Skip to comments.Terri Schiavo — A Tragedy Compounded
Posted on 04/21/2005 9:07:43 AM PDT by bookworm100
...Distortion by interest groups, media hyperbole, and manipulative use of videotape characterized this case and demonstrate what can happen when a patient becomes more a precedent-setting symbol than a unique human being...
(Excerpt) Read more at content.nejm.org ...
Nope. No possible pro-euthinasia bias there! (/s)
The neurologist and the radiologist chosen by the patient's parents and siblings, the Schindler family, disagreed and suggested that Ms. Schiavo's condition might improve with unproven therapies such as hyperbaric oxygen or vasodilators but had no objective data to support their assertions.
So why not try? She wasn't suffering, so there was all the time in the world to attempt to help her. Why rush her through a death sentence when she had committed no crime?
Even a mass murdering terrorist gets out of the death penalty if one person on the jury disagrees with it!!!
There's absolutely no excuse for her murder.
I read the propaganda piece. This is a Death Culture "doctor" who is hot to trot for involutary euthansia, as a bookend to his abortionist industry colleagues. All these "doctors" act in complete violation of basic human decency and the Hippocratic Oath.
I totally agree. There is no excuse for what happened to her and I am appalled that it could happen in the USA.
The "spin" for the doctors is amazing.
Among other things he said, I found this to be interesting: "Although I did not examine her, from the data I reviewed, I have no doubt that Terri Schiavo was in a persistent vegetative state and that her cognitive and neurologic functions were unfortunately not going to improve."
Terri ping! If anyone would like to be added to or removed from my Terri ping list, please let me know by FReepmail!
Her family and the public should be reassured and educated that dying in this way can be a natural, humane process (humans died in this way for thousands of years before the advent of feeding tubes).
Not so. Thousands of years ago, patients like this wouldn't have survived the initial trauma. It is a uniquely modern dilemma that we can stabilize the health of someone who is so very seriously functionally impaired.
Doctors are profesionally offended by patients who have no prospect of improvement, and deeply offended to have their pronouncements questioned. This one is no different.
Having viewed some of the highly edited videotaped material of Terri Schiavo and having seen other patients in a persistent vegetative state, I am not surprised that family members and others unfamiliar with this condition would interpret some of her apparent alertness and movement as meaningful.
That's why, you should read the ENTIRE paragraph on his basis.
Oh, brother! This is so disgusting. They killed her and she wasn't even sick.
I read it and sent a nasty email to them. There are too many doctors out there that think they are God. They need to realize they are the instruments of God.
I already told my son, who is in an EMT and studying to be a paramedic that I don't want to find out he helped starve and dehydrate some poor helpless person. He started to laugh but then realized how dead serious I was. He promised he would never help in that type of situation.
Agreed, euthanasia is murder, plain and simple.
Michael Schiavo's pet doctors are notorious patient killers. And so is the New England Journal of Medicine, which pioneered medical euthanasia and assisted suicide.
You can expect nothing else from this journal, which has long been in the forefront of the Culture of Death.
>>"Although I did not examine her, from the data I reviewed, I have no doubt that Terri Schiavo was in a persistent vegetative
that's pretty telling... doctor shortcuts... don't look at the patient, just look at her charts that Michael purged of all POSITIVE comments each day.
>>and Ms. Schiavo's attending physician all agreed that her condition met the criteria for a persistent vegetative state.
they are torturing comments from different timeframes.
In 2002, Greer planned to use the 5 doctors + the attending
to determine her PVS status. 6 doctors total.
But after hearing her attending exclaim surprise at how aware she seems to be, Greer changed gears, tossed out the attending physician,
and formed his opinion based on the 3-to-2 results from just the other doctors.
Would Dr. Quill be surprised that this woman recovered?
What the doctor appears to be saying is that this was a quality of life case in which the quality of the life didn't come up to his subjective standards. That's all.
It is worse than that. She was not diagnosed as having such a disorder. It is not a fact, but it is a supposition in order to explain her collapse.
He conveniently ignores the fact that there was not CLEAR evidence that Terri would wish to be starved. He conveniently ignores the fact that this was a precedent setting case to put the "Hearsay evidence" on the books for precedence.
He conveniently ignores the fact of Terri's religious beliefs that would not want her starved/dehydrated to death.
He also conveniently ignores the fact that Felos was very involved in the euthanasia movement, that laws had been systematically adjusted to allow hearsay evidence rather than proof. How? By an end-of-life panel which was given law making ability without oversight of the legislature. Euthanasists are on the panel.
So, just ignore what you wish and make a decision. Seems that is exactly how Terri was killed.
Odd that Quill titled his work "Terri Schiavo - A Tragedy Compounded". He is compounding it further by putting this garbage in print.
After reading this 'doctor's' submission, I have, without examining him, determined that he exhibits no cortical function. Since his quality of life cannot be expected to improve, he should be locked in a room sans food and water until such time all natural bodily functions cease. Since some moveable 'quality of life' standard seems to be what they desire to use, it can be manipulated to include anyone that they wish offed for being a 'useless eater'. Oh, joy. And its all 'legal'. More joy.
These are the medical 'facts' as understood by doctor Quill, but there are other qualified experts who disagree. So, as far as I am concerned, the premise to his analysis is suspect. That was the purpose of congress's instruction for the court to start over at square one to review the findings of fact, which were established by ONE man, Judge Greer.
"There's absolutely no excuse for her murder."
I agree totally. The media and all the Death Now Lovers,
are and have been, twisting this into condemnation against the VICTIM and her REAL BLOOD family, the ones who loved her most. Twisted logic. No reason for Terri to die, She was not ill. They murdered her!!! That was their goal, mission completed now they want a pat on the back. It's just sick thinking and a totally horrific death for an innocent disabled HUMAN BEING. Bunch of Sickos Greer,
MS and Felos and may no one ever have a neurologist like Cranford. They are disgust me. BTW I do not belong to any GROUP, I am not Catholic, but I do I know right from wrong. This was a tragic misuse of power.
Condemning the REAL family for using the tapes of her was the only way they could show she was NOT in a PVS. Now they say we dont see what we see. Why are two tapes still sealed?
It was a biased court from the time Greer sat his rump in that chair. Lordy, he must have no sense of Family, any decent Judge would have known that a "man" living with a paramour and kids with that woman needs to be removed as a guardian. Greer is a dismal souless failure of a judge.
But I bet he golfs well and spends lots of time with his "Death now buddies". Felos and Cranford, they are just flat out creatures with no morals. Speaking of Morals, MS has NONE, IMO. Terri was a sweet angel disabled victim of these horrible men and now the media is not still not done.
Well "Shame on THEM ALL".
hypokalemia brought on by an eating disorder
Oh, brother! This is so disgusting. They killed her and she wasn't even sick.
I agree, even MS testified he was unaware of any eat disorder. He used that in a lawsuit that the Drs. settled out of court. Then gets the fat check after promising to honor his marriage vows, dumps Terri in a nursing home, then a hospice. Makes a ring for himself out of her wedding rings,(usually folks wait to do such things when a person is DEAD) he kills her little kitties. Tromps on all the things she loved. For years this hate campaign towards her parents, brother and sister. He claims "Terri would have wanted this".
Yeah right.. He had her murdered, put to death, a death we don't allow our own pets to die like that.
No current testing. I am appalled by this.
All Lies. I can't stand it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
It is a very EVIL thing to do to someone.
Me, too. End times alert. This is the same old B.S. coming from the dark side. CONSIDER THE SOURCE!!
It made me sick, the way he talked about Terri - like she wasn't a human being worthy of respect. He said that she didn't feel her death which is disputed by EYE WITNESSES who said she suffered greatly. THIS IS DISGUSTING!!!!!!!!!!!
God bless Terri's family and give them strength to withstand these assaults from the enemy of our souls.
Your post #9 THANK YOU!!!!!!!!!!
But many people don't believe Father Pavone.
I know. It appears that most people don't care about what happened to Terri. Amazing, isn't it? I'm glad we're on the side of life but I'm afraid we're in for more of this with persecution.
That people accuse Father Pavone of having an agenda while not believing the same of George Felos is beyond me.
Perhaps most of those who think that way, have the same agenda as Felos.
Father Pavone is one of my heros. I didn't like the way he was treated by Bill O'Reilly. But life goes on.
Dr. Quill is a professor of medicine, psychiatry, and medical humanities and the director of the Center for Palliative Care and Clinical Ethics at the University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, N.Y.
Ethics folks LOVE death. They'd kill us all if they could.
1991 Dr. Timothy Quill writes about "Diane" in the New England Journal of Medicine, describing his provision of lethal drugs to a leukemia patient who chose to die at home by her own hand rather than undergo therapy that offered a 25 percent chance of survival.
From this website:
Ping to 37 if your interested in more about "Dr." Timothy Quill. I use quotation marks because I find little of his work to be really that which I expect of a doctor. Too Kevorkian for me.
The many doctors who said they too did not examine her, but sided with the family that she was not PVS were vehemently criticized. Where is the criticism now? Amazing!
Added to Terri Bookmark Mountain. FReegards....
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.