Posted on 12/21/2005 9:55:50 AM PST by BurbankKarl
ping
I bet Milton Bradley is rolling over in his grave, hearing that people can go to jail for tampering with a game.
If I buy a clock-radio that I want to make into a CD player by using parts from my portable CD player, I should be able to. GE can't come and sue me for modifying MY radio. If I want to add MP3 player capabilities to it, I can with off the shelf parts, the same rules apply to X-Box.
You can't play games you've borrowed?
In other news: Scammers jingle all the way Playing favorites on the Net? AOL gets $1 billion boost from Google During the investigation, undercover agents with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement paid $265 to have a modification chip, a hard drive and 77 pirated games installed on an Xbox, according to the criminal complaint.
I have no sympathy for the MPAA/RIAA/M$ etc... But this is the part I support. Modding shouldn't be an issue, but 77 pirated games certainly is.
These "mod chips" aren't the issue. You're right, you have the legal right to do whatever you want with an XBox you pay for.
The law is broken because modded XBoxes have a hacked version of the Microsoft COPYRIGHTED BIOS on them. (I know this because *cough* a friend of mine has a modded XBox.)
This modified BIOS causes the XBox to recognize a far larger hard drive than the one that ships with the system, and permits copying RENTED games or borrowed games to this larger hard drive, effectively allowing the owner to keep a game on the system he never paid for.
This second issue is called theft and/or software piracy.
To summarize, you DO have the right to mod your XBox. As soon as you drop a hacked BIOS on it, you are in violation of federal law, and will be prosecuted if caught. You exacerbate the crime if you choose to use your illegal XBox to pirate software.
They can GO TO JAIL, GO DIRECTLY TO JAIL. DO NOT PASS GO. DO NOT COLLECT $200.,..................
Now if they were just selling the chips and instructions on how to modify the system boards, that's another story, as that, then, becomes a private property issue. If this were an issue, we'd have a society spiraling out of control in a litigious quagmire where everyone can sue anyone for anything at any time. We wouldn't want that now, would we... wait...
/sarcasmOff
You seem to be a little too sensitive for the holiday season...you need to relax, and try to find some humor in things.
Oh I have humor. FREAKIN OODLES OF FREAKIN HUMOR!!!!!
;)
Is this right, though? The BIOS chips are removable EEPROMs that can be replaced, no? I've replaced BIOS chips in my comps all the time, but does a proprietary BIOS on a proprietarily run board mean that you can't pop out the BIOS and replace it with, say, an Award or Phoenix BIOS? If the board boots, it's ok, right?
I'd imagine if you popped the BIOS EEPROM out, put it into a reader and re-engineered the BIOS AROUND the proprietary system, then you'd be in violation.
In this case, I believe the "mod chip" they're talking about is something that has to be soldered onto the mainboard and circumvents certain registered media protections to allow burned games to be played. That is illegal, I believe, but I contend the BIOS switchout wouldn't be. Any thoughts?
I take it the caps were just raucus laughter??!!
"This modification may be illegal. But what does ICE have to do with modifying X-boxes? This appears to have happened in the United States. Aren't there some illegal aliens they should be catching?"
That's Immigration and CUSTOMS Enforcement. Selling hacked toys is a trade issue (potentially high dollar too) and that would explain the ICE involvement.
Merry Christmas,
Top sends
I thought he just signed with the A's? ;)
You are correct in that a BIOS switchout is not illegal in and of itself. The BIOS itself is Microsoft intellectual property, and has been reverse-engineered and modified to support the altered XBox. As you stated, this is what makes it illegal.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.