict so many? For Jews and Armenians, the genocides their people suffered are vivid, living memories that influence their daily lives. Yet today, on the 70th anniversary of the destruction of a quarter of Ukraine's population, this titanic crime has almost vanished into history's black hole.

So has the extermination of the Don Cossacks by the communists in the 1920s, the Volga Germans in 1941 and mass executions and deportations to concentration camps of Lithuanians, Latvians, Estonians and Poles. At the end of World War II, Stalin's gulag held 5.5 million prisoners, 23% of them Ukrainians and 6% Baltic peoples.

Almost unknown is the genocide of two million of the USSR's Muslim peoples: Chechens, Ingush, Crimean Tatars, Tajiks, Bashkirs and Kazaks. The Chechen independence fighters who today are branded as "terrorists" by the U.S. and Russia are the grandchildren of survivors of Soviet concentration camps.

Add to this list of forgotten atrocities the murder in Eastern Europe from 1945-47 of at least two million ethnic Germans, mostly women and children, and the violent expulsion of 15 million more Germans, during which two million German girls and women were raped.

Among these monstrous crimes, Ukraine stands out as the worst in terms of numbers. Stalin declared war on his own people in 1932, sending Commissars V. Molotov and Lazar Kaganovitch and NKVD secret police chief Genrikh Yagoda to crush the resistance of Ukrainian farmers to forced collectivization.

Ukraine was sealed off. All food supplies and livestock were confiscated. NKVD death squads executed "anti-party elements." Furious that insufficient Ukrainians were being shot, Kaganovitch - virtually the Soviet Union's Adolf Eichmann - set a quota of 10,000 executions a week. Eighty percent of Ukrainian intellectuals were shot.

During the bitter winter of 1932-33, 25,000 Ukrainians per day were being shot or died of starvation and cold. Cannibalism became common. Ukraine, writes historian Robert Conquest, looked like a giant version of the future Bergen-Belsen death camp.

The mass murder of seven million Ukrainians, three million of them children, and deportation to the gulag of two million more (where most died) was hidden by Soviet propaganda. Pro-communist westerners, like The New York Times' Walter Duranty, British writers Sidney and Beatrice Webb and French Prime Minister Edouard Herriot, toured Ukraine, denied reports of genocide, and applauded what they called Soviet "agrarian reform." Those who spoke out against the genocide were branded "fascist agents."

The U.S., British, and Canadian governments, however, were well aware of the genocide, but closed their eyes, even blocking aid groups from going to Ukraine.

The only European leaders to raise a cry over Soviet industrialized murder were, ironically and for their own cynical and self-serving reasons, Hitler and Italian dictator Benito Mussolini.

Because Kaganovitch, Yagoda and some other senior Communist party and NKVD officials were Jewish, Hitler's absurd claim that communism was a Jewish plot to destroy Christian civilization became widely believed across a fearful Europe.

When war came, U.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt and British PM Winston Churchill allied themselves closely to Stalin, though they were well aware his regime had murdered at least 30 million people long before Hitler's extermination of Jews and gypsies began. Yet in the strange moral calculus of mass murder, only Germans were guilty.

Though Stalin murdered three times more people than Hitler, to Roosevelt he remained "Uncle Joe."

The British-U.S. alliance with Stalin made them his partners in crime. Roosevelt and Churchill helped preserve history's most murderous regime, to which they handed over half of Europe in 1945.

After the war, the left tried to cover up Soviet genocide. Jean-Paul Sartre denied the gulag even existed.

For the western Allies, Nazism was the only evil; they could not admit being allied to mass murderers. For the Soviets, promoting the Jewish Holocaust perpetuated anti-fascism and masked their own crimes.

The Jewish people, understandably, saw their Holocaust as a unique event. It was Israel's raison d'etre. Raising other genocides at that time would, they feared, diminish their own. This was only human nature.

While today, academia, the media and Hollywood rightly keep attention focused on the Jewish Holocaust, they mostly ignore Ukraine. We still hunt Nazi killers, but not communist killers. There are few photos of the Ukraine genocide or Stalin's gulag, and fewer living survivors. Dead men tell no tales.

Russia never prosecuted any of its mass murderers, as Germany did.

We know all about the crimes of Nazis Adolf Eichmann and Heinrich Himmler; about Babi Yar and Auschwitz.

But who remembers Soviet mass murderers Dzerzhinsky, Kaganovitch, Yagoda, Yezhov and Beria? Were it not for writer Alexander Solzhenitsyn, we might never know of Soviet death camps like Magadan, Kolyma and Vorkuta. Movie after movie appears about Nazi evil, while the evil of the Soviet era vanishes from view or dissolves into nostalgia.

The souls of Stalin's millions of victims still cry out for justice.

TOPICS: Culture/Society; News/Current Events; Russia
KEYWORDS: anniversary; communism; genocide; history; josefstalin; russia; soviets; stalin; ukraine; ussr
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 61-8081-100101-120121-135 next last
Comment #81 Removed by Moderator

To: caltrop
Yes, I do remember that film. I even have a copy of it on tape somewhere around here...
82 posted on 11/16/2003 3:52:59 PM PST by karen999
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 38 | View Replies]

To: freedom44
The only European leaders to raise a cry over Soviet industrialized murder were, ironically and for their own cynical and self-serving reasons, Hitler and Italian dictator Benito Mussolini.

It's interesting that a lot of Lefties defend the support that Leftists gave the Soviet Union in the 1930s because 'It seemed like only the Soviet Union was standing up to Hitler.' Well, Hitler became chancellor in part because the Germans were afraid of the Soviet Union. And the Soviet Union was slaughtering millions long before Hitler killed his first Jew.

Somewhere in this, we have to consider the possibility that Leftists bear some moral culpability for causing Hitler's rise to power.

83 posted on 11/16/2003 3:53:25 PM PST by JoeSchem
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Chad Fairbanks
I had a similar experience.

In college, I had my own copy of Mao's Little Red Book. The propaganda that I saw from Russia didn't look too inviting, but I thought it worked well for people who'd been under the Tzar. I remember writing a paper on why communism was great for China and capitalism a poor choice for India.

Then...I met some Chinese intellectuals who'd been ripped from their jobs and families and forced to go into the fields (I have a feeling they suffered a lot more than what they were willing to talk about). I met Cambodians whose whole families had been wiped out, Vietnamese who risked pirates at sea to get out. I watched as a Chinese man I was escorting for business stood teary eyed in front a Chinese opera exhibit at the Smithsonian. Chinese opera had been banned by the communists and this was the first chance he'd been able to hear it in years. I became friends with a Jewish Romanian immigre whose family had to flee due to their religion. She would come to me because, as a convert to Judaism, I knew more than she did, since under communism she could not learn about her religion. I had a Ukrainian client, whose family had been devastated by their holocaust.

I think that a lot of Americans who support communism do so because they think that things should be 'fair,' and that communism reaches that goal. However, if they ever met someone who lived under that system, they would be disabused of that notion in a hurry.
84 posted on 11/16/2003 4:06:36 PM PST by radiohead
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 50 | View Replies]

To: Olam Hazeh
Sir,you go too far.You seem to minimize the deaths of Ukrainians .
85 posted on 11/16/2003 4:06:40 PM PST by MEG33
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 80 | View Replies]

To: Chad Fairbanks; Petronski
Thanks for pointing out post 12, and Thank you for bringing this book up to our attention.
86 posted on 11/16/2003 4:36:46 PM PST by KineticKitty (We have enough youth. How about a fountain of SMART?)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 31 | View Replies]

To: MEG33
Yes, he does.

In 1986, watching the effort to have "Harvest of Despair" broadcast, it was difficult to escape the conclusion that the deaths of some were deemed a whole lot less important that the deaths of others. Prior to that, I hadn't realized any particular group had a stake in being victims.

87 posted on 11/16/2003 4:39:43 PM PST by caltrop
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 85 | View Replies]

To: caltrop
I just looked up communism and anti semitism.Althought the communists promised Jews equality and the end of pogroms,they too eventually ended up in the same fix as the rest of the people.
88 posted on 11/16/2003 4:47:31 PM PST by MEG33
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 87 | View Replies]

To: caltrop
We are talking here about an event that killed twice as many people as the Holocaust you combine both starvations.

caltrop, don't get mad when you read this but I found someone on the net who disagrees with your film review. You should send them an e-mail of dispute. The Hoax of the Man-Made Ukraine Famine of 1932-33

89 posted on 11/16/2003 5:12:56 PM PST by Andy from Beaverton (I only vote Republican to stop the Democrats)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 38 | View Replies]

Comment #90 Removed by Moderator

To: nuconvert
Ed Asner is a commie a-hole.

The attitude amongst many liberals is that the communists were, at worse, misguided but generally ok. This stupid attitude is itself criminal, because it completely overlooks the holocausts that communists have perpetrated the world over: in Vietnam, Eastern Europe, Russia, the Ukraine, etc.

Stalin misunderstood, my a$$. Stalin was nothing more than a political, bloody, paranoid thug who killed millions of his own people. He was much more evil than Hitler. The PC crowd can stuff thier heads in the sand and lie about him all they want. I'm not buying.

91 posted on 11/16/2003 5:21:51 PM PST by Levante
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 13 | View Replies]

To: Andy from Beaverton
Ah..a review by the Progressive Labor Party..Hmmm Description:(their own)A Stalinist Party,a revolutionary communist party in the US.
92 posted on 11/16/2003 5:27:52 PM PST by MEG33
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 89 | View Replies]

To: caltrop
My #92
93 posted on 11/16/2003 5:29:05 PM PST by MEG33
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 92 | View Replies]

To: Andy from Beaverton
I checked it out. Thanks for steering me to it but I spent plenty of time arguing with Progressive Labor types, and other assorted screwballs, when I was active in NY politics so I think I'll pass up this opportunity to have another go at them.

The most amazing thing to me about the film was the very serious effort to make sure it wasn't shown. While a portion of it was undoubtedly an attempt to shield the Communists from criticism, it was clearly more than that in that there was a vocal constituency which argued that only Hitler's extermination of the Jews was ever worthy of discussion. This, presumably, is more of the same sort of nonsense as Elie Wiesel saying that the term "holocaust" can only be used to refer to the Jews who perished in WWII concentration camps.

94 posted on 11/16/2003 5:32:48 PM PST by caltrop
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 89 | View Replies]

To: Jack00
Solzhenitsin's idea that there is no such thing of "good communism" played itself out while witnessing the Nicaraugan Revolution and the Salvadoran civil war from a safe distance. Every knuckleheaded left-wing Catholic and touchy-feely Protestant and Jewish clergymen seemed to think this was "love in action." Which makes sense, considering the leadership of both juntas/rebel entities included priests and Catholic laypeople enamoured by "Liberation Theology."

Didn't make a difference. Ask anyone who ever opposed the Sandinstas and the Salvadoran FDR/FMLN.

Mowed down by thugs with rosaries wrapped around the pistol grips of their AK-47s. Solzhenitsin was right.
95 posted on 11/16/2003 5:59:13 PM PST by lavrenti ("Tell your momma and your poppa, sometimes good guys don't wear white." The Standells)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 74 | View Replies]

To: Levante
Glad you got that out.
Don't think anyone here will argue with you.
(unless Ed Asner just dropped by)
96 posted on 11/16/2003 6:00:07 PM PST by nuconvert
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 91 | View Replies]

To: MEG33
The PLP had more FBI agents at attendence of their meetings than actual members.

Most of these little groups number no more than several hundred. Unfortuantly many of them started getting involved in Democrat Party politics in 1988, led by those enabling clowns from DSA (Democratic Socialists of America).

I was there for that. Now the cat is out of the bag, folks.

When people complain about the radical trend within that party, well, it all started with the Jackson campaign and the decision of several Marxist-Leninist groups to glom on. Several became delegates to the Atlanta convention.

Now, some of y'all know that when one becomes a delegate to a major party convention, it opens some career doors.

Draw you own conclusions. I figured things out while being involved in a group that refused to along with the others.
97 posted on 11/16/2003 6:05:17 PM PST by lavrenti ("Tell your momma and your poppa, sometimes good guys don't wear white." The Standells)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 92 | View Replies]

To: lavrenti
Are you familiar with the World Workers Party and ANSWER International?
98 posted on 11/16/2003 6:10:11 PM PST by MEG33
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 97 | View Replies]

To: JoeSchem
Somewhere in this, we have to consider the possibility that Leftists bear some moral culpability for causing Hitler's rise to power.

Indeed. Hitler was quite to the left by American definitions of the term.

Hitler is often referred to as 'right wing'. Historically, 'right wing' in early twentieth century European politics meant he was a 'right wing' socialist. A 'right wing' socialist according to Lenin was one who wanted socialism but didn't want violent revolution to achieve it (see: Lenin and Right Wing). Right wing socialists were also interested in national socialist parties, rather than socialist parties owing allegence to international socialist or communist organizations that Lenin espoused.

The mainstream media conveniently leave out the socialist part when calling Hitler 'right wing'. Nazi principles are basically socialist (see points 11, 13, 17, 23, and 25 of Hitler's 25 Points).

A 'right wing' European socialist does not equate to a 'right wing' American politician. If anything, the Nazi party was closest in ideology to the left wing of the Democrat Party, some of whom are nothing but socialists.

99 posted on 11/16/2003 6:10:55 PM PST by rustbucket
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 83 | View Replies]

To: Olam Hazeh
One man's awful pain does not diminish the awful pain of another.Both deserve our efforts to diminish the pain and see that it doesn't reoccur.
100 posted on 11/16/2003 6:13:05 PM PST by MEG33
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 80 | View Replies]

Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 61-8081-100101-120121-135 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson