Generalized assertions that Marshall was wrong carry little weight. I don't know what "notable faction" of dissenters is referred to. Who were they, what did they write, where can it be found? I am referring to the specific question of the applicability of the Bill of Rights of 1791 to the state governments.
Incorporation is a mess. Incorporation is a mess. Incorporation is a mess. Multiply that by 1000 and you'll figure out what I think about it.