Skip to comments.Clifford D. May: To be 'pro-Palestinian' is to live in a world of delusions
Posted on 05/03/2004 2:37:58 AM PDT by kattracks
CONSIDER WHATS required to wear the label Pro-Palestinian.
To start, you have to appear non-judgmental about innocent Palestinian children being raised to become human bombs.
You must refer to those who send such children on suicide/mass murder missions as political leaders or, even better, as spiritual leaders. Call them militants if you must, but never terrorists.
To be thought of as pro-Palestinian, you must cite the plight of the Palestinian refugees as a key motivation for violence, ignoring the fact that there would have been no refugees had Israels Arab neighbors not launched a war to destroy the tiny Jewish state immediately upon its birth.
Indeed, Arabs who chose to stay in Israel are today Israeli citizens, as are their children, enjoying more freedoms than do the citizens of neighboring Egypt, Syria, Saudi Arabia or even Jordan.
Supporters of Palestinians must point to the Israeli occupation of Gaza and the West Bank as another root cause of violence. Avoid mentioning that it was a second Arab war against Israel that led to the seizure of those territories, which, at that time, were not called Palestinian territories. Gaza was administered by Egypt and the West Bank by Jordan and no one demanded that they be turned them over to Palestinian sovereignty.
The Israelis captured the Sinai as well. That territory, several times larger than all of Israel, was returned to Egypt in exchange for a piece of paper promising peace. Forget these awkward details.
To burnish your pro-Palestinian credentials, even as you rail against the Israeli occupation, say nothing positive about Prime Minister Ariel Sharons plan to end that occupation entirely in Gaza and to withdraw Israeli troops and settlements from 85 percent of the West Bank.
While it is true that at Camp David in 2000, then-Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak offered about 95 percent of the West Bank and Gaza, Yassir Arafat turned that offer down and initiated several years of terrorist attacks. Even so, Mr. Sharon has said hes willing to consider further withdrawal, to discuss permanent borders, though he wont negotiate with those dispatching terrorists. Dismiss all that as irrelevant if you want to be described as someone who sympathizes with the Palestinians.
Also, continue to insist that Israelis eventually must agree to a right to return that they must let millions of Palestinians settle not just in an independent Palestinian state next to Israel but in Israel itself.
Promote this idea even if youre savvy enough to know it can never happen just as Hindus can never re-settle in what is today Muslim Pakistan, just as Greek Christians can never re-settle in what is today Muslim Turkey.
In fact, Israelis with roots in Arab countries today comprise about half of Israels population. They might understand better than anyone else that a Palestinian right to return would mean the end of Israel as a homeland for the Jewish people, that Jews would become a minority in what would no longer be the worlds only predominately Jewish state.
And thats a frightening thought because, sadly, few minorities living in the 22 Arab countries and the more than 50 predominately Muslim nations enjoy anything approaching freedom and equality. Such freedom and equality may be achieved in Iraq in the years ahead though not if the dictators of Syria, Iran and Saudi Arabia can help it, and not if the Palestinian political and spiritual leaders who supported Saddam Hussein and who now oppose the American occupation have anything to do with it.
Nor should Friends of Palestine plan for the opportunities that the Israeli withdrawals will present. Dont even think about the Israeli homes that will be turned over to Palestinian families, the hotels that could be built along the Mediterranean. Forget about foreign investors, new hospitals and schools. And certainly dont talk about cooperation with Israel. On the contrary, shrug when Hamas terrorists bomb the checkpoints through which Gazans pass on their way to work in Israeli factories. But should the Israelis respond by closing those checkpoints, complain vehemently that the Israelis are cutting off the livelihood of Palestinian workers.
The United Nations is very pro-Palestinian. Thats why U.N. experts are not hard at work drafting a plan to give Palestinians more say over who governs them. Arafat was elected Palestinian leader he ran exactly one time in 35 years and in that election he was opposed by a woman whose name few can recall and who hadnt a ghost of a chance. Surely, thats as much democracy as any reasonable person could desire for Palestinians.
Perhaps someday people will look back in astonishment on all this.
Clifford D. May is the president of the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies, a policy institute focusing on terrorism.
WARNING: This is a high volume ping list
You have to believe that there really is a Palestinian people, even though all evidence indicates that they are Jordanian and Egyptian Arabs.