Posted on 03/27/2005 7:33:55 AM PST by mhking
After being jailed last summer in Union City, Shakita Perdue was stripped, strapped to a chair and left exposed to male prisoners and guards for hours, according to an investigation by jail officials of the incident.
Now, she is suing those she says are responsible for $10 million.
This week, Perdue, 28, filed the lawsuit in federal court against the city, the South Fulton County Municipal Regional Jail and Georgia Correctional Health, the firm that handled medical needs at the Union City-owned jail. She charges that her civil rights were abused by her jailers that night.
"I had never been treated like that before in my life," said Perdue, who was booked into the jail on a drug charge. "It was a traumatic experience. It has messed up my nerves."
In an internal report on the jail's investigation of the incident, jailer Tremata Anthony said she strapped Perdue in the chair because Perdue was drunk, abusive and threatened to kill herself the night of her arrest.
The jailer was fired 17 days after the incident occurred for failure "to conduct herself in a professional manner using sound judgment at all times," the internal report states. The report listed nine violations of jail policy in the treatment of Perdue. The report indicates that there is an "isolation room" at the jail in which Perdue could have been placed. It also says Anthony filed no incident report, nor did she justify stripping Perdue.
The internal report was provided to the Journal-Constitution by Perdue's attorney, Eldridge Suggs IV, who obtained it through Georgia's Open Records Act.
Anthony wrote in the report that Perdue's paper gown was taken away and her hair was cut because she tried to strangle herself with the gown and with her braids.
The jailer said that she put pepper spray on the chair straps because Perdue tried to chew through them.
In the same report, a nurse with Georgia Correctional Health, Cathy Adams, wrote that Perdue was restrained in an area where detainees are brought to be booked.
"Due to her violent behavior, she was held in the cage in the booking area until she was calm enough to be moved to the medical area," Adams wrote.
When a male officer asked if he could cover Perdue, Anthony wouldn't allow it, another officer wrote in the report.
Repeated calls to Anthony for comment were not returned.
Helen Turner, a Union City councilwoman, said she and other city officials first learned of the incident in an area newspaper.
"I think it is a disgrace that we didn't know anything about it," she said.
Turner called Perdue's treatment "inhumane," and said, "I was appalled to know it happened here."
Not commenting
The South Fulton County Municipal Regional Jail is owned by Union City, used by several nearby municipalities and governed by a five-member authority created by the Legislature.
J. Clark Boddie, the mayor of Palmetto and a member of the jail authority, said he would not comment about Perdue's lawsuit because the jail is named in the suit.
" I am not at liberty to talk about it at all," said Boddie, who is also a U.S. marshal. "I am familiar with the occurrence, I just can't talk about it."
Repeated calls this week to Union City Mayor Ralph Moore and City Administrator Ski Saxby were not returned. Nor were calls to Dennis Davenport, an attorney representing the city and the jail.
Georgia Correctional Health, a private company, no longer provides health care to the jail in Union City. A representative of its insurance carrier said he hasn't seen a copy of the suit.
According to the jail's own report, the incident began after midnight last July 31 when Fairburn police arrested Perdue on charges of disorderly conduct for fighting with her cousin.
When the officers ran a routine background check, they found Perdue was wanted in nearby Union City for not completing all of her required community service on a previous marijuana charge.
Fairburn police turned Perdue over to Union City authorities, and she was taken to the city's jail.
Perdue, who admits she'd been drinking that night, said she was angry and crying when she entered the jail because her cousin had not been arrested along with her. But she didn't try to kill herself, she said.
According to the investigation, conducted by jail Sgt. James Hall, Perdue was taken to the jail's shower room at 2:47 a.m.and returned less than five minutes later in a paper gown. The report said she was placed into the "cage" in the middle of the holding cell.
At 2:55 a.m., Perdue tried to choke herself, Hall wrote. A minute later, Anthony, the jailer, and Adams, the nurse, went into the cage, took off the paper gown and placed Perdue "in the restraint chair nude," Hall's report said.
Anthony's account said Perdue was threatening to kill herself. "Perdue started to bang her head against the wall," she wrote.
Efforts to help
At one point during the hours Perdue was strapped in the chair, Hall reported that two officers attempted to help her. One asked Anthony if he could go into the cage and cover Perdue because there were male officers coming in with male inmates. Anthony told him no.
Another officer, after Anthony repeatedly told him not to cover Perdue, hung a blanket over the side of the cage, "so that other inmates could not look at her nude body," according to the report.
The blanket provided incomplete cover, Hall noted.
At 6 a.m., more than five hours after her arrest, Perdue was still naked and strapped to the chair when another nurse, Arlene Campbell, arrived at work.
"I found the female [Perdue] in four-point restraints in a chair. [She] was completely nude with exposed female genitalia." Campbell's report went on to say men across from the booking center "were laughing and making remarks under their breath."
Perdue said male prisoners were allowed to sit and watch her. At least one male officer made lewd comments, she said.
Her attorney said Perdue's civil rights were trampled.
"I am going to relentlessly pursue justice on behalf of Ms. Perdue," Suggs said. "I want to make them an example."
Suggs acknowledges that Perdue has not been a model citizen. She had been arrested several times prior to the July incident, she doesn't have a steady job and she doesn't have custody of any of her five children, ages 4 to 11.
"We are in the process of helping her rehabilitate her life and we will use whatever proceeds that we are going to win to put her back in the middle of the road," Suggs said.
Perhaps if she had left the drugs alone, she wouldn't have been there in the first place. I really don't simply accept the story of a druggie at face value. There has to be more to this.
I'm guessing that despite her lifestyle, Perdue is still prettier than Anthony, who decided to degrade her out of envy and spite. The cutting off of Perdue's braids is a giveaway of her motive : Whenever a female murder victim is found with her hair chopped off, cops and profilers assume they're dealing with a female perp, because women target hair when they especially want to show contempt for their victims. As for Adams, she may also be envious, or she may simply have been too intimidated by Anthony to behave as a human being. I'm glad the other nurse did the right thing and reported this disgusting incident.
This mourning I need some humor.
yeah I could use some too....
Even paper can be twisted enough times and therefore made thick enough to be difficult to tear. Ever ripped a phone book in half? It's the same concept. My gut feeling is that she's mostly to blame for this incident because of her behavior.
HuntsvilleTxVeteran my apologies for what I would have posted.
Hell of an Easter ain't it?
FReegards,
Eaker
yeah....
it doesnt feel like Easter...it feels too early in the year...
It's the male prisoners that may have been more dramatized.
Yea, that has to be it. Her nerves must have been messed up by being strapped naked to a chair. It could not have possibly have been the drugs.
Except that other police officers wrote about their attempts to cover her in their reports. This is beyond disgraceful and the guilty "LEOs" should be held personally responsible.
-"I had never been treated like that before in my life," said Perdue, who was booked into the jail on a drug charge. "It was a traumatic experience. It has messed up my nerves."-
OK, I'm going to question this one. She was already messed up, seems to me, and I bet she's had all KINDs of "treatment" on her - good, bad, ugly; wanted and unwanted.
I think they made some highly questionable judgments for sure, but this gal is hardly an innocent, and I wouldn't take her word on it.
Well, then let's have the next person exposed like this be your mother. Still think it's ok to treat people like this?
Despite the fact that this woman is probably "trash", she was in the custody of the State and NO ONE should be treated like this. I find some of the comments on this thread appalling.
I think her lawyer can already smell the fine leather interior and hear the canvas-tearing scream of the new Ferrari V12 he's going to buy with just a portion of his third of the settlement. As for Shakita, I can imagine what she's going to buy with her winnings.
Are there any adults working in law enforcement down there?
If she was so out of control that they were worried about suicide, why didn't they transport her to a hospital and let her be naked there.
She, trash that she is, was treated abominably. Someone should lose her job but damages, oh 10 grand would do it for me. There is no terrible damage here other than to her dignity of which she has little.
Hmmmm...where does the money for the "police budget" come from? hahaha
FMCDH(BITS)
Perhaps some of those whose rights Purdue violated that resulted in her arrests have never been treated like that in their lives before. Maybe Purdue's actions messed up their nerves. Maybe they should sue Purdue for, say, $10 million.
I can't argue that point. My concern is that by not punishing mistreatment severely, the police and 'system' there will learn that they can get away with a lot for only 10K. Of course, I think that prisoners should be treated harshly, child molesters should be put to death, etc. I'm just tough all around, I suppose!
I'll go with your 'take' on things. About the same as mine.
trouble is the millions will come out of the pockets of citizens. I say fire the people who did this with prejudice and that will go a long way toward a solution.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.