Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

To: conservativecorner

Terrorists are not covered by rules of war


Commentary by Thomas Sowell

During the recent election campaign, it has been a liberal mantra that they ''support the troops'' while opposing the war in Iraq. Just what does supporting the troops mean -- other than just a throwaway line to escape the political consequences of a long history of being anti-military?

It certainly does not mean making the slightest effort to understand the pressures and dangers of combat, so as to avoid the obscenity of sitting in peace and comfort while second-guessing at leisure some life-and-death decisions that had to be made in a split second by men 10,000 miles away.

The latest example is the now widely-publicized incident in which an American Marine in Iraq shot and killed a wounded terrorist in Fallujah. Chris Matthews on Hardball spoke of ''what may be the illegal killing of a wounded, unarmed insurgent'' and asked: ''Is there ever a justification for shooting an unarmed enemy?''

The unreality of this question is breath-taking, both logically and historically. How do you know that someone is unarmed, when finding out can cost you your life? A hand grenade is easily concealed and can kill you just as dead as if you were shot by a machine gun or hit by a nuclear missile.

American troops in Iraq have already been killed by booby-trapped bodies. During World War II, wounded Japanese soldiers sometimes waited for an American medical corpsman to come over to help them and then exploded a hand grenade, killing them both.

Assuming that somehow you are certain that an enemy is unarmed, is it ever justified to kill him anyway? That question was answered more than half a century ago, when German troops wearing American uniforms and speaking English infiltrated American lines during the Battle of the Bulge.

Those German troops, when captured, were lined up against a wall and shot dead. And nobody wrung his hands about it.

The rules of war, the Geneva Convention, do not protect soldiers who are not wearing their own country's uniforms. To get the protection of rules, you have to play by the rules.

Terrorists are not enemy soldiers covered by the rules of war. Nor should they be. They observe no rules.

Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and the United Nations can all talk about ''the Geneva Convention.'' But that agreement on the rules of war has never applied to combatants not wearing the uniform of any country that is a party to the Geneva Convention.

Terrorists wear no uniform and show no mercy, as they have repeatedly demonstrated by beheading innocent civilians.

Why any such terrorists should be captured alive in the first place is a real question. Maybe they have information that could be useful. But every terrorist our troops try to capture alive increases the risk of death for American combat troops.

Their information better be damned important for that.

It is more than enough to ask a man to put his life on the line for his country, without needlessly increasing those risks by trying to be nobler than thou or playing to the international gallery. The very fact that this Marine in Fallujah has been taken out of combat and is under investigation can only have an inhibiting effect on other troops.

The inhibitions under which American troops have already had to fight have needlessly jeopardized their safety while we tiptoe around the delicate sensibilities of the media, European critics and ''the Arab street.''

The Times of London refers to a Marine ''killing an unarmed man in cold blood.'' If that was his purpose he could have opened fire when he entered the room, instead of waiting until he saw an Iraqi terrorist faking being dead -- for what purpose the Marine had no way of knowing.

We cannot fight wars to please The Times of London or the other nay-sayers and nit-pickers who have been against us from the beginning. There is no point trying to appease people who are not going to be appeased anyway. And to do so at an increased risk to American lives would be criminal.


13 posted on 11/23/2004 12:03:27 PM PST by conservativecorner
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies ]


To: conservativecorner

I'm an Infantry Sgt in the army who has 2 tours to Iraq under my belt. I really don't think that people here in the states understand what is really going on over there. These soldiers and marines are constantly having to make these judgement calls in a fraction of a second on whether they are good guys or bad. It seems that all anyone hears about are the cases like the marine in Fullujah. Never does anyone hear about the humanitarian efforts made by our service men and women. I also don't think people understand how difficult it is for us to go into combat mode and then later on in the day go into peace keeping mode. These men and women that are fighting in Iraq and Afganistan are truly the best that there is and I think that it is a testament to their professionalism that they are able to do all these things over a very long period of time and still get the mission done no matter how difficult. On top of all of this I can honestly say that never have I been more proud of my soldiers to see that they can buck up and meet the challenges head on time and time again.
On the contrary, it is extremely frustrating to fight this enemy who seemingly has no face. A majority of the time we are hit and then there is nothing left to shoot at because hajji is long gone. I don't care what anyone says, it always feels good to get some payback and release some of those frustrations, but never is it taken overboard. On many instances we return fire and kill or wound the enemy and then when it's all said and done we turn around and give them aid and comfort. This versatility is what makes this the greatest military there is and what separates us from them


14 posted on 07/19/2005 1:47:57 PM PDT by brinktk
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 13 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson