Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

California sacred lands law triggers $50 million NAFTA claim
Bakersfield Californian ^ | 2/22/05 | Don Thompson - AP

Posted on 02/22/2005 6:43:13 PM PST by NormsRevenge

SACRAMENTO (AP) - When California adopted a law to protect sacred Indian lands and the nation's toughest restrictions on open-pit metal mining in 2003, the twin actions spelled the end for a gold mine in the Southern California desert.

Now the mine owner is seeking $50 million in compensation under the North American Free Trade Agreement.

It's one of 42 such claims by corporations and investors so far, according to Ralph Nader's watchdog group Public Citizen.

Public Citizen, the Sierra Club, the environmental law firm EarthJustice and two California state lawmakers said Tuesday the NAFTA provision lets foreign corporations undermine state and federal laws and regulations. They criticized the Bush administration for seeking to expand the free trade treaty and accompanying arbitration agreement to Central America.

Yet, "The United States has never lost a single investor case filed against it ... nor has the U.S. government ever paid a single cent to settle such a case," responded Richard Mills, spokesman for the Office of the United States Trade Representative. "Groups such as this are trying to scare people and they don't tell the full story."

Public Citizen contends an adverse judgment against the United States is just a matter of time.

State Sen. Liz Figueroa, D-Sunol, who chairs the Senate Select Committee on International Trade Policy and State Legislation, called the report "a grim wake-up call."

She introduced a bill that would require that California pass a law agreeing to any future international trade agreements that she said currently "threaten democracy and public well-being."

Meanwhile, Assemblyman Lloyd Levine, D-Sherman Oaks, decried the threat of a NAFTA compensation claim that he said "undermines our sovereignty" and prompted the veto of his bill requiring that more old tires be used in roadways in the form of rubberized asphalt.

Currently there are $28 billion in claims pending against the United States, Canada and Mexico under NAFTA, by Public Citizen's tabulation, including $300 million by Canadian cattle producers for losses stemming from the United States' beef import ban after mad cow disease was discovered there in 2003. In 11 cases where judgments are final, $35 million has been paid to five corporations.

The international arbitration provision cuts both ways.

United Parcel Service is seeking $160 million from Canada for alleged unfair competition from the government's delivery service there, and U.S. firms are challenging Canadian bans on a pesticide and gasoline additive.

Similar arbitration provisions are in some 2,000 treaties around the world, said John Murphy, vice president for Western Hemisphere Affairs for the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. The United States is party to about 40 such provisions, which mirror protections in the U.S. Constitution that property cannot be seized without compensation.

"These have proven quite helpful to American corporations," Murphy said, particularly in countries with slow or cumbersome legal systems.

He said Public Citizen's tally of $35 million in successful claims "seems fairly accurate. ... The striking thing about that number is how small it is relative to the flow of foreign investment."

Glamis Gold Ltd. of Reno says it already had invested $15 million in its proposal to mine federal land near the Quechan tribe's Fort Yuma Reservation near Winterhaven, in Imperial County, on part of the tribe's sacred "Trail of Dreams."

The proposed mine was rejected by the Clinton administration because it encroaches on Quechan sacred land, but the Bush administration rescinded that ruling.

California then enacted a law requiring that a metallic pit mine within one mile of an Indian sacred site be restored to its original landscape contour. Two days later, the California State Mining and Geology Board required mining companies to refill new open-pit metal mines and flatten mine waste piles back to nearly the natural landscape.

Glamis Gold, a U.S. subsidiary of a Canadian firm, filed for compensation under NAFTA instead of in U.S. courts.

"You use whatever means is at your disposal, where ever you think you have the greatest chance of success," said Michael Steeves, Glamis' vice president for investor relations.

---

On the Net:

Public Citizen: http://www.citizen.org

Office of the United States Trade Representative: http://www.ustr.gov/

Read SB348 at www.sen.ca.gov


TOPICS: Business/Economy; Foreign Affairs; Government; Politics/Elections; US: California
KEYWORDS: americanindians; california; claim; environment; mining; nafta; publiccitizen; sacredlands; trade; triggers
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021 next last

1 posted on 02/22/2005 6:43:16 PM PST by NormsRevenge
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: NormsRevenge

Wasn't NAFTA supposed to harmonize transnational trade?


2 posted on 02/22/2005 6:49:10 PM PST by DoughtyOne (US socialist liberalism would be dead without the help of politicians who claim to be conservative.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: DoughtyOne

lol.. Who signed that pig in a poke anyway?


3 posted on 02/22/2005 6:50:23 PM PST by NormsRevenge (Semper Fi ...... The War on Terrorism is the ultimate 'faith-based' initiative.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: NormsRevenge

Yikes! We've got a long way to go to even reclaim the concept of private property rights.


4 posted on 02/22/2005 6:55:15 PM PST by WorkingClassFilth (What if they had to hold a bake sale to pay for the salaries at NPR?)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: NormsRevenge

As I recall, there wassn't one person who read the thing. Bob Dole bragged that he'd never read the thing before he signed it. The total documentation was reportedly over 30,000 pages long. You'd think that would have covered things like mad cow etc. Oh well.


5 posted on 02/22/2005 6:56:19 PM PST by DoughtyOne (US socialist liberalism would be dead without the help of politicians who claim to be conservative.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: DoughtyOne

Coming from Dole and the Senate, not a surprise.

considering hardly any elected officials even bothered to look at the evidence accumulated about Clinton and made available for all to review as part of the Impeachment process.


6 posted on 02/22/2005 7:04:59 PM PST by NormsRevenge (Semper Fi ...... The War on Terrorism is the ultimate 'faith-based' initiative.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: NormsRevenge

i'd like to file a lawsuit against the left and their media during the vietnam war.


7 posted on 02/22/2005 7:06:32 PM PST by ken21 (the terrorists didn't blow up the new york times because the times supports them. /s)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: DoughtyOne
It was the lame duck democrat controlled senate and BJ Clinton.
8 posted on 02/22/2005 7:07:10 PM PST by HuntsvilleTxVeteran (a bullet only costs two bits.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: HuntsvilleTxVeteran

Maybe, but I remember Limbaugh going on and on about how great it was going to be too. Come to think of it, the only one who campaigned against it was Perot....that's scary.


9 posted on 02/22/2005 7:15:51 PM PST by AnOldCowhand (The west is dead. You may lose a sweetheart, but you will never forget her - Charles Russell)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 8 | View Replies]

To: AnOldCowhand
Come to think of it, the only one who campaigned against it was Perot...

Yep, old Ross Perot is a smart businessman who was looking to the future. The rest were busy pandering.

10 posted on 02/22/2005 7:54:01 PM PST by janetgreen
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 9 | View Replies]

To: NormsRevenge; AdamSelene235; SAJ; Grampa Dave; SierraWasp; Dog Gone; wardaddy; jmstein7; ...
"California then enacted a law requiring that a metallic pit mine within one mile of an Indian sacred site be restored to its original landscape contour. Two days later, the California State Mining and Geology Board required mining companies to refill new open-pit metal mines and flatten mine waste piles back to nearly the natural landscape. Glamis Gold, a U.S. subsidiary of a Canadian firm, filed for compensation under NAFTA instead of in U.S. courts."

That's beautiful! If you want to smash California's anti-business laws, you incorporate some little shell firm in Canada, and *then* use that shell firm to control your California operation.

Then, any eco-law that gets in your way can lead you straight to a NAFTA pot-o-gold via successful arbitration!

11 posted on 02/22/2005 8:01:34 PM PST by Southack (Media Bias means that Castro won't be punished for Cuban war crimes against Black Angolans in Africa)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: NormsRevenge

True...


12 posted on 02/22/2005 9:05:55 PM PST by DoughtyOne (US socialist liberalism would be dead without the help of politicians who claim to be conservative.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 6 | View Replies]

To: DoughtyOne
Bob Dole bragged that he'd never read the thing before he signed it.

He said the same thing about the Republican Platform, when some one challenged him on whether he supported some of the conservative planks. Guess he didn't have time to read much, what with all his legislatin. <(•¿•)>

13 posted on 02/22/2005 9:32:13 PM PST by itsahoot (There are some things more painful than the truth, but I can't think of them.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 5 | View Replies]

To: itsahoot

Perhpas if he'd had that Viagra a few years earlier...

mm n d(o.o)b n mm


14 posted on 02/22/2005 9:34:38 PM PST by DoughtyOne (US socialist liberalism would be dead without the help of politicians who claim to be conservative.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 13 | View Replies]

To: Southack

Well, thar ya go!!!


15 posted on 02/22/2005 9:39:19 PM PST by SierraWasp (The Dems have lost whatever "redeeming social value" they ever had!!! Just ask Zell...)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: Southack

I dunno. If I had spent $15 million on my property, only to have the state of California tell me that I can't use it because it's within a mile of "sacred ground", whatever that is, I'd use every tool in the book to get my money back.


16 posted on 02/23/2005 5:44:16 AM PST by Dog Gone
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 11 | View Replies]

To: NormsRevenge

Bankrupt California NOW!!


17 posted on 02/23/2005 6:25:34 AM PST by Jimbaugh (They will not get away with this. Developing . . . . .)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: itsahoot

Speaking of Bob Dole; Has anyone heard when he's going to start his campaign for president? I've been waiting.....since '96.


18 posted on 02/23/2005 7:21:15 AM PST by AnOldCowhand (The west is dead. You may lose a sweetheart, but you will never forget her - Charles Russell)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 13 | View Replies]

To: AnOldCowhand

<(•¿•)>


19 posted on 02/23/2005 1:44:36 PM PST by itsahoot (There are some things more painful than the truth, but I can't think of them.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 18 | View Replies]

To: DoughtyOne
I am always glad to see your input on these threads, you have a fine sense of propriety. And your posts are always insightful, often humorous
20 posted on 02/23/2005 1:47:22 PM PST by itsahoot (There are some things more painful than the truth, but I can't think of them.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 14 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-2021 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson