Skip to comments.Resist the Filibuster Fiat (Democrats Plead)
Posted on 01/31/2005 3:41:25 PM PST by RWR8189
During President Bush's first term, 10 of his judicial nominees were filibustered by Senate Democrats. This month, when the 109th Congress convened, Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist finally declared war. Calling the filibusters an "unfortunate break with more than 200 years of Senate tradition," he made the Democrats an offer he hopes they can't refuse. "Right now," he said ominously, "we cannot be certain judicial filibusters will cease. So I reserve the right to propose changes to Senate Rule XXII and do not acquiesce to carrying over all the rules from the last Congress."
In other words, if Democrats don't play ball, Frist reserves the right to invoke the "nuclear option": a parliamentary ruling that eliminates judicial filibusters by fiat, without a vote of the Senate.
But the majority leader protests too much. Not only have filibusters been attempted against judicial nominees in the past, but Frist himself has even voted for one. In 2000, after Senate conservatives had held up Bill Clinton's nomination of Richard Paez to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit for four years, Frist joined in an unsuccessful attempt to filibuster Paez -- a judge who was favored by a clear majority of the Senate and who won confirmation after the filibuster was broken by a vote of 59 to 39.
Still, Frist has a point. Senate Democrats have relied on filibusters to block judicial nominees far more often than have minority parties in previous
(Excerpt) Read more at washingtonpost.com ...
FOR GOODNESS SAKE FRIST, JUST DO IT!! Use the nuclear option.. let's roll for Crissakes.
Filibusters as a primary tactic to stop the functioning of the government are unprecedented, period. What the Democrats are doing is called sedition, and this is highly punishable - especially in wartime - if only someone had the guts to punish it.
It would be wrong to invoke the nuclear option without first making the obstructionists stage a real-live filibuster. Backing down to the threat of a filibuster is silly.
Do you or do you not, Mr (Mz) Senator, believe in the constitution, as you swore to uphold it when you took office ?"
Sir? ....Hello ?? Ma'am? .... We're waiting for an answer....
The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself.
Please go ahead and institute this rule. It would be an act of kindness to the put the Dums out of their misery.
Perhaps you can enlighten me to those you name and why?? Just trying to learn something new... :)
I think that the Alien and Sedition acts expired in March. March of 1800 that is, when Jefferson was inaugurated.
"Calling the filibusters an "unfortunate break with more than 200 years of Senate tradition," "
The list is long - as to the number of 'firsts' that democrats have pulled over the past 12+ years.
They leave 'decorum' to the republicans while they bulldog their agenda through time and time again.
Establish an offense - just do it!
Geez, like he talking to a bunch of kids. "I'll count to three and then..."
He's been threatening "Nuclear Option" for 3 years. Either use it or lose it, Frist.
Just Do It
May I say this without getting this post pulled????
Scaaaaaaarooooooooo the meeeee-dia.. :)
LOVE the CHECK!! Just DO IT!
Hopefully there will be some nominees that Sen. Frist can bring to the floor to find out how the democrats are going to react this session....
Tomorrow after morning business the nomination of Alberto Gonzales will be brought to the floor to begin debate on his confirmation to be Attorney General... It will be interesting to see how many hours they will agree upon for debate.
You know......if I see one more powdered wig foxtrot on the floor of the Senate I'm going to puke. We don't have 4 years to get things done; we have little more than 2. Let's rumble.
Filibusters should be totally eliminated. Whoever came up with this moronic concept that somehow the minority should be able to tie the majority in knots whenever they so please should be vilified. The senate is truly a tyranny of the minority.
Frist is in a much better position with 55 members in his caucus than he was with 51, so I'll give him the benefit of the doubt as this session gets under way.
The senate is truly a tyranny of the minority.
With all due respect to the Honorable Senator Frist: Fight them or run away with your tail tucked between your legs like the other gutless Republicans.
Make it so.
If they do not, then we are so over.
Talk is cheap. Yhe dems know he won't use it. This is like parents who constantly threaten their children and still have the brattiest kids in the neighborhood because the kids have yet to see one threat implemented.
They have to ACT like a majority, but it may require a trip to the add-a-nut-to-me factory.
Word up is the 'rats have never actually filibustered, only threatened to do so.
Let's make them start talkin' nonstop.
They will only lose more ground with thinking Americans.
While procedural games were played to keep Paez' nomination in limbo for over 2 years, it's questionable if this could properly be called a filibuster.
I cannot tell if any cloture votes on his nomination were ever taken and lost by the Democrats until the year 2000. If so, then it should be called a filibuster.
There was the one 2000 cloture vote taken and the possible filibusterers lost it, so a filibuster was never begun because it never got off the ground.
All of the Republican senators would have known that the cluture would be upheld, so Frist's vote against cloture could have been taken for philosophical rather that filibusteral (:>) reasons.
I have yet to see a real fillibuster on this. I guess our republican senators are afraid of having to stay awake for 24-48 hours straight.
I'm sure soldiers are having to do so somewhere right now
under a whole lot worse circumstances.
Congressman BillyBob prefer to call it "the constitutional option" , ..not "nuclear option", it does make better sense... plus "Constitutional Option" really pisses the 'RATS/Liberal Constitutional Lawyers off and they can't *itch much.
Is there any chance that the 'Rats will back down on these filibusters? After all, look what it got Tom Daschle.
Sedition is still a crime in the US code.
<< Geez, [It's] like he's talking to a bunch of kids. >>
It's worse than that.
He is [But a big kid, himself -- and is] talking to a bunch of kids.
We need term limits and the consequential restoration of our beloved FRaternal Reuplic.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.