Skip to comments.Tom McClintock: To understand education budget, start with math
Posted on 05/16/2005 2:24:48 PM PDT by calcowgirl
The multimillion-dollar campaign paid by starving teachers unions has finally placed our sadly neglected schools at the center of the budget debate.
Across California, children are bringing home notes warning of dire consequences if Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's scorched-earth budget is approved -- a budget that slashes Proposition 98 public-school spending from $42.2 billion this year all the way down to $44.7 billion next year.
That should be proof enough that our math programs are suffering.
As a public-school parent, I have given this crisis a great deal of thought and have a modest suggestion to help weather these dark days.
Maybe -- as a temporary measure only -- we should spend our school dollars on our schools. I realize that this is a radical departure from current practice, but desperate times require desperate measures.
The governor proposed spending $10,084 per student from all sources. Devoting all of this money to the classroom would require turning tens of thousands of school bureaucrats, consultants, advisers and specialists onto the streets with no means of support or marketable job skills, something that no enlightened social democracy should allow.
So I will begin by excluding from this discussion the entire budget of the State Department of Education, as well as the pension system, debt service, special education, child care, nutrition programs and adult education. I also propose setting aside $3 billion to pay an additional 30,000 school bureaucrats $100,000 per year with the proviso that they stay away from the classroom and pay their own hotel bills at conferences.
This leaves a mere $6,937 per student, which, for the duration of the funding crisis, I propose devoting to the classroom.
To illustrate how we might scrape by at this subsistence level, let's use a hypothetical school of 180 students with only $1.2 million to get through the year.
We have all seen the pictures of filthy bathrooms, leaky roofs, peeling paint and crumbling plaster to which our children have been condemned. I propose that we rescue them from this squalor by leasing out luxury commercial office space. Our school will need 4,800 square feet for five classrooms (the sixth class is gym). At $33 per foot, an annual lease will cost $158,400.
This will provide executive washrooms, around-the-clock janitorial service, wall-to-wall carpeting, utilities and music in the elevators. We'll also need new desks to preserve the professional ambience.
Next, we'll need to hire five teachers, but not just any teachers. I propose hiring only associate professors from the California State University at their level of pay. Since university professors generally assign more reading, we'll need 12 of the latest edition, hardcover books for each student at an average $75 per book, plus an extra $5 to have the student's name engraved in gold leaf on the cover.
Since our conventional gym classes haven't stemmed the childhood obesity epidemic, I propose replacing them with an annual membership at a private health club for $39.95 per month. Finally, we'll hire an $80,000 administrator with a $40,000 secretary because, well, I don't know exactly why, but we always have.
Our bare-bones budget comes to this:
5 classrooms -- $158,400 150 desks @ $130 -- $19,500 180 annual health club memberships @ $480 -- $86,400 2,160 textbooks @ $80 -- $172,800 5 CSU associate professors @ $67,093 -- $335,465 1 administrator -- $80,000 1 secretary -- $40,000 24 percent faculty and staff benefits -- $109,312 Offices, expenses and insurance -- $30,000 TOTAL -- $1,031,877L
The school I have just described is the school we're paying for. Maybe it's time to ask why it's not the school we're getting.
Other, wiser, governors have made the prudent decision not to ask such embarrassing questions of the education-industrial complex because it makes them very angry. Apparently the unions believe that with enough of a beating, Gov. Schwarzenegger will see things the same way.
Perhaps. But there's an old saying that you can't fill a broken bucket by pouring more water into it. Maybe it's time to fix the bucket.
Tom McClintock represents the 19th District in the California state Senate. Write to him by e-mail at firstname.lastname@example.org.
I'm going to bite the bullet here. I want to formalize a "McClintock Ping List." Up to now, anyone I have pinged has been on a totally involuntary basis.
Please let me know via freepmail if you want on or off this list.
Fix the bucket. Redistrict NOW. (And elect Tom Lt.Gov)
That is simply brilliant.
Tom McClintock for Lt. Governor in 2006:
keep me on the list.
Cut out sex education and other liberal indoctrination programs and there'll be enough funds for english, science, math, history, social studies, art, music.
The system of government education in America today remains an utter failure. After 40 years of social engineering by liberals and the current crop of big government Republicans, only a miracle can turn things around.
Very nice editorial. It's so darned reasonable - but perhaps California will embrace its vision anyway. I wish Texas would, too.
You got it!
Here is hoping that McClintock can continue to build his standing with sensible liberals and moderates in CA so that he can be our next governor.
They still teach math in schools in California?
I'm shocked to hear that! :-o
...but of course!
I'm not from CA, but I do love Tom McClintock... use your judgement.
I am amazed that no one seems to point out to them the obvious fact that it costs less to educate fewer students. All together now .... DUH!
sheesh .... I forgot to mention that this is a California "distinguished" school.
DAMM~!~ THATS GOOD
I'll put you on for now--the posts are not frequent.
As his Atty General campaign begins, just let me know if want off the list.
How does CA do it? Around here we have more non-teaching staff than we do classrooms or desks.
One local high school added a "World Languages" wing a couple of years back - 12 classrooms, I believe. Rather than a single building, however, they built 3 stand-alone square buildings, all in a row, with 4 classrooms each, 2 on each opposite side. Of course they had to build sidwalks between the buildings so the kids would walk around/through/whatever.
LOL That's actually cheap compared to here with admin costs....
I hope I'ma keeper!
If you poor it in fast enough, you can. Of course, it doesn't stay full very long.
You're definitely a keeper!!! ... until you're put away in a home, of course. ;-)
Request Granted! :-)
"LOL That's actually cheap compared to here with admin costs...."
That's Tom's proposal!
The do nothing idiots that are currently on the payroll get a lot more.
When I was in high school 50+ years ago in a school of 1800+ students there were a total of 12 people that wern't teachers including the gardener.
First, how does the union get the right to send notes home to anyone? Isn't this against the law on several levels?
Lastly, I think Tom makes some good points and I think what he says is worthy of discussion. I do believe his behavior during the last Gov. election does exclude him from any consideration for a job in Government where the people have to elect him. I think he betrayed us at our expense last election.
Keep me on.
(Denny Crane: "Sometimes you can only look for answers from God and failing that... and Fox News".)
I think Tom made a good point and the fact is that education got an increase under the current budget.
I also appreciate the topic and discussion brought to the table by Tom.
The teacher's union should be an object of focus by Republicans just as Judges are now just starting to be.
End the teacher's union IMO and public education would be better for it.
You got it!
Break up the big school districts and get rid of most of the administrators.
I didn't read your post before I posted mine. Oh well, we agree about getting rid of administrators.
Bump for later
Break up the current control of unions by law if we must and reduce administrators down to maybe 1 for every 40 teachers.
Also take away the power of the union to make it cost us 100k to fire a bad teacher.
The union only has the goal of growing, so they have been big for illegals in the schools because that means more teachers would be needed to educate them.
I think we need a change in the Constitution of the United States so that illegals are not due any free education, benefits of any kind nor should any get a birth certificate for their children born here unless they prove they were here legally at the time.
It's not just the teacher's union. All of the school workers are unionized.
Our school parents wanted to paint our janitor's office last year as a gift for him, but there were union rules against that.
Our parents wanted to volunteer in the library when the district cut the librarians, but the union rules wouldn't allow that.
It's a joke.
Forgot to agree with you on the illegals. I have little patience with the whole illegal situation, and it is one area that I do not agree with our president on.
That's what the kids say... "Dadgummit, let's go over to the Nursing Home and watch Dad gummit!!!" (That's what they say when they're not thinking about gittin the ranch)