Posted on 11/18/2004 3:07:16 AM PST by foolscap
ROME (AP) - History condemns Italy's World War II dictator Benito Mussolini for his crimes, but a new book by his son depicts Il Duce as a caring father, who loved music and cried at the wedding of his beloved first-born daughter. The look at Mussolini's private side in Romano Mussolini's fast-selling "My Father Il Duce" has rekindled a heated debate in Italy about how to treat the infamous leader. The debate, like that sparked in Germany by a film on the last days of Adolf Hitler, is sensitive in a country that many say hasn't come to grips with its Fascist past.
"There's the psychological risk of identifying more with a man presented as a good father or seen with his wife and children," said Sergio Luzzatto, a professor of modern history at Turin's University.
The book is not the only attempt to polish Il Duce's image.
Another book, titled "Eating with Il Duce", written by Romano's former wife Maria Scicolone, reveals the dictator's culinary tastes. Their daughter, Alessandra Mussolini, a longtime lawmaker in the National Alliance right-wing government party, has recently founded her own movement to defend her grandfather's name.
"Looking at Il Duce as from a keyhole is a long-standing temptation that doesn't seem to end," said Luzzatto, the author of the recently published "The Crisis of Anti-Fascism". "But today, through modern media and TV, it penetrates every household and gains political and historical respectability."
"My Father Il Duce" does not go into the history of Mussolini's political rise and fall, or address the dark pages of the 20-year-long Fascist dictatorship, which began when Mussolini gained power in 1922 and ended in ruin in World War II. During the dictatorship, opposition parties were outlawed, media were tightly controlled, and after the 1938 racial laws Jews were persecuted.
Instead, the 170-page account depicts Mussolini as seen through the eyes of his children, shows his habits and tastes, and includes family photos: Mussolini during a picnic with his family, or holding a 2-year-old Romano on his shoulders. But it also shows him in military uniform and being rescued by the Germans after being held briefly by the Italian army when the government surrendered to the Allies.
"He sometimes gave the impression he was living for others, rather than for himself," Romano Mussolini writes of his father. Il Duce took an interest in his children's report cards in school, he adds, and "never raised his voice, but one of his famous stern looks was enough to make us anxious."
A jazz musician and a painter, Romano Mussolini was 17 when he last saw his father in April 1945, 11 days before the dictator was killed. Until now, he has refrained from discussing his father's legacy.
The book came out in mid-September, and has sold all of the first edition's 16,000 copies, said the Rizzoli publishing house. Another 5,000 copies have been published, while negotiations are under way to translate it in other languages.
The book's presentation last month on a popular show on state-run RAI-TV sparked an outcry, with one commentator saying the show looked like a "soap opera of the Mussolini family."
"Two hours of history about a nice and sporty Italian, who was a good husband and a great father, an affectionate father-in-law, an unforgettable grandfather. Who incidentally happened to be a dictator for two decades," wrote Curzio Maltese, a commentator in the left-wing newspaper La Repubblica.
Some contend that talking about Mussolini, even his private side, will help the country deal with its past.
"The time has come to listen to the reasons of those who were defeated," wrote right-wing commentator Marcello Veneziani. "This is true ... for the whole country if it wants to come to terms with its past, in a civilized way, to digest it and overcome it without removing or demonizing it."
The controversy follows a similar one in Germany, where the film "The Downfall" raised questions over whether Hitler should be portrayed with a human touch.
Among the movie's fiercest critics was filmmaker Wim Wenders, who has criticized the film for not taking a stand in showing Hitler's last days in the bunker and for inadvertedly de-emphasizing the Nazi horror.
the problem with all these dictators, like Hitler, Stalin, Mussolini e.a. is that to their friends and family they will always portray themselves as decent and caring, but in reality they don't care a rat's ass when expending millions of human lives.
I saw the "Downfall" Hitler movie, and I must say, I cannot see how anyone could possibly misunderstand that Hitler was a bad guy, just because he was, well at least biologically, human. No mistake possible, socalled neonazi's won't find anything in that movie to gloat about.
The 'Prince' was NOT the 'King of Italy'.....!!!
I have observed, first hand, the charm and charisma of the sociopathic personality. They are totally controlling and manipulative, for their own aggrandizement, of course. Those who cooperate and agree to become enslaved to their wishes will be treated with generosity and kindness. Disagree or confront even on an opinion about the weather and you might get yourself a death sentence. They will not tolerate ANY dissent about their total and absolute rule.
You ARE then fully aware of the U.S.A. public school SYSTEM....?
/Columbine?
Yeah, and John Wayne Gacy was nice to his wittle pussy cat, too. So what. Effing apologists and revisionists.
I understand that Ho Chi Minh was adept at making delicious pastries and desserts, skills he learned while working as a professional chef.
I hear Yuri Andropov loved American movies and jazz. Or so the media kept telling us when he took over the USSR after Brezhnev.
I also heard that Idi Amin used to frolic with his children at the palace swimming pool. When he wasn't eating his enemies, he was quite the father.
One reason Mussolini deserves study is that his regime was the only one in history that was truly "fascist," the omnipresent adjective used by the Left to describe all its opponents. Another reason is that his mixture of nationalism and socialism survives today in many third world "national liberation" movements which reject class struggle in favor of the proletarian nation's struggle against the "plutocracies" and also in the celebration, rather than the denigration, of native tradition. Even mainstream encyclopedias point out that there was far more Mussolini than Marx in the political ideology of Kwame Nkrumah and similar third world tyrants.
Yet another reason for study of Mussolini is that, while other Catholic nations had a history of "holy nationalism" Italy did not (in fact, the existence of a united Italy was contrary to Church policy) and this founder of the "idealist" philosophy was an atheist/materialist. Isn't it ironic?
It is often forgotten that Mussolini came to power in 1922 and for a long time was not associated with Hitler (mach shemo). He was in fact a favorite of many famous statesmen and was hailed as "a genius."
I wonder if anyone else remembers (as I do) a PBS special many, many years ago that actually attempted to rehabilitate Mussolini? Evidently it didn't work, but obviously someone wanted to rehabilitate him.
ping
Yeah and Charles Manson's childhood neighbor said he was a nice kid, too......
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.