Skip to comments.Transcript of Christopher Hitchens on subject of Cindy Sheehan from Wed. night's Hardball
Posted on 08/18/2005 10:18:15 AM PDT by Charlesj
ODONNELL: Im sure also the president did not anticipate that while he was spending a five-week vacation at his ranch in Crawford, Texas, that he would be witnessing a mom, Cindy Sheehan, who has been camped outside his ranch now, demanding a meeting with the president, saying she wont leave until that happens.
Christopher, do you think that this representsor she represents some sort of tipping point in public opinion in America?
HITCHENS: Certainly not. She has, just today, lied about a statement that she made several times before to the effect that her son was killed in a war run by a secret Jewish cabal within the administration. She now says she didnt make that statement. She did make that statement. So as well as being an hysterical paranoid ideologist, or at least being manipulated by people who are, turned this into camp fruitbag and nutbag, she has decided not to have the courage or maybe the cowardice of her conviction. She now says she didnt make a statement that she definitely did.
(Excerpt) Read more at msnbc.msn.com ...
I watched that...
Hitchens just ripped into her.
Was ODONNELL shell shocked when he said it?
No. Actually. She seemed to think it was kind of amuzing.
It's interesting how the media have given Sheehan a pass from the normal scrutiny directed towards public figures. If Sheehan had been some rabid conservative camped out at Clinton's summer home, the MSM would have been looking into - and publicizing - her past and present political affiliations, her financial connections, her handlers, her inconsistencies, her lying, and her numerous outrageous public comments about the president and about our country. But the MSM is pretty much looking the other way, and it's people like Hitchens and Drudge who have to raise these issues.
Hitchens needn't get so emotional. He's the only one on the tube expressing common sense on the subject of Cindy Sheehan.
LOL ... me too. I think we should start calling her 'Mother Moonbat".
Well, that's interesting.
Her and Fineman seemed to grudgingly agree with Hitchens.
They just tried to laugh it off though.
Hey champ...google is your friend. Not hard to find. He's talking off the cuff...he should come up with a quote then and there? Let's get real.
Do you smell ozone? ;^)
Hi... Cindy Sheehan, Rush Chairman,
DAMN GLAD TO MEET YOU!!!
Bu bye ....
Here's alive idiot!!!!
The direct quote isn't hard to find if you really are interested in reading it. But DU trolls like yourself will never look because that's how you approach facts. You and your DU comrades ignore facts, but serious people who care about this country and our military takie the time to learn the facts.
To do that you have to leave the moveon.org/DU/michealmoron/Al Jazzeria websites because all they are is propaganda
Some Israel references of Sheehan:
"Yes, he was killed for lies and for a PNAC Neo-Con agenda to benefit Israel. My son joined the Army to protect America, not Israel."
"[My son] was killed for a neo-con agenda that only benefits a very chosen few in this world. This agenda and their war machine will chew up and spit out as many of our children as they can unless we stop them now.
We should not let Israel/USA invade Syria or Iran."
"The other thing I want him to tell me is 'just what was the noble cause Casey died for?' Was it freedom and democracy? Bull---t! He died for oil. He died to make your friends richer. He died to expand American imperialism in the Middle East. We're not freer here, thanks to your PATRIOT Act. Iraq is not free. You get America out of Iraq and Israel out of Palestine and you'll stop the terrorism,"
"And yet he remains unable to produce a direct quote. Perhaps he'd locate one if it got between him and a gin & tonic."
Hey troll, here's your quote from Dementia Queen Sheehan. Sounds to me like she's claiming the Jews are to blame:
Am I emotional? Yes, my first born was murdered. Am I angry? Yes, he was killed for lies and for a PNAC Neo-Con agenda to benefit Israel. My son joined the Army to protect America, not Israel.
Hey, sparkey, you signed up today just to bless us with that pearl of wisdom? Do some homework.
And yet if Hitchens had been, say, Molly Ivins, and had said, "Church experts who have asked to remain anonymous agree, Catholic or not Sheehan should be sainted", O'Donnell would have been nodding her head like a bobble-head doll.
For those who haven't already read Hitchens' piece about Cindy Sheehan that appeared in Slate.
Here's the link http://www.slate.com/id/2124500/
ABC did not retreat, in fact they confirmed that this letter was signed by Sheehan and sent to them on her behalf.
They have asked Anderson Cooper of CNN retract his statements and apologize
FR thread with the info:
I think we should start calling her 'Mother Moonbat".
LOL - Great Idea!
Lying, creepy liars are not well received here....
"They have asked Anderson Cooper of CNN retract his statements and apologize"
Cooper just ignored it and pretended it didn't happen.
I got the impression that all of them - O'Donnell, Finneman and Hitchens -- were all on the same page.
The tide is turning against Cindy.
Have you never heard of compassionitivity???
Yeah... That was my impression too.
It was like O'Donnell and Fineman didn't want to say it as plainly as Hitchens, but they seemed to agree that Sheehan is a moonbat.
"I think our profession should stop acting as her megaphone. Until I published her real political opinions in Slate yesterday, she had to answer no more questions than, how does it feel? OK? I object. I shouldnt have had to do that.
I said, this woman is mouthing the most sinister piffle from Michael Moore and David Duke. She should be held responsible for what she thinks. When she was asked about it finally by Anderson Cooper yesterday, she said, I didnt say it. Shes also a liar."
How dare Hitchens challenge St. Cindy's views? Doesn't he know she has "absolute moral authority" to say what she wants and no one else is allowed to say anything about it?
Why is there a subtle scent of ozone around this thread... ?
Fineman says that the ground is shifting under Bush's feet re. Iraq. Ok Howard, but we know that the opinion polls are rigged (grossly oversurveying dems) and that Cindy is a liar and, well, just a mouth piece for the same ole groups with the same ole messages.
I think, Howard, you will find that if the ground is shifting anywhere, it is under the feet of Ms. Sheehan and her mouthpieces.
Howard, the anti-war schtick has rarely brought any party to power.
Exactly! That's what I was thinking......neither one of them said one word to disagree with him!
He was FABULOUS; I find myself agreeing with him so many times, it scares me.......LOL.
LOL Poor Cindy has gotten a dose of reality from Hitch. Something in Short supply in Camp Fruicake.
Norah O'Donnell had a look on her face like Hitchens wipped out his schlong.(shock and Horror what i could tell.
Oh, and he just ripped little Miss Seditious Moonbat Puppet a new one.
Has ABC actually asked CNN to make a correction? I couldn't find anything suggesting that on the link.
"ABC News also said they spoke to CNN to see if they are going to run a correction about the statement Anderson Cooper made that "ABC News does not seem to be confirming this is what Cindy Sheehan wrote to them."
I'm listening to Rush at the moment. He says someone called in to tell him that he stayed overnight in a Crawford motel and Cindy Sheehan was staying in the room below him. So much for the vigil. She said some days ago that she moved to the Peace House because there were fire ants in her tent, but if anyone remembers those hippy cribs from the 60s there are very few people who can stay in places like that.
Sometimes Hitchens is just "spot on."
Many thanks! This'll be an interesting "watch and wait" (like waiting for icycles to form in Gehenna).
I read on one of the numerous threads on Sheehan that she was caught at a hotel and explained that she had a tv interview with ABC's "Good Morning America" so she needed a good nights sleep in order to look good for the show.