Skip to comments.7-Year-Old Suspected In Beating Death Of Baby Sister
Posted on 06/02/2005 7:15:50 AM PDT by Puppage
TAMPA, Fla. -- In an attack that's rattled even veteran detectives, police in Florida said a 7-year-old boy has confessed to beating his baby sister to death.
Investigators said the boy was jealous of the attention the infant was getting and upset by her crying. They said the boy beat the baby with his fists, feet and a two-by-four.
The attack occurred in Tampa, while the boy was visiting his father.
Police said the father and his girlfriend were outside with neighbors when the boy came out and told them the baby was "bleeding." They said the seven-month-old had a bloody nose, and wasn't breathing. The parents rushed the baby to a hospital, where she was pronounced dead.
A spokesman said detectives noted they'd never seen someone so young "show so much violence and so little remorse."
May God have mercy!
Very upsetting. It also makes me mad. What causes this?
I really don't know what to say about this sort of thing.
A prayer is all I can come up with.
Why did they leave the infant alone with a 7 year old?
Tells me a lot...
And the Supreme Court says we can't put this kid to death.
Some of us on FR have been talking about the fact that recently we seem to be getting more and more child abuse/death stories. We can't figure out why that is.
Since you posted this one, I wanted to ask your motivation. Why post this story? What do you believe it achieves?
Thanks for your response.
He's 7 years old. Do you believe he has the mental capacity to understand what he did? Just asking.
Police said the father and his girlfriend.....
Ripping families apart and reassembling them can be torturous for little kids....
Punch, hit and smash in order to get the baby to STOP crying? B.S. A 7yrs old is plenty old enough to know that.
Parents probably went next door to drink, or smoke it up, should've never been out of ear shot.
You don't trust ANYONE with, or near, a newborn - cat, dog, kids, friends, etc. unless you are standing right there. They are just too damn fragile to risk or assume anything.
Bottom line - they screwed up raising their 7yr old and that chicken came home to roost.
Open your wallet, we're all going to be paying for this 7 yr old kid the rest of his life - jail, institutions, welfare, etc. The parents little "gift" to the rest of us.
Note the article said "while the child was visiting his father" and "the father's girlfriend". I read that to assume that (a) the boy didn't live with his father and (b) the baby probably was a half-sister, born of a relationship the father had with his "girlfriend". From those two observations, I would make a good guess that the child did not have much of a home life and that at least one of his parents was leading a tawdry life of his own, and (c) There was a lack of loving nurturing in the kid's own home, i.e. he's witnessed other beatings.
All that said, this is a dreadful act; but the kid is probably not altogether totally to blame.
Tells me a lot...
You got that right....that is all one really needs to know. Typical loser parents more concerned with their lust lives than anything. If these children had a loving, stable, two-parent (original parents) home, this would not have happened.
I think the unstable lives many children lead is a contributing element to their acting violently and irrationally.
You want to execute a 7 year old!?!? The boy is 7, not 17!
Adults who fail to civilize their children.
I hate to say this, but the kid should be put to death. If someone so young has the capacity to murder their own infant sister, then they don't deserve life themselves and do not belong on this planet.
I know I'm being harsh but no amount of "rehabilitation" has ever been shown to work. There is a 99% chance that this kid will do it again if given the chance.
We had a 4 y/o stab his sister to death here.
I honestly don't have a clue other than no one is paying attention to the kids.
A few years back we had an 11 year old stab his 13 year old neighbor to death because she wouldn't "date" him. There were no parents in either home at the time.
I think you may be thinking of the 9 year old girl in New York. This is a 7 year old boy. Both are horrific stories.
IIRC, I think that was from the story yesterday about the friend killing her friend with a knife.....this is a different story...but what does it really matter? It is all the same, all of it reeks of bad parenting.
What kind monsters are being raised?
A very good question......
Local news described the sibling relationship as step-sister. Also said the boy was jealous of attention the baby received.
Broken or disfunctional family situation I bet !!!
I have five grandchildren who have been taught through love to look out for one another , and they do , thank GOD .. .. ..
Devil's advocate here...
Lets say we DO put to death all kids who kill ...
Even the ones as young as 4....
1. Who does the killing?
2. How are they executed?
3. Would you want to live next door to the person who puts these kids to death?
4. Lastly, do we really, truly want to live in a country that executes children?
(and the first One Note Wanda Hijack of 'but we abort them' post will get a personal boot in the backside from me).
Differnt kid, differnt state, differnt story, same result.......
I do believe he knew what he was doing. When I was 7 I still had a lot to learn, but I had very very very very clear NO BEATING AND NO KILLING. If 7 year olds don't understand that, there would be way more killings like this.
You're either a troll or ignorant.
Please provide your proof that 99 percent of 7-year-olds who have killed somebody cannot be rehabilitated.
Some people are just defective, so you can't say this wouldn't happen, but I bet the odds of it happening would be FAR, FAR lower.....
I dissagree a little bit in that you NEVER leave a baby with anybody else. There are people you trust and that is OK. I left my baby with my father while I was shopping and I was reassure nothing would happen to him. Or you can have very close friends. I know people with kids sometimes cover up for each other. There is nothing wrong with it.
What is draining the innocence from so many childhoods? Perhaps the fact that fewer adults appear willing to expend the effort creating the environment that allows childhood to exist in the first place. As a society, we seem to be regressing to an ancient era.
OK, but lets say the kid is raised watching movies like "House of a 1000 Corpses" from the time he's born (I know a kid like this).
Lets say that hitting with fists, punches and slaps are a pretty common occurance.
Lets say that this kid pretty much has been left to raise himself.
With that, I can see how he could do what he did.
Why post ANY story? It's local area news posted on FR for people to comment on and debate if the story necessitates. It is the fabric of FR, is it not?
What's with the "achievement" angle????
Jealousy is also found in animals and many dog attacks are caused for the same reason.
kid in a non-stable family situation.
Not being fathered enough?
Not being controlled enough by a mother who uses him for emotional support?
I have heard of murderous attempts done by young kids who were sexually abused or physically abused as very small children, who had the bonds of trust shattered and had this horribly deep well of anger.
Whatever it is, it is a true tragedy for the people involved.
Do you think a 7 year old should be executed?
Correct-a-mundo , and well said Sax
"He's 7 years old. Do you believe he has the mental capacity to understand what he did?"
When I was about 3 (this is what my mother told me), my father took me to the grocery store, and I wanted a candy bar. He said "no"; I decided to take it anyway. We were about to leave the cashier when he discovered what I had in my hand. I was promptly spanked *in front of the cashier* and told to give it back. To this day I have never even thought about stealing anything.
Even though I don't remember the incident, I certainly learned my lesson - at 3 years old, no less. How's that for mental capacity? However cliche it sounds, it's squarely his parents' fault for not teaching him the value of right and wrong at a younger age.
The story of Cain and Able comes to mind.
They were outside on the lawn... Its not like they went to the store..
I don't think a 7 year old will ever be put death but look at Lionel Tate. Anyone here at the the time think he was going to be rehabilitated? Most FReepers probably thought he would lead a worthless life and he's proven us right. I don't know what you do with a 7 year old but it's probably too late for this boy. It's either the way he was raised, an unseen defect from birth, or both of those factors. Society will be hearing from/about this child again.
"If these children had a loving, stable, two-parent (original parents) home, this would not have happened."
Hard call to make there - I'm not sure of 100% of the details, but what about the would-be high school graduate who murdered his grandparents and friends before committing suicide? Wasn't his home stable? That's what I was led to believe, anyway.
Thanks for posting this story. I heard about it yesterday on the radio and couldn't find any other details.
These stories where young kids are killing babies and other young kids are heartbreaking.
"He's 7 years old. Do you believe he has the mental capacity to understand what he did? Just asking."
Do you believe he doesn't have the capacity to understand? If he doesn't have the capacity, why don't more 7 year olds kill? In fact, why don't 5 year olds, they have even less capacity to understand.
The fact is, he has enough reasoning ability to know he did something terribly wrong. At this point, he is a lost soul. I firmly believe he will be nothing but a burden on society for the rest of his days.
Death penalty? I don't know. Lock him away forever? Well, seems humane, but what kind of life is that? Prison doesn't rehabilitate, it hardens.
I don't have the answer, but I do believe this child is damaged beyond repair and should never be allowed to run free in society.
It's one of those "rectal estimates".
Wrong story. This is a 7 year old boy.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.