Skip to comments.Who Killed Pat Tillman?
Posted on 12/26/2005 3:38:48 PM PST by Tolerance Sucks Rocks
The American mass media are like tired old dogs, dutifully fetching official lies on command and dropping them like bones at the feet of an unsuspecting public. We in turn reward them by buying both the products and the myths they sell us. Eventually, however, the products fail and the myths unravel. When the government's popularity wanes sufficiently, despite the support of a compliant press, even old dogs can come up with new tricks, reviving the lost art of investigative reporting.
Take the Pat Tillman story. Remember him? He was the star National Football League defensive back who, after the 9/11 attacks, walked away from his $3.6 million contract with the Arizona Cardinals to enlist as an elite U.S. Army Ranger and go off to Afghanistan to whip some terrorist a**. No matter what your opinion on the U.S. invasion of Afghanistan, or your theory on who was ultimately responsible for the 9/11 attacks, Tillman was clearly acting as a selfless hero in the traditional sense of the word. The media sang only one song at the time-dirtbags in Afghanistan did this to us-and "deterrence" through violent retribution was the only discussable response. Both Tillman and his brother Kevin, like most every American, bought into the program-but they actually volunteered to fight.
After joining up, however, they weren't shipped off to Afghanistan, where they believed terrorists were holed up, but to Iraq to fight in a newly minted war that didn't exist when they signed away control of their lives. Here's where the recruiting poster image deviated from the script. There was a lot more depth to Tillman, who was pursuing a master's degree in history, than one would normally expect of an NFL gladiator. Afghanistan had been an easier sell, but Tillman would never buy the official line on Iraq. At one point, according to a San Francisco Chronicle article published nearly a year and half after his death, he told fellow Rangers fighting in Iraq that the war was, "so f***ing illegal." A close friend told the paper, "That's who he was-he totally was against Bush." Tillman's mother clarified, explaining that her son believed the Afghanistan war was justified by the September 11th attacks but "Pat was very critical of the whole Iraq War." Another friend, who served with him, recalled how Tillman admonished fellow Rangers to vote Bush out of office in the forthcoming presidential election.
The Chomsky Factor
Tillman, we now know, was also in contact with one of his favorite authors, America's leading intellectual dissident, Noam Chomsky. According the Chronicle, Tillman had set up a meeting with Chomsky to take place when he returned from Afghanistan, where he eventually wound up after serving his tour in Iraq.
This image of a Chomsky-loving, anti-Bush, anti-Iraq-war hero (at a time when most of the U.S. population supported the administration's foreign policy), flew in the face of the official Bush administration portrait of Tillman, painted by dutiful media whores like Ann Coulter, who once described him in near-racialist terms as "An American original-virtuous, pure and masculine, like only an American can be." (Max Blumenthal, blogging for the online Huffington Post, asked if we could have Coulter's line in the original German).
As both wars droned on, Tillman, the picture perfect poster boy, evolved into something of a wild card. With a Chomsky meeting on the horizon there existed a very real possibility that Tillman, in the weeks leading up to the 2004 presidential election, might go public with his anti-war, anti-Bush views, dealing a critical blow to the very foundation of the Bush administration's propaganda pyramid. That day never came, however. On April 22, 2004, Tillman was killed while on patrol in Afghanistan by three American bullets to the head.
Jessica Lynch Redux
Immediately, evidence surrounding the killing began to disappear. One day after his death someone burned his body armor. Two days later someone burned his uniform. At some point his journal, which he religiously wrote in, went missing. With that journal disappeared Tillman's voice.
Meanwhile the Bush administration's professional liars began spinning one of their tallest tales, with their cohorts in the Pentagon explaining how the hero Tillman was killed by enemy fire. Bush himself chimed in to announce that Tillman was "an inspiration on and off the football field, as with all who made the ultimate sacrifice in the war on terror." The Pentagon, as it did with the Jessica Lynch story, spewed forth so many lies as to bury itself under an obvious pile of bullshit. The Army issued Tillman a postmortem Silver Star for bravery, explaining in the process how, "through the firing Tillman's voice was heard issuing fire commands to take the fight to the enemy on the dominating hill ground." And this is the story the media reported to the world.
Reports of Fratricide
But files obtained by Tillman's mother, from three Army investigations into the killing, document a different set of last words. According to testimony issued by a fellow Ranger, who was at Tillman's side when he was killed, the last words Tillman shouted before being shot were, "Cease fire, friendlies, I am Pat F***ing Tillman, dammit!"
According to the San Francisco Chronicle, Ranger commanders received a report the day after his death stating that Tillman died in a suspected act of fratricide, the crime of killing members of your own group. But the more they were confronted with the truth of what happened, the harder Army officials stuck to the official lies. One week after his death they pulled the Silver Star move, successfully milking the hero dying in action myth in a compliant media environment. Two weeks after his death the Army's official casualty report stated that he was killed by enemy forces. Six weeks later, however, with the mythic version of Tillman's killing firmly embedded in the American conscious, and with the Tillman story safely buried in the ashbin of "old news," the Army finally told Tillman's family that the official cause of death was "fratricide."
By all accounts, Tillman was popular and loved by the troops with whom he served-supporting the theory that his death was in fact a tragic accident. One of the Army investigations, however, suggested leveling charges of criminal intent against the killer or killers, prompting Tillman's mother to ask, "I want to know what kind of criminal intent there was." But all she has been able to glean from over 2,000 pages of official reports are contradictions, continuously changing stories, and countless blacked out lines.
Putting It All Together
What we have with the Tillman case is a cover-up and a fabrication. What was covered up was the embarrassing reality surrounding the futility of his death-the wasting of an iconic American hero. What was fabricated was a fairy tale story of a heroic battle, one that would support the Bush administration's global war effort while not undermining its military recruiting. What was deliberately ignored was an incident at his funeral-reported in the May 4, 2004, San Francisco Chronicle and New York Daily News-when Tillman's youngest brother, Rich, took offense at words that Tillman was now "with God"; he stated to the gathering, "Pat isn't with God. He's f***ing dead. He wasn't religious." More importantly, what was buried was the complex story of Pat Tillman's opposition to the Iraq war and the Bush agenda. Murdered in this fabrication and cover-up, therefore, was the real Pat Tillman. According to his father, "The administration clearly was using this case for its own political reasons. This cover-up started within minutes of Pat's death, and it started at high levels."
Only now, as a flood of public opinion is forcing the media to report critically about the Bush administration, will we possibly see a real investigation into how Pat Tillman died. And if we are persistent enough we might even see a proper investigation into why Tillman, and thousands of other Americans, and tens of thousands of Iraqis and Afghanis, had to give up their lives.
Michael I. Niman is a professor of journalism at Buffalo State College in New York. This article is adapted from the version appearing in the November 10, 2005, issue of ArtVoice. Dr. Niman's previous articles are archived at www.mediastudy.com.
Why does his college get one federal dollar?
So if I'm reading this correctly, the "Professor" is implying Tillman's death was the result of a deliberate conspiracy by the evil Bush Administration to prevent him from meeting with his idol Chomsky?
I just read this fast...but, did this guy just insinuate that Tillman was killed because of his relationship with Chomsky...and the plans to use his "anti-war, anti-Bush" stance in the run up to the elections???
Didn't seem to work. I think the American people, except for those who don't like any war that is started by a Republican, understand that in any war, there will be soldiers who are killed by their own because of identification problems in the heat of battle, or for many different reasons. It is sad, just as it is when soldiers are killed in any battle, but it doesn't make the overall effort any less noble.
One mention of Chomsky discredits an author and article.
Is there the slightest bit of truth to this story?
I find it hard to believe.
The only truth in this article might be that Pat Tillman was an Army Ranger and was killed in Iraq.
I wonder why this wasn't given a barf alert tag.
Tillman was killed in Afghanistan.
I don't believe a word of this drivel. They SAY he was going to meet with Chomsky. They SAY he hated Bush. Any proof? Sounds like his mother is just a Cindy Sheehan-in-training. She, like Sheehan, does not honor his sacrifice with this crap.
was the embarrassing reality surrounding the futility of his death-the wasting of an iconic American hero.
So does the professor mean we can only be heros if we are a famous football, baseball, hockey, etc., star and under no circumstances should these so-called "stars" join us peons in dangerous situations?????
I'm very skeptical. I understood that Tillman was killed in Afghanistan, but this story says Iraq. A fact like that would be nearly impossible to cover up.
I am sure that before its all over it will be Bush's fault that he was killed, or ordered killed, or whatever they are trying to say.
Everything is Bush's fault, everything! The dems are so hungry for power they are willing to bring down America in the process of gaining power. If they get that power that they so severely seek, will there be a Country left to have power over??
In combat, in uniform and in service to his country.
Dog food for people who love to swallow lies.
Indeed. I have never understood the hubub about how he died. It was how he lived that mattered.
"On April 22, 2004, Tillman was killed while on patrol in Afghanistan ..."
Add an f in front of that l.
Mr. C. How are the Fonz and Richie doing?
Yes he was, and here's a link:
This is garbage.
That was my brother Howard.
Oh, I thought you were Howard after he gave up the bottle. Sorry for the mistake.
I wish it HAD been....it is totally BARF ALERT worthy.
I have to admit that I haven't read everything about Pat Tillman...but this is the first I have heard about his relationship with Chomsky...or his anti-war views..
I don't like Chomsky any more than the next guy, having had to slog through his pseudo-intellectual mush during grad school, but I'm not sure I'd pop a cap in a guy who wanted to meet him.
Meeting Chomsky in person has to be punishment enough in itself.
Michael I. Niman
I could be wrong, but the good professor appears to have Democrat tendencies.
To be honest, I think it's made up.
There's a guy on a local forum I go on who posts every single conspiracy theory he can find. If you look hard enough, you can find an article for just about anything and any political thing you want.
That loud sound was the irony flying right over your head.
I know he died in Afghanistan.
Irony can fly??? Geez, that's a pressing issue, I'll have to steel it back before it steams anyone or they join the club.
Cheech and Chong Go to College...
Make that Cheetah and Chong.
Eh? What is that about - sort of sets this guy's comments in context. What media is she a whoring for? Most can't stand her.
If the all powerful BUSH CONSPIRACY was so worried about soldiers against the Iraq war that it assassinated Tillman, why did they let Wesley Clark and Kerry live?
A growing number of "professors" seem to be dangerous lunatics.
And kudos to the "Humanist" for further discrediting their pathetic rag.
THAT cannot be the real person...gotta be photoshopped or is someone joking around.
I don't believe a word of it.
The Tillman Jekyll and Hide crap smells. A concoction from the fever swamps of DU and John Kerry. I don't think any serious student of history would ever even think of meeting with the complete marxist phony Noam Chomsky. And as Mark Twain said, "The Thirteenth Stroke of a Clock is not only false of itself, but casts exceedingly grave reservation on the veracity of the preceding twelve..."
She is the darling of some of those guys on talk radio though.
Put Wesley and Kerrey together and you get Kerley or Werrey.
I suspected at the time that the left would take out Tillman for the expected anti-wot propaganda value. If they did, then this would be the typical "beat them to the accusation" tactic that they use habitually.
"beat them to the accusation
Say that phrase real fast and it provides a more realistic picture.
There is general agreement that Tillman was killed in a friendly fire incident. Unfortunately, from time to time that happens. The rest of it is complete out of left field, and I don't believe a word of it without seeing some better evidence than this creep.
"painted by dutiful media whores like Ann Coulter."
After joining up, however, they weren't shipped off to Afghanistan, where they believed terrorists were holed up, but to Iraq to fight in a newly minted war that didn't exist when they signed away control of their lives ... he returned from Afghanistan, where he eventually wound up after serving his tour in Iraq.
This article is confusing. I'm still skeptical.
Where does it say that? Pls quote.
Ann Coulter is a media whore?!!
That don't make a lick of sense.
The Pentagon, as it did with the Jessica Lynch story. . . .
I'll have to depend upon my memory to dispute this employee of Buffalo State College's story. Though registered I now find it difficult to access W-P stories.
The Pentagon never presented Private Lynch as a hero. A couple of employees of The Washington Post splashed the story of her "fighting to the death" on the front pages based upon a female army officer's feeeeeeling that that is what happened. No one knew at the time the real story.
As far as the Tillman family's tragic loss I can only say that if you are doing heroic things and tragically die by "friendly fire" it does not subtract from your heroism, IMO.
Not getting a consistent story out of the Pentagon does torment the Tillman family. But to say the confusion was intentional is wrong, IMO.
One thing that struck me about searching for info on the story was the use of the word "fratricide" -- a word that the employee of Buffalo State College jumped on given the word's conotation.
I did manage to get access to one old W-P story. The "news" article used the word fratricide. "Friendly" fire is bad enough -- but fratricide?! Why not "fragging" or is that too Viet Nam?
A quick search for info on the employee of Buffalo State College suggests to me that he is not without an agenda.
Now his typings make sense.
Tillman's parents have been very outspoken. And they did, if the SF Chronicle isn't lying, confirm he was going to meet with Chomsky.