Posted on 09/10/2005 4:46:12 AM PDT by Colonel Kangaroo
A witting historical lie of the first rank. The governor of Virginia was John Letcher, and his government sat at Richmond undisturbed by the cabal put together by Cornershooter Abe throughout 1861-3, the period during which Lincoln used the military occupation of western Virginia to create a "state" ex nihilo.
Lincoln used the Constitution to shine his shoes.
Don't waste your time. Neo-Confederates are cultists, impervious to logic or facts.
< Besides, with the exception of the Eastern Panhandle, I sincerely doubt that the state of Virginia would want West Virginia back! >
...and we don't want to go back.
...and you can't have the Eastern PH either...so there...nanner....nanner.
My best bud has told me that "...though you my never be a hillbilly, you may be a Mountain William." }:^)
Congress (the real, U.S. one) agreed to seat the two U.S. Senators elected by the loyalist government of Virginia, so yes indeed Congress recognized that state government as legitimate.
No, I don't. I said that, under the Unionist theory, Virginia never left the Union. Of course she did.
West Virginia was a conquered province. Lincoln just didn't want to admit that the States that had left the Union, had become another country.
So he lied a lot.
Look in the mirror, drone. You wear your own intractability like a badge of honor in your screen name, and you accuse other people of your own favorite vice.
You never know, Manchin may try to sell it!
With the infamous Salmon P. Chase, party of the first part to the original felony, presiding.
Crooked court, crooked case, crooked result.
Sat in Richmond, faithful to Virginia's People, while her favorite son covered himself in undying glory afield with her armies.
Your fictions are so wretched, they are a joke.
The Supreme Court in 1871 had nine Yankees on it, 5 selected by Lincoln himself.
They're a-tryin' to git around me on my left, general!
Are you sure that Congress let the Senators selected by the loyalist Virginia legislature take their seats? Virginia wasn't represented later during the Presidency of Andrew Johnson. In the 1868 trial of Andrew Johnson, there were only 54 senators voting. There were then 37 states (the 36 in the Union as of Lincoln's death plus Nebraska, admitted in 1867), so there should have been 74 senators, but 10 Southern states were not represented (the 11 which had belonged to the Confederacy, minus Tennessee, readmitted in 1866).
The irony here is that West Virginia is still officially listed as a southern state.
Yes, they were U.S. Senators Waitman Willey and John Carlile. See http://politicalgraveyard.com/geo/VA/ofc/ussen.html for more information.
Holidays come and holidays go. This country no longer reveres antiquated white men. The next and greatest holiday will celebrate The Prophet or perhaps Mother Kali.
HELLO! Americans let's focus please.
Damn! I keep forgetting that somewhere it says that only Supreme Court decisions that you personally agree with are valid decisions. I'm going to have to write that down for future reference.
That's because all the southern justices had resigned and run off to join the rebellion. I imagine that they had visions of helping establish the confederate supreme court. Boy, weren't they surprised!
Regardless, Virginia v West Virginia was a 7 to 3 decision, and by agreeing to hear it the court recognized West Virginia's status as a state.
If there had not been a Lincoln there would not be a West Virginia. That is like Texas forgetting about Sam Houston.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.