endangered species ping
please ping the list FF
From: Lee Riddle - Brookings, Ore
Sent: 7/18/2004 12:25:54 AM Pacific Standard Time
Subject: ESA Congressional Hearing ~ K Falls reportage
We got over to K Falls last night and made signs till midnight thirty or so
Got in the parade of about 800 ~ 850 People (and a horse "color guard") at 7 30 this morning hellow and marched through downtown K Falls to the Ross Raglund Theater
There was very heavy security, the whole downtown was closed off and cops were everywhere on bikes, foot, motorcycles
Afterwards we found out SWAT and Secret Service were on the scene, and maybe even more... perched on rooftops?
We gathered in front of the Theater to hear several speakers (one of which was Elliot Schwartz from Brookings) but then a drumming band of 40~80 ? "Klamath Tribe" supporters came up the street and proceeded to try to shout down the speakers, one of the whitie longhaired ones had salmon image shaped turban going through its head and carried a sign that said
"How would you like to be DAMNED ?"
Joan quickly confusilated him with facts I will never comprehend... (nuff said)... "hey he was all ready a potted plant" OK (Jesus)
We found out later that this Klamath Tribe March was in direct violation of what had been agreed to beforehand, between the leader of the tribe and the water users association, (the tribes were not going to be marching, then they were, but not there, but then they would not be confrontational, but they were) and thus the increased "police presence" (but no one got in a knock down fight situation, and there were no problems reported)
Off road jeepers were in the parade, and me with a pro farm sign (and a off road motorcycle T-shirt) held a sign that said "Curry & Del Norte Counties Support Klamath Agriculture" on one side, and "Victims of the ESA They Take My Land They Make Me Pay Fix the ESA~I Say" on the other side (that was the extent of any two wheeled troops) (where were you MRA ?)(Joni from Blue Ribbon was there)
Joan held the one that said "Salvage and Replant ~ The Burnt Biscuit" on one side and "Curry and Del Norte Counties Supports Klamath County Rights" on the other
Then we entered the Theater, dumped our metal items in the tray, walked through the metal detector, AND (pocket knives and signs ARE NOT allowed) (back to the truck) (try again) and this time I passed the metal detector and then got the special "wand" crotch test this time¦and even passed that one (shucks, And I thought I was a hard case..........) oh well(did I mention that security was on "red" ?) but i was code blue, so i got through
It is a huge wonderful theater, with great view of the stage Probably 200 people left after the march, so maybe 650 were seated in a place that holds 850, a pretty good turnout in busy times.
Then it got really interesting
Ken Calvert, the Chairman on Water and Power, California's 44th District Introduced the Congressional Panel:
Wally Herger 2cd District CA (pretty damn sharp)
John Doolittle 4Th District CA (does a LOT !! not a little!)
Greg Walden 2Cd District OR (does a lot, support this guy! )
These guys got quickly to the chase to determine "just what is the problem that farmers got crucified at Klamath?"
They really nailed Kirk Rodgers (Bureau of Reclamation), Steve Thompson (US~ Fish and Wildlife), Jim Lecky (NOAH Fisheries) to the cross in public.
The wiggleworms kept up the "just doing my job" mantra but Congress MAN "Doolittle" was just warming up, and pretty soon they were looking like three little wienies with their pants off
They had to admit that they were the ones that shut off the water for no good reason
They had to admit that they colluded among each other, had no good science, and admit that they harmed humans to death, and did not help "endangered species" one iota.
But still, they had suits and ties on anyway, and they were stuck on the hot seat bare butted. little weinies for all to see
The crowd loved it, perhaps it was all a show, but the questions from the congressmen were quite well thought out, and the cadence in which the questions were asked showed a well thought out agenda
The orchestration of this event, I believe, goes well beyond the "appeasement" of the injured attendants and a long way toward some real change for the positive in the near future.
We had our own Curry County Commissioner Ralph Brown giving testimony of the decimation of Pacific coast fishing industry, but not due to K Falls farming, rather to the ESA. I was outside afterwards with him as he was being interviewed by a green newswriter, who lost interest when his facts conflicted with her preconceptions.
Both Brown and Jimmy Smith (Humboldt Co Sup) were queried as to their affiliation with Glenn Spains group. Smith was weak on his response, Brown was not, he is a well educated, hard working man who continues to learn everyday. He reminded them to "think of the people", he gave a great speach, well considered of the loss the ESA has exacted upon the coastal human economy, in regards to fishing, logging income, giving figures as to the exact losses sustained to our communities.
Most interesting was Bill Gaines, California Waterfowl Association, who started out talking about his love affair with bird life, but ended up saying the Klamath Farmers are making MORE bird life than ever happened in history due to their irrigation and farming practice. Sounds like the "success of the goose" here on the coast to me (more in a minute)
The whole proceeding was very professional, the "tribes" representatives acted like undisciplined children, and were reminded several times to be considerate. Those who lost their farms or a family member showed so much resraint, it is hard to even imagine how they could do so.
The "media" will show whatever it wants to promote You just had to be there We had lunch with Grange, Blue Ribbon, OR Senate Candidates, Klamath Water Users, and more
SO HERE IS WHAT THE HOUSE COMMITTIEE on the ESA SEEMS TO WANT SUPPORT OF:
They would like to see outside "peer review" of any decision BEFORE it takes an action to list something that would destroy your human existence
They would like to see Human Economic factors included in that equation
They want to sort out who has the authority to ruin your livelihood and why and how
And put some checks and balances there
They want to see that a science based plan, will result in successfully results in a species "delisting"for the action taken, the effort taken and the money spent.
They want to have un cooped science involved in the mix to rule out "agenda" (wildlands was kind of polititely brought up, without mentioning is ugly face)
And if the science based plan does not result in "species recovery " they want to see changes that work
No "agendas", they want a win win, more "species" and successful farms at the same time
CONCURRENT AND TOGETHER
And they want to know EXACTLY "how many" geese or suckers it takes to be "recovered", they want the goal number that we are shooting for, a plan to reach that goal, that non agenda people say will achieve the goal, and when we reach that goal, we reached the goal, and the species is RECOVERED - No more goal swapping,
They seem willing to appropriate Fed $ to projects that get measurable results "if" increased seasonal water storage at K Falls would result in improved wildlife and help humans at the same time (although that is in question)they seemed willing to pursue FED appropriations to achieve that and they wanted the BoR to provide info ASAP toward that goal (no more friggin around) in fact they wanted info from a number of people "in the next two weeks"
They are open in the next 9 days to input from the affected "public's" humans experiences
Tell them YOUR EXPERIENCE with the ESA
How do you want to see changes in the ESA
YOU have two ways to put testimony into the pot
or fax to
I think you should send a copy to Herger, Doolittle, and Walden at the same time
Those guys are first class
You could not stamp out this species if you brought to bear the united power of the Army, Navy, and Air force.
Lord have mercy.
|To find all articles tagged or indexed using KlamathBasinCrisis, click below:|
|click here >>>||KlamathBasinCrisis||<<< click here|
|(To view all FR Bump Lists, click here)|
I admire anyone who takes on the enviro-nuts. Some ideas are good, but they have gone way beyond over they edge, ususally regarding property which they do not own. Talking about it as if it belonged to the "public." (No doubt they would say it does...)
Counties all over th state of WA are now having to pass resolutions to comply with new state law - interwoven with NEW and ONEROUS CRAZY regs that "helpful" county planners and "citizen planning boards" have added.
Hey people, I know we are the independent ones who just want to live our lives free- but if we do not get on these tedious boards, we will not even in theory own a piece of land. I guarantee you. And if you do not sleep soundly at night for fear of your government, you have good reason.