Skip to comments.Sources: Wilson (D) petitions not valid (OH-6)
Posted on 02/22/2006 3:44:14 PM PST by LdSentinal
LISBON Charles A. Wilson Jr. doesn't have enough valid signatures on his nominating petitions to run in the Democratic primary for the 6th Congressional District race, The Vindicator has learned.
The Columbiana County Board of Elections is left with no other choice but to disqualify Wilson's candidacy for the seat at its meeting today.
Wilson has only 48 valid signatures on his nominating petitions, according to two Democratic sources and one Republican source with knowledge of his petitions. Congressional candidates need 50 valid signatures from registered voters in their districts to get on the ballot.
Wilson, a state senator from St. Clairsville, was widely considered the favorite to win the May 2 three-man Democratic primary for the 6th District.
Wilson has said there are 50 valid signatures on his petitions.
His petitions had 96 signatures, all from Belmont and Scioto counties. Those counties are split into two congressional districts, and 43 of the signatures on his petitions came from voters who live in other congressional districts.
Of the 53 from 6th District residents, five were thrown out for various reasons, considered fatal flaws under state law, including those who listed post office boxes as addresses and one person who didn't list an address, those with knowledge of Wilson's petitions said. That leaves Wilson with 48 signatures from valid registered voters in the 6th: 41 from Belmont and seven from Scioto.
Wilson and his supporters acknowledge the campaign should have collected signatures in other counties.
Wilson has said he forgot his home county of Belmont is a split county even though he lives in the part that isn't in the 6th District. St. Clairsville is a community in the 18th Congressional District.
"Charlie Wilson appears to be grossly unfamiliar with the congressional district he wants to represent in Congress," said Ed Patru, a spokesman for the National Republican Congressional Committee.
Once disqualified, Wilson can appeal the decision to the Columbiana County elections board by the deadline Monday. If the board dismisses the protest, Wilson can file a complaint in the 7th District Court of Appeals.
If a legal challenge fails, Wilson can run as a write-in candidate in the Democratic primary or seek the job in the November general election as an independent.
"Those decisions have yet to be made," Wilson said Tuesday.
The write-in candidacy deadline is March 13. A simple form declaring his candidacy as a write-in is all that's needed to run that way.
Party chief's input
Chris Redfern, the Ohio Democratic Party chairman, said he'd prefer Wilson run as a write-in. The chairman said it would cost Wilson's campaign a considerable amount of money to make Democratic primary voters in the 12-county congressional district aware of Wilson's write-in candidacy and how to cast ballots for him.
To run as an independent in the general election, Wilson would need petitions with 1,886 valid signatures, according to the Columbiana County elections board. That number equals 1 percent of the total votes in the 2002 gubernatorial election.
Some Wilson campaign advisers want to go the independent route. But Redfern sees that as problematic.
"When we do sample Democratic ballots, we don't want to include an independent candidate," Redfern said, because it causes voter confusion.
Redfern said the state party doesn't have to endorse or support the winner of the Democratic primary. The two Democrats in the party's primary for the 6th District seat are Bob Carr of Wellsville and John Stephen Luchansky of Boardman.
As one of the few open seats in a competitive congressional district President Bush captured 51 percent of the district's vote in 2004 national Republicans and Democrats consider this to be one of the most important House races in the country. U.S. Rep. Ted Strickland, a Lisbon Democrat, isn't running for re-election this year, opting to run for governor.
State Rep. Charles Blasdel of East Liverpool is considered the Republican front-runner in this race.
"Whether he runs as a Democrat or an independent, we will bury Charlie Wilson," Patru said.
"I'm incompetent to get 50 valid signatures".
"I'm incompetent to know the first thing about the district I want to represent.
"I'm incompetent to serve in congress
So vote for me. I'm the front runner for the Democrat nomination.
*Ooopsie ! OH ping*
If I live to be 100, I don't think I will ever see such a promising congressional candidate screw up so badly on such a simple task. Wilson's a freaking state senator, and he can't get 50 valid signatures from residents of the district? All he had to do was talk to a Steubenville union leader and get 500 signatures by the next day; even if 90% of them were illegal he'd still get the 50 he needed.
As I posted last week, Wilson can either run as a write-in in the RAT primary or as an independent in the general. If he runs as an independent, it will ensure a GOP victory in a district that gave President Bush 51%, since even if the Democrat primary winner drops out he'll still get like 10% from stupid voters due to the D next to his name. So Wilson will probably run as a write-in in the RAT primary. While winning a primary as a write-in is not impossible (especially with an easy name to spell and remember such as Charlie Wilson and with such lackluster opponents), Wilson will have to spend quite a bit of time and money on a nomination that everyone thought he had sewn up. All I know is, what looked like a 50-50 chance at a GOP pickup now looks like a 75-25 chance, since if either of the two nobodies running in the RAT primary wins, he'll lose in the general.
Oh, and wouldn't it be sweet if the incompetent Wilson forgets to tell the election board that he will be running as a write-in under the names Charles Wilson *and* Charlie Wilson and thus Charles Wilson finishes second, followed by Charlie Wilson? Wilson would sue saying that Charles Wilson and Charlie Wilson are one and the same, and the GOP would find some other guy named Charlie Wilson saying that he's the real Charlie Wilson, and even if Wilson ends up winning in court he'd be meat in the general election for being such an ass.
This is too good.
Now if only Bob Taft were to be removed from the political scene. (read my tagline)
"If I live to be 100, I don't think I will ever see such a promising congressional candidate screw up so badly on such a simple task."
Nobody remembers this now, but in 1994, Indiana state Auditor Ann Devore was a strong candidate for Congress. But she forgot to turn in the proper paperwork, even though her own office was in the same hallway as the Secretary of State's office.
But this comes very close.
Thanks to CF for bailing me out! :-)
I see Devore ran in the 2nd, that was a pretty brutal GOP primary they had in '94, David McIntosh barely emerging as the victor by 1%.
Good thing it isn't New Jersey where 48 and 50 are probably interchangeable or just close enough or where the people need to have a choice or some crap like that.
That is the 'Rat mantra. They are too out of the loop to know the dealing inside their own party to know about corruption. They are too incompetent to know what theya re supposed and not supposed to do.
The idea that you cannot replace a petition before the deadline bothers me. The Florida and NJ Scotus wouldn't stand for it. :)
I still suspect this district wants to elect a Dem in 2006. Whether that happens depends on how effective the remaining Dem candidates are.
This is terrific stuff. How can you possibly f--- up getting just 50 signatures????
Oh, they're total losers, nobodys. Unless Wilson gets the nod, it's a sure GOP pickup.
OK. We shall see.
The one guy LIED about being the same guy who was a former congressman from Michigan of the same name. He is not the same guy, though, as it turns out.
Ya, scrath him. But if the remaining two are both kooks, and/or total nothings, than Wilson has a shot running as a write in no?
The two Democrats who are running are absolute nobodies, and losers to boot. Check out Bob Carr's website:
And John Luchanstay doesn't even have a website.
My only fear is that they're such losers that Charlie Wilson may win the RAT nomination as a write-in, and it will go back to being a 50-50 race in November. But if Carr or Luchanstay win the nomination, the GOP nominee can start measuring curtains in the House of Representatives.
I beat you to the punch by seconds. Torie is quick. :)
You don't think the Dem party has any organizational effectiveness in this district? I remember the district now held by Issa in California. The Pubbie nominee won the nomination running a dirty campaign, very dirty, with lies galore, and Packard ran as a write in and won. When a party establishment unites, going write in is doable.
Granted we don't know if Wilson will run as a write in, in the primary. That I suspect is the big joker in the deck, at the moment.
One mistake does not necessarily lead to another. I doubt that it will.
Well, if their petition drive is any indication of how the write-in campaign would be organized, I would not bet on it making a difference. ;)
But seriously though, for the time-being I've moved this up to the most vulnerable Dem seat, for obvious reasons. If Wilson is DQed and can't get back on the ballot, it goes to Likely GOP, at least.
I do however think the most likely outcome is for Wilson to win a write-in effort. Even if that's the case I think OH-06 will now be at least a Toss Up at the end of the primary, and possibly Lean GOP.
Sensible enough. But remember this is Ohio.
That only works if they're a Democrat. ;-)
Me ? Cynical ? Perish the thought.
I thought the signatures were thrown out because the district line cuts across counties and he didn't realize that some people in his senate district aren't also in the 6th. They aren't bogus voters.
And Illinois GOP George Lyan.
The IL GOP establishment is still in love with George Lyan.
They are strongly pushing Ms Lyan-Toopinka for Governor while the honest candidates are splitting the votes of the GOP base that favors honesty.