Posted on 08/03/2005 7:10:46 AM PDT by summer
ALBANY, N.Y. (AP) -- More dieters are ditching carb counts and biting into baguettes with gusto these days. ...
This week's bankruptcy filing by the late Dr. Robert C. Atkins' old company provide fresh evidence of the low-carb diet's demise, a downward spiral that began early last year. But no single new diet has filled the void.
Observers say the only sure thing -- given the boom-and-bust nature of weight-loss trends -- is that something will pop up eventually.
''There isn't one single strong contender,'' said Anne M. Russell, editor-in-chief of Shape magazine. ''If you look at what the single largest trend is, it's weight gain.''
Chapter 11 filings by Atkins Nutritionals Inc. on Monday came about a year and a half after books like ''The Atkins Essentials'' rode the best seller charts, bread makers were back on their heels and Burger King introduced a Whopper without a bun.
But Atkins has been in decline since February 2004, said Harry Balzer, a food industry analyst at market researcher NPD Group. Balzer claims Atkins was one of those demanding diets that simply ran its course, going from fad to fade like so many others before it, including the Scarsdale and the cabbage soup diets.
How far and how fast did Atkins fall? By September 2004, surplus low-carb products were being shipped to food banks in Appalachia....
Ruth Kava, director of nutrition for the American Council on Science and Health, figures it might be something like a high-protein diet.
''Somebody will come up with something new,'' she said. ''There's a lot of creativity out there in Diet World."
----
On the Net:
Government dietary guidelines: mypyramid.com
(Excerpt) Read more at nytimes.com ...
Everything else is just fluff.
Yes, but there are still a million ways to package that message in the eyes of creative marketers! :)
Damaging to the body how?
I think it failed because it is difficult, in American culture to deny yourself anything. Most Americans have been raised on a diet high in simple carbs (sugar and refined grains) and they are surrounded by it constantly. It's difficult to say no when everyone around you is eating the foods you love.
I predict there will not be any diet that the average American can stay on for the long haul. We (collectivly) are doomed to be fatter and fatter until someone invents a simple pill that dissolves fat, or something happens to make food less easily procured and exercise required (I don't mean by government regulation but in order to survive).
susie (yes, low carber since 1997)
Mmmmmm fluff.
Because it was eliminating foods your body needs and causing chemical changes in your body. It was a terrible diet. I can't believe that guy was a doctor. Though I noticed he was reportedly quite heavy at the time of his recent death.
Any diet that doesn't allow satisfying amounts of wine or beer is doomed to failure.
How exactly is it damaging to the body? Do you have proof of this, other than second or third hand rumor and gossip?
Weight lifters have used lo-carb for years. They use it to treat epiliptic kids. They treat diabetics with it.
How is it unhealthy?
I eat fresh meat, poultry, fish, vegetables, and cheese. How is this unhealthy?
I'm in thebest shape of my life. How has eating this way damaged my health? My doctor gives me flying colors when I have a physical.
How is lo-carbing "so damaging"?
"calories burned > calories consumed = weight loss."
True, but the types of food you eat can affect your metabolism which affects your calorie burning potential.
We all react differently to different foods...no one diet is good for everyone. When I cut back carbs I lose weight, feel better, sleep better, and don't get heartburn. With others, it may be the fat that is the culprit.
Atkins was too rigid and extreme though.
You are right-Atkins works!!! It hasn't failed, the business managers failed. I don't even understand how their bankruptcy has foddered these "no carb craze" discussions. What does one have to do with the other? That's like saying b/c Enron failed, energy doesn't work.
Have you read the book?
Ahh, but you can have as much of the clear spirits as you like. Gin, scotch, vodka, light rum. My sister calls this the "Gin Loophole"! And white wine has half the carbs as red.
Speaking of fluff, my college roommate had the most horrid dietary habits. We were raised on fresh or home-canned ruits & vegetables, we never had sodas in the house, rarely ate out and everything was cooked from scratch with very little frying, so you can imagine my shock when I walked in one day and she had spooned an entire jar of marshmallow fluff into a bowl, mixed it with pecans, microwaved it, and was eating it with a spoon.
It should be "moderate carbs" not "low carbs." Everything in moderation, the problem is the typical diet is extremely high in carbs. Just get carb intake down to a moderate level, but many took it as eliminating carbs altogether, which is ridiculous.
You should know that people who are diabetic MUST eat a low carb diet or it IS detrimental to their health.
1. The atkins diet is not damaging to the body, read the book, stop being a dumb ass. If you follow the instructions in the book the diet is far safer than the low fat diet, which will pack on the pounds, and leave you hungry.
2. No where does the article reference any data showing the popularity of the diet has wanned only that the company filed chapter 11. That would be like saying because Chrysler filed chapter 11 the popularity of the automobile is decreasing.
Before, all carbohydrate info-at-a-glance packaging could only be found in the painfully small diabetic foods subsection of one aisle. Now it's everywhere! :o)
1. Stupid article.
2. Wrong.
3. Ditto for your comment.
Dan (2 years + on Atkins, very healthy and happy)
calories burned > calories consumed = weight loss.
Everything else is just fluff.
lo-carb **is** a calorie reduction diet/lifestyle. If you watch your calories lo-carbing, you eat less calries, because you stay "full" longer. Eating proteins and fats satisfies your hunger a lot longer than eating carbs.
You can't change the laws of thermodynamics. Lo-carb is not a "magic bullet", it incorporates many of the things that any diet needs to have success in losing weight: calorie reduction, portion control, and avoiding certain foods. It also helps those with abused insulin response systems to take control back from the sugar spikes.
And Atkins himself pushed for daily exercise, the other part of the equation. Just eating lo-carb won't do it, you have to move your butt, too.
It is only in the first two weeks of Atkins where one avoids all carbs. After that, they are reintroduced until you find your "critical carb level". It makes sense. You come to find how many carbs you can have w/out gaining weight.
Major health food shops, i.e. Wild Oats, Whole Foods, didn't carry them and my local grocery store with a large "health foods" section, carried a very limited supply.
Now with South Beach going "over-the-counter" with ready-to-eat products made mostly by Kraft, they are including such things as "High fructose corn syryp", which is a very major no-no, so I won't purchase any more - period!
Major health food shops, i.e. Wild Oats, Whole Foods, didn't carry them and my local grocery store with a large "health foods" section, carried a very limited supply.
Now with South Beach going "over-the-counter" with ready-to-eat products made mostly by Kraft, they are including such things as "High fructose corn syryp", which is a very major no-no, so I won't purchase any more - period!
Major health food shops, i.e. Wild Oats, Whole Foods, didn't carry them and my local grocery store with a large "health foods" section, carried a very limited supply.
Now with South Beach going "over-the-counter" with ready-to-eat products made mostly by Kraft, they are including such things as "High fructose corn syryp", which is a very major no-no, so I won't purchase any more - period!
MMmmmmmmm...sugary goodness in my veins!
Nyack. That stuff would have a narcotic effect on me. *shudder*
Yeah, I also think part of the problem is that there are alot of other companies out there peddling low carb stuff too. The low carb *craze* was a real boon to people like me who were tired of having to make everything from scratch!
I also read that the guy who sued Atkins for his heart attack is funded by an animal rights org. This surprises me not at all. I personally think the AR orgs hate this diet because we eat animals and the govt doesn't like it much because it's not a cheap way to feed lots and lots of people.
susie
I'm not dead. Interesting. Wait...maybe I am! No....I just need more coffee....
susie
Low car wine is not bad. Very dry. You can also mix it with diet sprite for a decent spritzer...
susie
May I suggest the South Beach Diet. My loss has been 30 lbs in less than 11 weeks. It is not really much different than the old Weight Watchers, except that you don't have to obsess over weighing, measuring, exchanges, and points. And it allows enough carbs to keep the elimination system functioning. After the first 2 weeks, it is easy to follow, and you can order off of most restaurant menues. I feel great.
Right! I've lost weight very effectively by watching carbs (basically, lots of salad, avoiding bread, cake, potatoes), but I've also gained it back by returning to my preferred, almond-torte-rich diet.
Because it was eliminating foods your body needs and causing chemical changes in your body. It was a terrible diet. I can't believe that guy was a doctor. Though I noticed he was reportedly quite heavy at the time of his recent death.
Nonsense and poppycock.
My body does not NEED sugar or refined white flour. Period. Any nutrients I lack I can easily replace with a trip to GNC or any vitamin shelf.
**EVERYTHING** makes chemical changes in your body. When your body STOPS making chemical changes, then you need to worry, because then you're dead.
Beyond that, you should do some research, and find out what "insulin resistance" is, and how an abused body reacts to carbs, and how it's a vicious cycle, and how lo-carb helps break that cycle. Diabetics know all about it, or should.
Atkins died from a fall, and hitting his head. His lifestyle did not kill him.
So is obesity.
You really can't eliminate carbs altogether for very long. I've tried and it's just not possible. But Atkins does not eliminate carbs altogether anyway, so it's a moot point.
susie
...you ready for this...?
It's called...
The EAT LESS, EXERCISE MORE Diet. It's SO revolutionary that even the cavemen might've used it once. I'm telling you, once people catch on, they're going to wonder what they were worrying about all these years.
Please, tell your family, friends, co-workers, neighbors, kids, kid's friends, kid's friends parents, teachers, doctors, lawyers, cops and criminals... it's the new diet REVOLUTION... YEAAHAHHHHHHHHHHH
/Dean
And given the fact that people were dumb enough to go the Atkins route, I'll just start by saying that people need to put down the remotes and the keyboards and read more books. Nutrition and exercise books and magazines are prolific. I recommend Men's Health for the guys out there. I've been a subscriber since college, and I've lost a significant amount of weight thanks to their nutrition and exercise tips.
I'm not sure where you got the idea that it's horrible for the body. When I went to high protein, very low carb, cut out sugars and white flour, my cardiologist was and is absolutely delighted with my blood work, my weight loss, my over all general good health now.
That's true to a point. The body can only handle so many carbs in a short period of time. It has to convert the extra to fat. So in reality it's not so much how many calories in a day you consume, it's how dense those calories are in a short period of time. And many high processed, high density carb foods simply overwhelm the body's capacity to process sugars. Then even worse, if you don't eat for a period of time afterward, the metabolism slows down to the point where it will conserve the fat. The best way to lose weight is to basically "graze" during the day. Eat small meals every few hours. Keeps your metabolism constant and gives the body time to process the calories without overwhelming it.
My internist says it is her way of life. She has been living on Atkins for years. I tried but I was ready to "kill" for a piece of bread in less than a week. I was even dreaming about bread. Funny thing is I only eat one slice of toast for breakfast and seldom eat any more for the day. Without my breakfast toast I was a desperate woman.
Lemmie see if I can correct this...
(calories burned + calories expelled) > calories consumed = weight loss. Now that is more like it.
Actually, just eating low carb CAN do it. I'm proof. Certainly exercise is good for you (I'm an ex aerobics instructor, so I'm all about exercise). But when I went on it in about 1997, I lost about 40 lbs without doing any exercise (other than walking around that you normally do in a day--and I wasn't working, so it wasn't that much, believe me).
susie
Dieters haven't ditched low carb, they've ditched the high priced Atkins products. Actually, the idea behind the diet was changed after Dr. Atkins died and the company was more concerned with making $$ rather than promoting the doctor's ideas. The book versions after his death were also going out in left field from his original diet. It's certainly not surprising the media and the uninformed public can't/won't distinquish between the company and the diet.
I can't believe people still think it's all about eating bacon piled high with butter three times a day. The only foods the "original" Atkins restricted was the same as what your greatgrandmother knew in her time - don't eat white foods (sugar, starch, and breads).
Atkins Nutritionals Inc. failed because of increased competition. Today, there is a plethora of carb conscious products out there and the Atkins stuff is on the expensive end of the scale. They lost their virtual monopoly and weren't able to respond well.
What do you mean? The Atkins diet has been around for over 30 years, so it can hardly be called a fad diet. And what evidence do you have that it's damaging to the body?
Personally, I have never tried the Atkins diet. I believe in the "everything in moderation" philosophy. Too much of anything can be bad, but there is no denying that a low-carb, low-sugar diet is healthy. I prefer to look at it as a more all-natural diet--that is, staying away from processed ingredients like high-fructose corn syrups, artificial sweeteners, hydrogenated oils, etc.
People overeat and under-exercise because that is the easier way to live. Sloth and gluttony are two of the seven deadly sins for a reason.
People KNOW this.
They really want to continue to overeat and under-exercise so they look for an easy way out.
Diets offer the promise of an easier way out.
Pills, drinks, magic candy bars, special exercise equipment.....they ALL offer the promise of instant, er, well, "3-week" promise of a better something or other.
People want the MAGIC PILL.
The only way to get fit and lose fat is to stop thinking in terms of WEIGHT and LOOKS.
It's just too simple -- EAT LESS and EXERCISE MORE.
Way too simple.
The problem for me is, Atkins bars are the best!
I haven't found anything nearly as good as the chocolate PB bar -- must others are like chewing hardened Play-Do or clay. Ditto S'Mores, and their new granola bars. And believe me, I've looked!
Dan
)c8
I agree. It was not a diet that could be sustained, and if people did sustain, it was so unbalanced it would lead to all manner of health problems.
The solution, which I am working on, is eating less, less fats and refined sugars, no artifical or pre-prepared foods, never any sodas and few if any desserts, and exercise more.
It also helps greatly to never eat at night (like after dark), and there are certain herbs which help with fat metabolism. And I DON'T mean Herbalife.
Gotta agree with ByDesign. Many people failed on Atkins because they didn't understand or follow the long-term program. They stuck to the initial elimination portion of the diet and predictably got bored.
The Atkins diet was a quite reasonable one, incorporating carbs - good ones - into the diet over time on a regular basis. The main thing over the long term was to eat better, and less of everything. And, get exercise. Nothing wrong with all that.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.