Posted on 08/15/2005 5:49:58 AM PDT by OESY
I'd also mention that I don't think of Canadian lumber producers in terms of just British Columbia. Some of the largest pulp and paper mills in Canada are actually in Alberta, not BC -- and these mills are busier than ever because it's cheaper to do business in Alberta than in BC.
Ottawa sold out the forest industry (and the west...again) when they signed.
Ironically, lumber was always duty free before the free trade agreement.
But IMO, the free trade agreement was still a very good agreement for Canada.
And Ottawa has made the best use they can of the softwood problem. Since then it has been used as an election tool for the Liberals to bad mouth Americans with.
IMO Washington is not going to back down here either as it is one of the few things left to them with which to influence Ottawa.
"Sure, we'll sell you all the oil you need down there -- but for each barrel of oil you have to buy a load of (duty-free) lumber."
:-)
No mention of raw logs...just cut lumber...hmmm
And I would expect a hearty response.
I find it hard to believe an Albertan wants to link the two issues diplomatically though, as it will cost Alberta the most.
IMO Ottawa will not interfere in exports to the USA in any other of its life bread industrys, especially energy, to appease the softwood lumber industry.
Look for soft ball tactics, mostly aimed at farmers.
They charge what is known as a stump fee of around $200.00 per 1000 board feet to the Timber companies that do the logging (In the USA the timber companies get charged a fee by our Government of around $700.00 per 1000 board feet), this does not include all the regulations our Government imposes on timber companies here(Replants, emissions etc).
So wouldn't the best thing to do be to lower the Stump Fee here in the US to $200.00 and just lessen the Feds requirements to timber companies? Or do you just want to give the Canadians the upper hand in this without regard for our country?
Or do you just want to give the Canadians the upper hand in this without regard for our country?
That's a very good question. One thing to remember here is that on a "level playing field" the Canadians will always have the upper hand in this industry simply because there are a lot more trees up there than down here in the U.S.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.