Skip to comments.Schiavo doctor a right-to-death activist
Posted on 03/22/2005 10:32:59 PM PST by tessalu
Neurologist chosen by husband addressed Hemlock Society
The neurologist chosen by Michael Schiavo to examine his estranged wife, Terri, is a right-to-die activist who has been a featured speaker for the pro-euthanasia Hemlock Society.
Dr. Ronald Cranford testified in the court cases before county court Judge George Greer that Terri Schiavo was in a persistent vegetative state with no hope of recovery.
"I've seen her," he told CNN. "There's no doubt in my mind, whatsoever, she's in a permanent vegetative state. Her CAT scan shows extremely severe atrophy to the brain. And her EEG is flat. It doesn't show any electrical activity at all."
His diagnosis has been disputed by Dr. William Hammesfahr, who said, "I spent about 10 hours across about three months and the woman is very aware of her surroundings. She's very aware. She's alert. She's not in a coma. She's not in PVS."
Hammesfahr added, "With proper therapy, she will have a tremendous improvement. I think, personally, that she'll be able to walk, eventually, and she will be able to use at least one of her arms."
"There's no way," responded Cranford. "That's totally bogus."
Cranford is a member of the board of directors of the Choice in Dying Society, which promotes doctor-assisted suicide and euthanasia.
He was also a featured speaker at the 1992 national conference of the Hemlock Society. The group recently changed its name to End of Life Choices.
In 1997, Cranford wrote an opinion piece in the Minneapolis Star Tribune titled: "When a feeding tube borders on barbaric."
"Just a few decades ago cases of brain death, vegetative state, and locked-in syndrome were rare," he wrote. "These days, medicine's 'therapeutic triumphs' have made these neurologic conditions rather frequent. For all its power to restore life and health, we now realize, modern medicine also has great potential for prolonging a dehumanizing existence for the patient."
He explained that while landmark legal cases like those of Karen Ann Quinlan and Nancy Cruzan demonstrated it was "sensible to stop treatment in patients lingering in permanent vegetative states," it was now time to look beyond those cases.
"The United States has thousands or tens of thousands of patients in vegetative states; nobody knows for sure exactly how many," he wrote. "But before long, this country will have several million patients with Alzheimer's dementia. The challenges and costs of maintaining vegetative state patients will pale in comparison to the problems presented by Alzheimer's disease."
The answer, he suggested, was physician-assisted suicide.
"So much in medicine today is driving the public towards physician-assisted suicide," he wrote. "Many onlookers are dismayed by doctors' fear of giving families responsibility in these cases; our failure to appreciate that families suffer a great deal too in making decisions; our archaic responses to pain and suffering; our failure to accept death as a reality and an inevitable outcome of life; our inability to be realistic and humane in treating irreversibly ill people. All of this has shaken the public's confidence in the medical profession."
He blamed "right-to-lifers" and "disability groups" for discouraging families from making the choice for euthanasia. He applauded European values that embrace euthanasia.
"But here in the United States, many caregivers wouldn't consider not placing a feeding tube in the same patients," he wrote. "It's hard to understand why. If we want our loved ones to live and die in dignity, we ought to think twice before suspending them in the last stage of irreversible dementia. At it is, it seems that we're not thinking at all."
Sarah Scantlin was 18 years old when, as a pedestrian, she was injured in a hit-and-run accident that left her in a vegetative condition, aware of her surroundings but unable to speak or move.
Since that time, she has been in a care centre in the Midwest US state of Kansas.
Scantlin´s parents unexpectedly received a phone call last week from the nursing home where their now 38-year-old daughter resides.
However, instead of the call being about Sarah, it was actually from Sarah.
"Hi mum," she said to her mother.
The words were a shock and a joy for Scantlin´s parents.
"There´s just no words," mother Betsy Scantlin told a CBS television news show. "I´ve just laughed ever since because it´s just so amazing."
Prayer is the only thing that Terri can depend on now since her government has failed her. Pray and visualize that God's will shall duplicate this miracle for Terri. If the good lord wills this to happen, it would be for the whole world to see and people should fear his judgement on their own soul.
Like morticians who defile corpses, there is just something plainly wrong with a doctor who takes delight in killing patients. Freud would have had a field day with the Hemlock Society. The God Complex persists among the most warped of physicians. One suspects that there exists quite a few Mengeles and Kevorkians treating patients with an agenda of death.
These guys need to watch about a week's worth of WWII documentaries about the Nazis. They will then either step away from the abyss or find their true kindred spirits.
If you see my comment #4, Mengele was one of the Nazis I had in mind. Would you like to entrust your life, or the life of a loved one, to someone like Dr. Cranford?
I've never heard before that Terri showed flat brain waves on an EEG.
Can this be confirmed anywhere?
I was under the impression that only brain dead patients show flat EEGs.
As Terri breathes, maintains vital organ functions, moves, opens her eyes (etc..) and has maintained her reflexes - she cannot be brain dead.
I may be wrong - but something is telling me this doctor is fibbing about the EEG.
From Felos to Greer, Terri Schiavo's "representation" has been by a bunch of gleeful ghouls.
Who are making money off it.
Boycott Pinellas County!
I read that somewhere, but in reading it went on to say something about Terri being real aggitated while taking it so they (don't remember who they were) felt it was reading falsely.
"I read that somewhere, but in reading it went on to say something about Terri being real aggitated while taking it so they (don't remember who they were) felt it was reading falsely."
OK, umm....how does a vegetable manage to become "aggitated"?
I thought they weren't capable of becoming aggitated.
Well, you know what they would say.
She is just having involuntary spasms.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.